Announcement

**Aryan** · 05-06-2009, 04:27 PM

Topic Approved.

**Devilpulsarian** · 05-06-2009, 04:33 PM

Shine among these...

especially for Pune roads..!

**MSJ** · 05-06-2009, 04:45 PM

Thanks for the quick approval Aryan.

It would also be nice if existing Shine or Aviator owners could share their experience with me, if they are using their bike for this type of long city commute.

**Thunder** · 05-06-2009, 04:49 PM

Aviator and shine though both belongs to the same manufacturer ---- both are entirely different Segments......

Aviator ---- Its a Scooter 100cc....Suitable for those who doesnt know to ride Gear bikes.....Suitable for Heavy Trafficated Areas since its gearless ....Luggage holding capacity....Everyone can ride in the family

Shine ------ Its a Bike 125cc.... Suitable for those office goears who want style and conmfort and yes Mileage ....Also suitable for Trafficated areas....cannot carry Luggages in it unless u have a Seperate Side Box or Tank Cover.....

It depends upon your choice .... but yes there is a soft corner for u on Aviator since u wanna travel more ---- it will be helpful for u to carry ur bag in it ...... and easy to ride.....

**MSJ** · 05-06-2009, 04:57 PM

I do understand that Shine and Aviator are 2 completely different categories of bikes. Just as well, they have different advantages.

I will not need to carry any luggage, just a shoulder bag. And I will be using the bike only for office commute, not as family vehicle.

The only reason I was thinking of Aviator is bcoz its an automatic. But the question is, since its a scooter, would it be uncomfortable for this type of long ride? The traffic in my route is not too heavy. I keep moving at 30-50 kph range. One way drive is around 50 minutes. So comfort in sitting posture, suspension, and avoidance of fatigue are of utmost importance to me.

**Devilpulsarian** · 05-06-2009, 05:05 PM

On a scooter you would feel more fatigue-d than on a bike...on a 27 km distance

Added to that, the fact that though aviator comes loaded with telescopic front shockups, theres a very limited distance which they can travel.

Add to that, the sluggishness (comparatively) of aviator would add to more fatigue

Add to that the yawning milege difrence between these two

I, own a dio and get paltry milege of 30-33kmpls..

If fortune favors you, you can expect a milege of 35+ on it
compared to shines 60+
Its almost double the ownership cost...!

If at all you are very serious about a scooter, than try the suzuki access
Its a better scooter in India...!

**MSJ** · 05-06-2009, 05:11 PM

I think you mis-read my post. I wrote that traffic is not too heavy.

I hear from friends that scooter can cause back/shoulder pains if used for long distance commuting. My experience with Dio is not good for long rides. Its painful. So I wanted opinions of xBHPians on Aviator. I dont mind riding a geared bike. But if both Shine and Aviator can provide equal amount of comfort, then I would prefer Aviator as its gearless.

It would be great if someone who is using Shine or Aviator currently for this type of long commute can share their experience with me.

**kushalwagh101** · 05-06-2009, 05:14 PM

honda activa

u can also look honda activa my activa gives 40 to 45 average mostly riding in mumbai traffic roads

...but it is old one the new activa comes with lot more average and other features ..... comparing avaitor and shine i say shine more average better comfort !!!

**akshaye11** · 05-06-2009, 05:21 PM

Sorry brother i miss understood .

then there should not be any doubt regarding it go for shine as it will give more average, feel better power then the aviator .

**undergroundrider** · 05-06-2009, 05:46 PM

i own a aviator too.. its mostly used by my dad.. its hastle free no doubt.. but then you tend to get bored on it verry soon.. it gives me a decent average of 45kmpl.. that to in bombay traffic.. but i would advice you to go for the shine.. cause no mopid or scooter can give you the feel and joy of a bike

**MSJ** · 05-06-2009, 06:02 PM

I will be taking test ride of both Shine and Aviator soon. But the problem is its difficult to judge long distance riding comfort during a 5 minute test drive.

Hence, I am awaiting for responses from owners of Shine or Aviator who use it for such long distance commute daily.

(To Akshay): No problem brother.

**shrestaz** · 05-06-2009, 09:32 PM

i would recommend that you go for shine
Even though shine is not much comfortable for long rides,but it is much much better that aviator or any other scooters
Also,being a bike, shine is much more fun than aviator
U know, playing with the gears,clutch, n performance
go for shine dude

**outworldly maniac** · 05-06-2009, 09:59 PM

i dont mean to confuse you but if u can stretch your budget a bit...... then acc to your requirements in which the priority being less fatigue and comfort level cannot be matched at all..... in terms of comfort .... unicorn is one of the best bikes!!! n also very smooth engine..... lasts years if u take proper care
and also it will be value for money
u will not regret
some may say u can try the suzuki gsx 150r also

rest if ur budget is limited and still wanna choose from both
i dont have the exp of aviator so i cannot comment
but these gearless are made acc to city requirements kept in mind and undoubtedly have good suspension ........ better than bikes in some cases i have seen........... but as u say,,, ,ur experience with dio is not good
then go for SHINE

**MSJ** · 05-06-2009, 11:32 PM

I know Unicorn is a really good bike. I have used Unicorn for some time. But it dint suit my height and weight. I am 5'6" and 60kg. Unicorn riding position is suitable for more taller guys. Also, for light weight people, the suspension is too firm. The ride is a little bouncy.

Hence I am looking for smaller bike. Aviator I believe is the best amongst the Scooters, and amongst the 100-125cc motorcylces, I narrowed down to Shine. Other suggestions for comfortable bikes in this category are welcome.

Announcement

Honda Shine or Honda Aviator

Honda Shine or Honda Aviator

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment