Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Clean visor equals clear vision.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Why do FI Motorcycles need to be filled as soon as they hit reserve?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Why do FI Motorcycles need to be filled as soon as they hit reserve?

    I've been haunted with this thought as why FI motorcycles requires to be topped up as soon as they hit the reserve limit?

    I can quite understand the pump pulls the fuel & supplies it to the injector; since it doesn't work on Gravity basis, as long as the electronic/electric pump is able to pull the fuel, it should only matter if the fuel is available or not right? So why a restriction like this?

    Now comparing this with a modern day car, I've personally experienced in my FI WagonR go complete empty on the fuel tank and still was able to fill in a litre of petrol from the can & then the car starts normally.

    I'm confused as why FI equipped motorcycles require a minimum capacity of fuel to be available in reserve & why not the tank go empty? BTW, has anyone experienced what happens when a FI motorcycle goes empty & then refilled? Can someone help me understand pls? Tks.
    Last edited by aargee; 09-07-2010, 06:43 PM.
    Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
    Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
    ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

  • #2
    Topic approved.
    (Been There Done That) x 3.25

    Comment


    • #3
      I dont know for sure wether it is correct, but they say that if the fuel supply is less to the FI pump it gets heated up and burns and that leads to costly issue of replacing the pump, thats what I heard.. But I have rode a R15 till the empty tank but did not face any issue I just filled it up and it is running normally!
      All the wise men of the world are called wise only after they spoke their mind, so dont keep the ideas to yourselves!

      Comment


      • #4


        I have seen my fren'z RTR Fi many times, and it always runs in reserve. So far there is no problem with his bike or the Fi system. He is getting an average of 40+ and the ride is 18k on odo.

        This is the first time I am hearing this type of a problem. I will ask my friend to talk about this at the ASS.

        Would be nice if you could throw some light on how and where you heard about this?
        /// Trying to be there, dreaming to do that ! \\\

        Prabhakar

        Comment


        • #5
          Google & xBhp gives...


          Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
          Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
          ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by aargee View Post
            I've been haunted with this thought as why FI motorcycles requires to be topped up as soon as they hit the reserve limit?

            I can quite understand the pump pulls the fuel & supplies it to the injector; since it doesn't work on Gravity basis, as long as the electronic/electric pump is able to pull the fuel, it should only matter if the fuel is available or not right? So why a restriction like this?

            Now comparing this with a modern day car, I've personally experienced in my FI WagonR go complete empty on the fuel tank and still was able to fill in a litre of petrol from the can & then the car starts normally.

            I'm confused as why FI equipped motorcycles require a minimum capacity of fuel to be available in reserve & why not the tank go empty? BTW, has anyone experienced what happens when a FI motorcycle goes empty & then refilled? Can someone help me understand pls? Tks.
            One clarification: In most FI systems, pumps no longer 'pull' fuel from a tank but in fact 'push' fuel from inside the tank itself.

            Two reasons for maintaining a certain minimum fuel level .

            1. The bikes are fueled by submersible pumps that are run by small, high-torque motors. The fuel they are immersed in acts as a heat sink and keeps the motor and pump body cool.

            2. Remaining immersed under fuel is important for the pump to be able to generate sufficient fuel pressure in the fuel line to keep the engine running.

            But why don't the same rules apply to cars?

            A bike has another degree of freedom in movement i.e. around its rolling
            axis. Even if the fuel level is sufficient with the bike upright, it might fall below the minimum when the bike tilts. Cars don't tilt all that way.

            Also bikes probably have pumps that are not self-priming. So if the inlet to the pump gets exposed to air while the pump is 'on', it might result in a vapor lock/air lock inside the pump and even filling up fuel will not help in getting the pump back to building up fuel pressure. And since bikes can 'jump' about a lot while in motion, a low fuel level could momentarily make the fuel level go below the inlet, allow air to enter and so stop further fuel flow to the engine.
            I don't let my motorcycles interfere with my motorcycling...

            Join xBhp On

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
              One clarification: In most FI systems, pumps no longer 'pull' fuel from a tank but in fact 'push' fuel from inside the tank itself.

              Two reasons for maintaining a certain minimum fuel level .

              1. The bikes are fueled by submersible pumps that are run by small, high-torque motors. The fuel they are immersed in acts as a heat sink and keeps the motor and pump body cool.

              2. Remaining immersed under fuel is important for the pump to be able to generate sufficient fuel pressure in the fuel line to keep the engine running.

              But why don't the same rules apply to cars?

              A bike has another degree of freedom in movement i.e. around its rolling
              axis. Even if the fuel level is sufficient with the bike upright, it might fall below the minimum when the bike tilts. Cars don't tilt all that way.

