Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Always keep the chain well lubricated.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What is "Power", what is "Torque"..??

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by bhasma View Post
    No offence meant but someone bunked his English classes.

    lol!! its ok re....chillax...

    sigpic

    Respect the nature and it will respect you back.....

    Cheers!!!!
    Dinesh


    First Ride to Malshej Ghats.....

    Comment


    • #17
      Torque - Power - RPM

      Guys the more I do research in this area the more confused I get. I have a list of queries here..I am expecting atleast this forum might clear my mind.

      Please read the below sentences which I have gathered from the web
      Torque is a measure of the twisting force an engine can generate .

      A harley might Produce High torque at Low RPMs whereas an R6 will produce High Torque at High RPMs. But the max RPM of a harley will be less than that of an R6.

      Every time we change up a gear, we are trading torque for rpm.-- Didnt understand this.

      Takin the above info into consideration. Can anyone please explain what is the relation between Torque RPM Power.?
      Also TECHNICALLY whats the diff between a high revving and low revving bike ??
      Thanks in advance
      With Great Torque comes Great Responsibility !!

      Comment


      • #18
        Similar threads merged.
        (Been There Done That) x 3.25

        Comment


        • #19
          my 2 cents.. or 4..

          First of all, I think this is an excellent topic to discuss for motorcycle enthusiasts. I think its very important to know these things as they are very basic and it makes a healthy "biker's discussion".

          What I am going to write here is purely my understanding on the subject. Any remarks/criticism is most welcome. I am not going into the units and technical information on any of the following terms, I'll probably go into it as the discussion progresses. This is how I'd put it to a layman.

          Power: Everything starts from the engine. Power is purely a parameter of the engine. It depends on the engine size(capacity), tuning(discuss later), Compression ratio, 'bore X stroke' etc. But whatever the parameters, power depends purely on how the engine is built. By the definition of power, it is the energy put out by the engine (as a result of combustion of fuel) per unit time.

          This was the easy part.

          Torque: To understand torque, you need to understand the concept of power applied in an angular fashion(discussed earlier). But when it comes to motorcyles, the power output of the engine or the resultant torque doesn't directly run the motorcycle. Here is where gears play a very important role. A good understanding of gear ratios will put all your doubts to rest. Consider the following picture:



          Lets say one of them is the input gear (driven by the engine directly), one of them is the output gear (driving the motorcycle). (No. of teeth in output gear / No. of teeth in input gear) = Gear Ratio = (Torque output / Torque input).

          For different gears (1st, 2nd, 3rd etc), the gear ratios are different, and hence the torque output is different. Therefore, your vehicle's behavior is different.

          It is practically impossible to be able to estimate a bike's performance purely by peak-power and peak-torque figures(provided on the spec sheet), unless it is known to have a more-or-less "linear torque curve".

          Enough for now..

          Thoughts?
          Last edited by epic.fail.engineer; 02-05-2012, 03:17 PM.
          Education is an admirable thing, but it is well to remember from time to time that nothing that is worth knowing can be taught. - Oscar Wilde

          A question that sometimes drives me hazy: am I or are the others crazy? - Albert Einstein

          A man who carries a cat by the tail learns something he can learn in no other way. - Mark Twain

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by ROCKRZ View Post
            I HEARD THIS ONE SOMEWHERE SO I AM PUTTING IT HERE
            TORQUE IS LIKE
            HOW HARD U CAN HIT A WALL


            AND POWER IS LIKE
            HOW FAST U CAN DRAG IT ALONG WITH U

            Summed it up sweetly.



            Comment


            • #21
              Torque is just "force" applied on anything. If I push a train, I'm applying some torque, even though the train might not move even 1mm.

              Power is force combined with the movement caused due to that force.

              So, at zero movement, power will always be zero, while torque may not be theoritically.


              For example, 5 NM @ 2000 rpm makes lesser speed and drive than 5 NM @ 14,000 rpm. Because the engine itself is rotating higher. At any point of time, more rotations mean more speed, other factors assumed constant.
              ---
              Brotherhood, Rules, Freedom. Xbhp.
              Indian riding = Alertness, Anticipation and Adjustment.

              Comment


              • #22
                @samrath
                but an engine which produces 5NM torque @ 2k rpm will be at a very high speed @14k RPPM when compared to the engine producing 5NM at 14k rpm... am i right?
                Apache 180

                Comment


                • #23
                  lol AFAIK more torque means more pulling power i.e R15(15NM) with pillon is slower then p220(19NM) with pillion and thunderbird(~28NM) with 3people pulls faster then the other two bikes....

                  and bhp may be top speed dont knw exactly....
                  correct me if im wrong dont ROFL..

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    if we go according to that formula then bike with 13nm torque like p150 produce around 22bhp @ 9krpm which doesn'nt make any sense..

                    someone please explain this..
                    p220 specs..
                    MAX TORQUE=19.12@7000rpm
                    MAX POWER=21.04@8500rpm

                    so if we calculate bhp using tat formula then p220 should hav 25.22bhp...so please explain...
                    Last edited by abhiiceman; 02-06-2012, 10:14 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by saipranav View Post
                      @samrath
                      but an engine which produces 5NM torque @ 2k rpm will be at a very high speed @14k RPPM when compared to the engine producing 5NM at 14k rpm... am i right?
                      To explain my last post, I was assuming that the SAME engine makes 5 NM @ 2000 as well as 5 NM @ 14000 rpm too. (It is very much possible)

                      In that case, its speed at 14000 rpm would be more than at 2000 rpm (EVEN THOUGH TORQUE IS SAME). This is the concept of "Power". Its associated with work done/ movement caused.

                      Am I clear?

                      Originally posted by abhiiceman View Post
                      lol AFAIK more torque means more pulling power i.e R15(15NM) with pillon is slower then p220(19NM) with pillion and thunderbird(~28NM) with 3people pulls faster then the other two bikes....
                      and bhp may be top speed dont knw exactly....
                      correct me if im wrong dont ROFL..
                      You're right about torque. No matter what bike you have, you should be near the max torque spot rpm too. I mean, an R15 @ 7000 rpm is still better than P220 @ 3000 rpm.

                      Max Power figure affects both acceleration and top speed. Gearing also affects both these figures.

                      So, when you rev your bike near its redline, you experience a push of power, that translates to good acceleration or high top speed. But the "push" is there...

                      Originally posted by abhiiceman View Post
                      if we go according to that formula then bike with 13nm torque like p150 produce around 22bhp @ 9krpm which doesn'nt make any sense..

                      someone please explain this..
                      p220 specs..
                      MAX TORQUE=19.12@7000rpm
                      MAX POWER=21.04@8500rpm

                      so if we calculate bhp using tat formula then p220 should hav 25.22bhp...so please explain...
                      That formula? Ok, torque changes according to rpm, ok?

                      In other words, the P150's example considered, 13 NM torque is produced at around 6000 rpm ONLY, not beyond that. Beyond that, while rpm keeps increasing, but torque keeps decreasing slowly.

                      So, you can't use 13 NM (@ 6000 rpm) figure for something measured at 8000 rpm ie power. For that you'll need torque @ 8000 rpm which will be lower than 13 NM.

                      Power = (Torque at "N" rpm) X ("N" rpm). N can be any rpm the engine travels at...

                      So as you rev beyond 6000, when torque is dropping down slowly and rpm is getting higher, the maximum power is produced at around 8000 rpm (can differ for other engines). Beyond 8000 rpm, the torque drops to such a level that increasing rpm can't make more power.

                      So, when you drag race, you rev it a bit beyond max power spot and then shift the gear up, and pass through the same max power zone again and shift up and so on....

                      See a torque and power figure to understand power, torque and rpm:



                      The torque is the yellow line that is maximum at 3400 rpm.. Then it starts decreasing as rpm keeps increasing... RPM X Torque curve is made which tops at 4800 rpm. This is the power.
                      Last edited by Samarth 619; 02-06-2012, 11:39 PM.
                      ---
                      Brotherhood, Rules, Freedom. Xbhp.
                      Indian riding = Alertness, Anticipation and Adjustment.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Originally posted by Samarth 619 View Post
                        To explain my last post, I was assuming that the SAME engine makes 5 NM @ 2000 as well as 5 NM @ 14000 rpm too. (It is very much possible)

                        In that case, its speed at 14000 rpm would be more than at 2000 rpm (EVEN THOUGH TORQUE IS SAME). This is the concept of "Power". Its associated with work done/ movement caused.

