Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Tubeless tyres are better than tubed ones.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Michelin SIRAC - compensating loss in torque by using bigger sprocket ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Michelin SIRAC - compensating loss in torque by using bigger sprocket ?

    I need to change the tires on my Pulsar 220 dtsi in sometime now .. And i definitely want to go in for the Michelin SIRAC 120/90 -17. The thing is , i dont want the loss in acceleration .. So i was wondering , By installing the 220 fi's rear sprocket ( 37t ), will it nullify the loss in torque caused by the higher profile tire ??
    btw , P220 dtsi's rear sprocket is 36t.

    does this Sound like a plan that will work ???
    WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
    Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

    DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
    sigpic
    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

  • #2
    Query Approved
    Join xBhp On



    My photography page: Gourab Das Photography

    Comment


    • #3
      ^^ can you get a measurement of the OD ( overall diameter) of both tyres for an idea??


      My offerings to the gods of speed -

      - KTM Duke 200
      - Yamaha RXZ 5 speed


      Comment


      • #4
        120/80 to 120/90 will raise height by 12mm, if the new tyre's rim area is same as old one's. If it is not the same, then read on...

        Ashwin, it is not confirmed that tyre change WILL result in re gearing. Yes, it happens, but not always. For example, People installing FZ's 140/60 on their Pulsar 220s don't feel any change in gearing.

        Reason is that the wider tyre was meant for wider rim of FZ, but on narrow rim of P220, it gets squeezed and gives greater height (Rubber expands and contracts depending on the rim). Hence, 140/60 gives almost the same ride height as P220's 120/80, due to rim difference.

        So, my suggestion is that you notice speeds now, in 5th gear, at different rpm's like:

        3 krpm: 50 kmph
        4 krpm: 64 kmph
        6 krpm: xx kmph
        8 krpm: xxx kmph

        And then go for the tyre change first. Then tell me what speeds show up at these rpm's. Then we can decide what gearing to use exactly through precise calculations.

        I'll be keeping a watch on this thread...

        NOTE: Even P200's 38 teeth fits your bike. P180 UG4's 39 teeth might fit. Karizma's 40 teeth will also fit but that might overkill.
        ---
        Brotherhood, Rules, Freedom. Xbhp.
        Indian riding = Alertness, Anticipation and Adjustment.

        Comment


        • #5
          First change the rubber and see if you want to change the rubber in the first place!

          Changing over the 37T sprocket will not completely return back your acceleration. An approx calculation here, Sirac gives you +5 Kmph in each RPM, and using the 37T will give a drop of -3 Kmph in each RPM. So over all you will still be a bit taller geared!

          That being said, keep the Sirac and ride for about 1K kms and then decide if you want to up the acceleration!
          _________________________
          LoneWolfRides©

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by jd666 View Post
            ^^ can you get a measurement of the OD ( overall diameter) of both tyres for an idea??
            yup here is the measurement -
            rim dia - 17inch = 431.8mm
            total dia with 120/80 (stock tire)= 431.8+96 = 527.8mm
            total dia with 120/90 (michelin sirac) = 431.8+108 = 539.8mm

            Originally posted by Samarth 619 View Post
            120/80 to 120/90 will raise height by 12mm, if the new tyre's rim area is same as old one's. If it is not the same, then read on...

            Ashwin, it is not confirmed that tyre change WILL result in re gearing. Yes, it happens, but not always. For example, People installing FZ's 140/60 on their Pulsar 220s don't feel any change in gearing.

            Reason is that the wider tyre was meant for wider rim of FZ, but on narrow rim of P220, it gets squeezed and gives greater height (Rubber expands and contracts depending on the rim). Hence, 140/60 gives almost the same ride height as P220's 120/80, due to rim difference.

            So, my suggestion is that you notice speeds now, in 5th gear, at different rpm's like:

            3 krpm: 50 kmph
            4 krpm: 64 kmph
            6 krpm: xx kmph
            8 krpm: xxx kmph

            And then go for the tyre change first. Then tell me what speeds show up at these rpm's. Then we can decide what gearing to use exactly through precise calculations.

            I'll be keeping a watch on this thread...

            NOTE: Even P200's 38 teeth fits your bike. P180 UG4's 39 teeth might fit. Karizma's 40 teeth will also fit but that might overkill.
            ill be keeping the stock rim .. which is why Im looking at 120 section tires because its optimum for the 220 rim ..
            and just for your information , on stock tire here are the speeds/rpm values on 5th gear:
            4k - 60 or 61 kmph
            6k - 90 kmph
            8k - around 120 ish


            Originally posted by Praful View Post
            First change the rubber and see if you want to change the rubber in the first place!