              Also bikes probably have pumps that are not self-priming. So if the inlet to the pump gets exposed to air while the pump is 'on', it might result in a vapor lock/air lock inside the pump and even filling up fuel will not help in getting the pump back to building up fuel pressure. And since bikes can 'jump' about a lot while in motion, a low fuel level could momentarily make the fuel level go below the inlet, allow air to enter and so stop further fuel flow to the engine.

              can somebody explain more technically the issue of motorcycle fuel pumps
              Mountain biking on impulse with my wife and our bike goes down in water

              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/2...own-water.html

              my saddle sore 1600k is official - the story

              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/2...ddle-sore.html

              my space
              www.harikesh.com

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                1. The bikes are fueled by submersible pumps that are run by small, high-torque motors. The fuel they are immersed in acts as a heat sink and keeps the motor and pump body cool.
                Sir just a small doubt. But doesnt such immersion of the fuel pump in the fuel be dangerous?? As the fuel pump runs on electricity & if even a small spark occurs then it can result in the ignition of the fuel around it??
                Please throw some light on it.
                NOT BEEN THERE NOT DONE THAT

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by madhav krishna View Post
                  Sir just a small doubt. But doesnt such immersion of the fuel pump in the fuel be dangerous?? As the fuel pump runs on electricity & if even a small spark occurs then it can result in the ignition of the fuel around it??
                  Please throw some light on it.
                  Yes Madhav, motors and electricals can spark and do so in the case of these pumps too. But the fact that you need the trio of fuel, heat and oxygen to start a fire comes to the rescue here. With the pump fully immersed in the fuel, there's no air to start combustion. So the fuel doesn't catch fire. Thats also probably one of the reasons why it is important to keep a minimum fuel level in the tank. Though as a redundant safety measure, the pump's electric supply gets cut off if any of the conditions like heating of the pump, drop in outlet pressure indicating low level at inlet, sudden impact (inertia switches) and roll-over of the bike. I cannot vouch for the fact that all this is a part of the FI bikes being manufactured here but that's pretty much the norm for FI engined vehicles.
                  I don't let my motorcycles interfere with my motorcycling...

                  Join xBhp On

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                    Also bikes probably have pumps that are not self-priming. So if the inlet to the pump gets exposed to air while the pump is 'on', it might result in a vapor lock/air lock inside the pump and even filling up fuel will not help in getting the pump back to building up fuel pressure. And since bikes can 'jump' about a lot while in motion, a low fuel level could momentarily make the fuel level go below the inlet, allow air to enter and so stop further fuel flow to the engine.
                    Not sure about this what you said. I am not a tech guy but as far as I know vapor lock/air lock is taken care by an external pump. So air shoudn't enter your engine?? not only in Fi engines but it was the same even in my old ZMA..Isn't that right
                    Last edited by justyhere; 09-07-2010, 11:12 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Thanks for the answers OF Sir; it took a while & I'd to read it multiple times to understand & hence the delay in response.

                      Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                      One clarification: In most FI systems, pumps no longer 'pull' fuel from a tank but in fact 'push' fuel from inside the tank itself.
                      This is news to me as I was always under the impression that fuel is always being pushed.

                      Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                      1. The bikes are fueled by submersible pumps that are run by small, high-torque motors. The fuel they are immersed in acts as a heat sink and keeps the motor and pump body cool.

                      2. Remaining immersed under fuel is important for the pump to be able to generate sufficient fuel pressure in the fuel line to keep the engine running.
                      And from your replies, I can think of one more reason - avoid fire being immersed.

                      Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                      Also bikes probably have pumps that are not self-priming.
                      Couldn't get this point OF Sir; can you help me understand pls?

                      Originally posted by Old Fox View Post
                      So if the inlet to the pump gets exposed to air while the pump is 'on'...
                      Again, I couldn't think in this direction. I was always thinking as the fuel is being pushed. Appreciate to throw some pointers on air inlet tube.

                      OF Sir - from your post what I understood is that, the FI pump in motorcycle is something like a submersible water pump that is sunk in water & pushes the water up to the over head tank. If the water dries up the motor burns. This is exactly what I can relate. Pls guide if my understanding is incorrect.

                      On the other hand, I couldn't help thinking, why the manufacturers could not adopt a fuel pull motor technology like in the car so that the reserve also could be used?

                      Few sources from net on FI
                      1. Harley-Davidson Motorcycle Fuel Injection Explained
                      2. How Electronic Fuel Injection (EFI) Works - Motorcycle Cruiser Magazine
                      Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
                      Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
                      ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        hmmmm
                        i am riding my zmr in reserve from months ....but touch-wood i have not faced any problem till now

                        by the way
                        if i fill more petrol i would end up riding more & again bring it to reserve on the same day
                        Just Me And Her [ZMR]

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Reviving the thread to post addition info that I came across - Jbabs's Fuel Injection Page
                          Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
                          Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
                          ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            in the 1st link i.e. EFI in harleys, there is another link that leads to a table EFI terminology
                            in that, they have mentioned a senor by the acronym BAS(bank angle sensor). As per my understanding, this thing safeguards the FI against entry of air by switching off the engine whenever it exceeds a certain bank angle.
                            My question is can't things like his be developed and incorporated in to desi FI bikes?

                            edit: but then again, if the bike goes over a bump(highly probable on Indian roads) then the BAS won't be able to do anything at all
                            btw, thanks for the links

                            edit 2:another thought- why don't the FI manufacturers provide an indicator in the bike's console for the 3L level? Even after that if the owners show up with blown up injectors wanting to claim warranty, then the company will atleast have a strong point for defending.
                            Last edited by gautam_k; 09-19-2010, 06:32 PM. Reason: addition to the text
                            If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough - Albert Einstein

                            I think i know less than what you think i know.

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X