                        Am I clear?


                        You're right about torque. No matter what bike you have, you should be near the max torque spot rpm too. I mean, an R15 @ 7000 rpm is still better than P220 @ 3000 rpm.

                        Max Power figure affects both acceleration and top speed. Gearing also affects both these figures.

                        So, when you rev your bike near its redline, you experience a push of power, that translates to good acceleration or high top speed. But the "push" is there...



                        That formula? Ok, torque changes according to rpm, ok?

                        In other words, the P150's example considered, 13 NM torque is produced at around 6000 rpm ONLY, not beyond that. Beyond that, while rpm keeps increasing, but torque keeps decreasing slowly.

                        So, you can't use 13 NM (@ 6000 rpm) figure for something measured at 8000 rpm ie power. For that you'll need torque @ 8000 rpm which will be lower than 13 NM.

                        Power = (Torque at "N" rpm) X ("N" rpm). N can be any rpm the engine travels at...

                        So as you rev beyond 6000, when torque is dropping down slowly and rpm is getting higher, the maximum power is produced at around 8000 rpm (can differ for other engines). Beyond 8000 rpm, the torque drops to such a level that increasing rpm can't make more power.

                        So, when you drag race, you rev it a bit beyond max power spot and then shift the gear up, and pass through the same max power zone again and shift up and so on....

                        See a torque and power figure to understand power, torque and rpm:



                        The torque is the yellow line that is maximum at 3400 rpm.. Then it starts decreasing as rpm keeps increasing... RPM X Torque curve is made which tops at 4800 rpm. This is the power.
                        i was talking abt that power=(torque*current rpm)/5252...

                        so torque drops after some particular rpm depending on the vehicle,but still why people shift gears at redline during DRAG?..

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Originally posted by abhiiceman View Post
                          i was talking abt that power=(torque*current rpm)/5252...
                          so torque drops after some particular rpm depending on the vehicle,but still why people shift gears at redline during DRAG?..
                          Yes I understood the formula after some thinking & replied accordingly.

                          Red lining is not always a measuring point for shifting in drags. Passing through the "Maximum Power" spot while revving is necessary.

                          Example: You rev your P220 upto 9500 rpm and then shift. When you shift your rpm drops to 8000. Then you rev it upto 9500 and shift into 3rd and rpm drops to 8000 again. By this process, you pass through the max power spot (8500 rpm) multiple times and gain maximum drag.

                          Consider a different scenario: You're racing on a circuit and revving around 9000 rpm, and there's a corner closing ahead where before turning, you have to downshift for sure.
                          You have 2 choices:
                          1. keep revving in the same gear beyond 9500 rpm upto 10500 rpm or so and then downshift as corner approaches,
                          2. shift up at 9500 rpm and immediately, shift down again as corner is too close now,

                          What will you choose?

                          Obviously here, the 1st choice (to keep revving until we approach the corner and then downshift) is better as shifting takes up valuable time and power.

                          Its called "overrun". That's why some Supersports 600's have their rev limiter very high up even when they make maximum power @ 14 krpm.
                          For example, rev limiters of the 2007 ZX 6R (16.5 krpm) and 2007 YZF R6 (17 krpm approx).
                          ---
                          Brotherhood, Rules, Freedom. Xbhp.
                          Indian riding = Alertness, Anticipation and Adjustment.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            True that.

                            Consider a scenario of a gradient, say, going up a treacherously inclined slope. You tend to down shift to prevent your engine from stalling. You go for a smaller gear ratio which provides more torque (pulling force) and less power.

                            The graph in the post above is for a single gear. On a very treacherous uphill, your best chance to overcome it is @3800 rpm in the first gear. If the engine stalls at that, there is no way you can go past that incline.

                            Power band funda was beautifully explained in the previous post, why racers on a straight road go for gear shift just above max power rpm.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              As simple as i understand, torque is something that helps you to get from zero to running and power is something that helps to maintain that running.
                              sigpic

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                The simplest definition that I have come across and that has made me understand is this.

                                The real power of the engine is actually the Torque. By power I mean the pulling power. How quickly this power is put to road is BHP.

                                Trucks have huge Torque but low BHP. Super Bikes have lower torques (They dont need much) but very high BHPs.
                                Rachit K Dogra

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X