Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Look further to stay alive.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

    Hi All Fellow Bikers ,

    I have been very fascinated by the whole electric cars revolution in recent years and after seeing two wheelers like Tork T6X (even though its not on road yet) and Ather 450 I find the idea of using electric bikes very appealing especially for day to day office commute. Also we have seen companies like Harley releasing LiveWire and Bajaj is talking about Urbanite electric range of two wheelers.

    But I always think that it won't be my "main" bike as in the only bike I would keep, I would have an electric bike for day to day use but weekends I would like something that is traditional bike like what we have now.

    That got me wondering what about other bikers ? Would you consider an electric RE Interceptor or electric KTM Duke or any of your bikes that you like in electric version as your main bike or only bike to use ?

    Regards,
    Mohan

  • #2
    Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

    Thread approved.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

      Sure, I'm all up for saving the environment.

      I ride a 2014 R15 V2 and wouldn't mind it in full electric avatar as long as I get the same acceleration and decent range for daily office commute.
      I would miss changing the gears on the ultra slick gearbox and will have to ride it like a gearless scooter, but as long as I get similar power and acceleration out of it, I am willing to give it a go.
      Currently the main issue with e-vehicles is the battery replacement every 4-5 years (even soon depending on the usage). The more advanced the battery, the more expensive it would be to replace. So as long as the battery replacement cost is equal to my 5 year service bill of petrol powered bike and it satisfies all the above conditions, I would gladly ride a e R15 to office everyday.
      I would like to thank my legs for supporting me, my arms for being always by my side and my fingers; I could always count on them.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

        Theoretically -

        - Hub Drive with regen braking
        - Low to nil driveline vibrations
        - Insane torque from low down rpms
        - Simulated and programmable Shift points
        - Switchable Twin Hub drive for ADV variants
        - Zero Tailpipe Emissions
        - Quick Charge ability
        - Battery housing as tensile frame - lowered CG and weight
        - Easier integration of Multi-mode TC and ABS
        - Lower maintenance requirements
        - Lower consumables
        - Battery leasing programmes - Swap In/Out


        Why NOT? I'd Love it!
        Last edited by roy_libran; 02-04-2019, 03:01 PM.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

          No, because for the time being, "electric" really just means "coal-powered but since you can't see the pollution we can pretend it's clean", and because I ride an expedition bike, and value the ability to not spend an hour or more at each refuelling plus electric charging stations can be hard to find out in the mountains.

          Electric is fine if you never go anywhere farther than your local market on your bike, and in that respect electric bikes might be a good choice for the "Mango Man" riders, but this is a motorcycle enthusiast forum, and we aspire to do more than just commute to work on our bikes; for the enthusiast, an electric bike is still no more than an impractical curiosity, and is likely to stay that way for at least another 5-7 years at best, and unless someone rewrites the laws of thermodynamics electric bikes are always going to be inferior to petrol power.
          ATGATT: All The Gear, All The Time!

          Current bike: Yamaha XT1200Z Super Tenere

          Put the phone away, put your helmet on, and ride!

          Scooters are like fat girls: fun to ride, but embarrassing if your friends see you with one.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

            Originally posted by The Mountain View Post
            No, because for the time being, "electric" really just means "coal-powered but since you can't see the pollution we can pretend it's clean", and because I ride an expedition bike, and value the ability to not spend an hour or more at each refuelling plus electric charging stations can be hard to find out in the mountains.

            Electric is fine if you never go anywhere farther than your local market on your bike, and in that respect electric bikes might be a good choice for the "Mango Man" riders, but this is a motorcycle enthusiast forum, and we aspire to do more than just commute to work on our bikes; for the enthusiast, an electric bike is still no more than an impractical curiosity, and is likely to stay that way for at least another 5-7 years at best, and unless someone rewrites the laws of thermodynamics electric bikes are always going to be inferior to petrol power.
            I can agree that electric bikes are not exactly eco-friendly when you consider how they're being charged as majority of the power source is from coal but countries like Germany are committing to become 100% renewable energy by 2030 and also even in India good initiatives have been taken.