            Changing over the 37T sprocket will not completely return back your acceleration. An approx calculation here, Sirac gives you +5 Kmph in each RPM, and using the 37T will give a drop of -3 Kmph in each RPM. So over all you will still be a bit taller geared!

            That being said, keep the Sirac and ride for about 1K kms and then decide if you want to up the acceleration!
            Actually the fi sprocket will be fine .. A little tall gearing is always welcome ..

            ^@ all , thanks for all your input guys .. Will update this thread when i change over to SIRAC ..
            WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
            Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
            http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

            DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
            sigpic
            http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

            Comment


            • #7
              ill be keeping the stock rim .. which is why Im looking at 120 section tires because its optimum for the 220 rim ..
              and just for your information , on stock tire here are the speeds/rpm values on 5th gear:
              4k - 60 or 61 kmph
              6k - 90 kmph
              8k - around 120 ish
              You didn't get my point. I'm not saying anything about a rim change. What I meant is that, it is not necessary that the Sirac tyre is meant for the P220 rim. It may expand or contract more. Its rim area may or may not be same as your older tyre.

              Anyways, I suggest you get the tyre changed first. We'll do the calculations later.
              ---
              Brotherhood, Rules, Freedom. Xbhp.
              Indian riding = Alertness, Anticipation and Adjustment.

              Comment


              • #8
                Also consider that rubber will wear off with usage. And a bit tall gearing shouldn't really hamper much of your performance.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Pulley physics dude.. Higher the diameter, or larger the sprocket / wheel (whatever) Lesser the leverage.. Hence a marginal reduction in pick-up (Torque) But might help in top speeds which depends on sme other fctors of the new element

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Samarth 619 View Post
                    120/80 to 120/90 will raise height by 12mm, if the new tyre's rim area is same as old one's. If it is not the same, then read on...



                    Reason is that the wider tyre was meant for wider rim of FZ, but on narrow rim of P220, it gets squeezed and gives greater height (Rubber expands and contracts depending on the rim). Hence, 140/60 gives almost the same ride height as P220's 120/80, due to rim difference.



                    .

                    Rubber itself doesnt expand or contract here in this case.

                    The part of the FZ tyre which you are saying gives better ride when put on a pulsar's rim, was never meant/designed to take the load of a sidewall. You cannot simply slap on larger tyres on thinner rims and claim to gain sidewall height. In that case, the reverse should apply when skinnier tyres are put on wider rims
                    You can take the ride away from me but you cannot take the rider out of my soul.........

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      So in case i'm changng sprocket , should i change the entire set ( front , rear sprocket and chain ) ? The chain and sprocket set wore out prematurely for me and it has been changed @ 12k kms ( currently done 15k ).. Some people feel that the sprockets and chain should all be changed in one go ..

                      And how about using the Sirac as tubeless ?? I searched the tires thread but there is no one to clearly say "yes no prob" .. So can I use the sirac as a tubeless without absolutely any problems ??
                      What do you guys feel ??
                      WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
                      Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
                      http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

                      DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
                      sigpic
                      http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by ashwin208 View Post
                        So in case i'm changng sprocket , should i change the entire set ( front , rear sprocket and chain ) ? The chain and sprocket set wore out prematurely for me and it has been changed @ 12k kms ( currently done 15k ).. Some people feel that the sprockets and chain should all be changed in one go ..

                        And how about using the Sirac as tubeless ?? I searched the tires thread but there is no one to clearly say "yes no prob" .. So can I use the sirac as a tubeless without absolutely any problems ??
                        What do you guys feel ??
                        I know of at least 4 different P220s using Sirac as a tubeless tyre with absolutely no problem. Couple of the bikes have seen really harsh riding conditions while on tours and the tyres performed really well, just as they are expected to.
                        You can take the ride away from me but you cannot take the rider out of my soul.........

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Hi! guyz... I too run on Michellin Sirac 120/90-17 on my p180 ug3...

                          Can it be run tubeless? How do will we fill air?
                          Presence of MIND and self CONFIDENCE is the primary aspect You need to be on road, not what brand your riding gears are.
                          If you lack these two then DONT

                          Feel the pleasure of Ultimate Biking
                          __________________________________________

                          . . .
                          alwayzaLive . . .

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by motormania View Post
                            I know of at least 4 different P220s using Sirac as a tubeless tyre with absolutely no problem. Couple of the bikes have seen really harsh riding conditions while on tours and the tyres performed really well, just as they are expected to.
                            Yeah I also checked with Praful Tripathy and his sirac has been Leh tested as tubeless should be changing it sometime next week Ill keep you guys posted ..
                            WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
                            Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
                            http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

                            DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
                            sigpic
                            http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Even I have recently put Sirac as TL on my ZMR !!

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X