            Also by the time electric technology becomes mainstream and trickles down to small bike manufacturers I think there will be a better battery technology and also better charging capabilities and probably all petrol stations will have charging (very long shot but eventually).

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

              Originally posted by Dandamudi Mohan Krishna View Post
              I can agree that electric bikes are not exactly eco-friendly......
              Discussing the environmental aspect of E-vehicles will derail this thread, so we better not do that please.
              But, do consider that with e-vehicles:
              1. it is simpler to control the air pollution at the source of electricity production, than to plug millions of tail pipes,
              and,
              2. the electricity generation can and does happen mostly in non-urban centres thereby taking the effluents away from cities, something that is impossible to achieve in cities if millions of fuel powered vehicles are plying daily,
              but,
              3. there is the additional aspect of safely disposing of the consumed batteries that is still a huge area of concern.

              Let's not get into this convoluted debate.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

                Like Roy bro commented above, pollution at Power generation can be controlled well and efficiently than on the road. Case on point, people like to remove the catcon and many don't even bother with the proper combustion setting based on pollution tests. Punching holes in exhaust and removing the catcon and other shit inside it is a commonplace practice by people these days.

                In light of such conditions, electric bikes make sense. Since some people mention that these are for commuter only and not for touring and long distance, it can be helpful in curbing the pollution in the cities as most people use bikes/scoots to commute.

                Next up, the problem of long distance can be solved by battery leasing programs, with easy to swap technology. And given we have enough batteries on the system so that one can simply head over to petrol pump/gas station and simply swap the battery for a charged one for a fee. Another thing to consider is that such long distance and touring bikes should have 2-3 such batteries. But still, for adventure tourers to have all electric power train would be a tough thing like the mountain says.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

                  Originally posted by Zapps View Post
                  Next up, the problem of long distance can be solved by battery leasing programs, with easy to swap technology. And given we have enough batteries on the system so that one can simply head over to petrol pump/gas station and simply swap the battery for a charged one for a fee. Another thing to consider is that such long distance and touring bikes should have 2-3 such batteries. But still, for adventure tourers to have all electric power train would be a tough thing like the mountain says.
                  I understand but imagine there's a perfect world where electric bikes are just as capable and usable as normal bike would you consider it over normal bike as your "main" bike or it would be just a office goer/grocery getter ?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

                    Originally posted by Dandamudi Mohan Krishna View Post
                    Hi All Fellow Bikers ,

                    I have been very fascinated by the whole electric cars revolution in recent years and after seeing two wheelers like Tork T6X (even though its not on road yet) and Ather 450 I find the idea of using electric bikes very appealing especially for day to day office commute. Also we have seen companies like Harley releasing LiveWire and Bajaj is talking about Urbanite electric range of two wheelers.

                    But I always think that it won't be my "main" bike as in the only bike I would keep, I would have an electric bike for day to day use but weekends I would like something that is traditional bike like what we have now.

                    That got me wondering what about other bikers ? Would you consider an electric RE Interceptor or electric KTM Duke or any of your bikes that you like in electric version as your main bike or only bike to use ?

                    Regards,
                    Mohan
                    Agreed that electric bike are eco friendly and helps in reducing pollution but there are still many drawbacks too. It can prove more expensive than normal petrol bikes because of short batteries life and so the durability is less as compared to petrol bike. So I'd rather prefer petrol bike.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Would you consider an electric RE or KTM or any brand that you like as your main bike ?

                      Originally posted by Dandamudi Mohan Krishna View Post
                      I understand but imagine there's a perfect world where electric bikes are just as capable and usable as normal bike would you consider it over normal bike as your "main" bike or it would be just a office goer/grocery getter ?
                      Ofcoz, why not. But the cons I have mentioned have to be addressed to make it suitable for long tours.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        In the fast-paced world of gaming, the demand for powerful, portable machines has grown exponentially. Enter gaming laptops, the go-to choice for gamers who want the freedom to play their favorite titles without being tied down to a desktop setup. https://achievegaming.com/

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X