Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Accelerate quick but brake easy.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

city riding :- Apache or FZ or Something else?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • city riding :- Apache or FZ or Something else?

    I want to know which bike is good for driving in city in 150+ CC range.
    Please suggest a bike on following criteria.

    -Fuel Efficiency
    -Driving Confort
    -Handling on City Roads.

    Following things dont matter.
    -Top Speed, Power, Feel, Look etc etc

    I am considering one of these
    Apache 160 RTR or Apache 160 RTR FI or Yahama FZ-S , you can add to the list (Pulsar Fans, please excuse )

    Additional Details:-
    Height: 5'5''
    To be Used for:- Commute to office(approx 12km one way)
    Budget :- 70K(can pay more if there is a reason)
    First Time Bike User
    Please mention Milage of the Bike ur talking about for city riding (if u know)
    I have heard about (Sucking or Not) Apache tyres, please mention ur view points.

  • #2
    Topic Approved.
    :)

    Comment


    • #3
      you can also consider gs150r and unicorn... both are very good bikes to drive in city with good comfort and handling. you can expect a mileage of around 50 or more from both of these (this would also depend on your driving style). you should remove the fz from your list coz it fails miserably in the mileage department.

      Comment


      • #4
        My comments in bold. Seems like you have pretty much narrowed it down to 160 RTR FI.
        Originally posted by bhosleganesh View Post
        Please suggest a bike on following criteria.

        -Fuel Efficiency - (160 RTR FI by a whisker against 160 RTR)
        -Driving Confort - (FZ)
        -Handling on City Roads. - (All)

        Following things dont matter.
        -Top Speed, Power, Feel, Look etc etc
        (RTR wins here as FZ is a looker. Though FI gives a marginal extra power, hope it won't put you off )

        I am considering one of these
        Apache 160 RTR or Apache 160 RTR FI or Yahama FZ-S , you can add to the list (Pulsar Fans, please excuse



        Budget :- 70K(can pay more if there is a reason)
        (160 RTR FI with some extra money in Mumbai)

        Comment


        • #5
          I would suggest the Unicorn for you. And please stay away from the Suzuki GS150R. It has got too many issues.
          Your biking tells a lot about the person you are!

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by abhijeet080808 View Post
            I would suggest the Unicorn for you. And please stay away from the Suzuki GS150R. It has got too many issues.
            Whats the problem with Suzuki GS150R.

            Comment


            • #7
              Unicorn will serve you well in the city with the ample mix of power and mileage. GS150R has some issues detailed in the ownership threads. You might want to take a look there.

              If you want looks coupled with power, Hunk seems to be a choice as well as its the same Honda engine with different clothes.

              Both the bikes have fairly good seating position for comfort in the city rides.

              RTR160 does not have very favorable seating position for stop and go traffic conditions if you encounter that in your daily 12km ride. FZ might be a tad better here but dont have any personal experience on the FZ.

              Take a test ride and choose your steed!!

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by sanjukoli12 View Post
                Whats the problem with Suzuki GS150R.
                Basically rusting issues and fuel efficiency issues. Look over at the ownership thread.
                Your biking tells a lot about the person you are!

                Comment


                • #9
                  out of the bikes that you've mentioned,RTR 160fi makes sense...but GS150R and unicorn are good alternatives(getting a uni maybe a pain in the a** coz of the waiting period which has worsened due to the strike)
                  It all begins with a thumb-start -- Oh, wait, I forgot the kill-switch

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Go for the unicorn or GS150R. Test ride the bikes and see which one is more comfortable for you.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Well the FZ series and the RTR series are both very capable street fighters, within a city envoirnment. Not sure where you are from @bhosleganesh but in a cities like Pune/ Bangalore these two bikes can fly rings around pretty much any indian motorcycle on the street except the p220,Modded RXs or the RD 350 so if you re looking for an aggressive street fighter do nt look beyond these two in the 150 - 180 CC class. In fact the RTR 180 might actually smoke a modded RX and give a good run to the p220.

                      The Uni and the GS150 are good capable commuters also the Uni has delivrry issues from the company with long waiting periods and the GS150 has a few rusting issues as reported by owners on the it's ownership thread. Also there is not much that sets these two bikes apart from the whole bandwagon of Splendors, ambitions, glamours, platinas, calibers etc out there on the street. And then there is the HH Hunk which is a great package but it being so radical it s looks and stance is quite out of the ordinary and kinda appeals to very few people if you do like it's looks/image do consider it. Remeber there is a danger of it turning into a mechanical bull and scaring other cars in your basement. (Kidding )

                      And between the FZ and the RTR they both have their pros and cons that i kinda wanna do a comparo below:

                      When it comes to pure initial pick up the RTR wins hands down

                      Looks there nothing much between them both look like really mean aggressive machines well the FZ scores a lil over the RTR in the looks front.

                      Handling they both can stop and turn on a Dime

                      Refinement the FZ wins with it's cush ride and there are reports of vibrations from RTR owners. The RTR is the unrefined of the two but for some it's crudeness itself is the appeal.

                      The FZ has monoshock suspension and this makes the handling on the FZ really good and this bike looks and feels like a proper sprots bike.

                      The the sound of the RTR is supereb I absoulutely love the bassy engine note of this bike.

                      The FZ has a sweet spot in it's rev range that is 4.5 k - 6k and feels really powerful if ridden in this rev range, the RTR has usable power throut it's Rev range and has a better top end than the FZ.

                      My vote goes for the FZ but then I already own one and you re the one buying a bike so spend some time at both the showrooms give both the bikes a very good look in. Sit on em and see which suits you better and get your Ride. Test ride em of course but the test rides but you get at the showrooms you cant really base your decison on, if you can get a test ride on a friends bike on a real commute that would be great. Finally get the bike that you feel comfortable on as these two machines are awesome mobikes.
                      Last edited by yamahatrooper; 10-22-2009, 04:25 AM.
                      "I set out running but I take my time, a friend of the devil is a friend of mine. If I get home before day light, just might get some sleep tonight" - The Grateful Dead.

                      The Stable - 2009 Yamaha FZS (Baby Beast) & 2010 YAMAHA YZF R15 (Anjuna Sunset).

                      Wishlist - Kawasaki Ninja 250r, YAMAHA R6 and Bullet standard 500 with the CI engine and a handpainted Goa Chic helmet.

                      www.facebook.com/powerslave666

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        RTR Fi, it looks good delivers around 45 kmpl in the city little more performance than non Fi RTR and way more than the FZ when you compare the feel. Its more of a simple bike compared to Yamaha.
                        Never upgrade without getting your basics RIGHT.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          im from pune,

                          I have already taken ride of Apache from one friend.....it was lot better than pulser and others.
                          i will take ride of FZ, its just that not many people have FZs so i am searching some one who has it.

                          My whole decision is based on only two questions below and one test ride.

                          Is there tyre issue with RTR??

                          milage of FZ, is it atleast 40? Most of Owners(from Owners thread) have quoted it between 35-42.
                          Last edited by bhosleganesh; 10-22-2009, 06:41 PM.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by bhosleganesh View Post
                            Is there tyre issue with RTR??
                            The factory fitted srichakras aparently are nt that grippy ive read and heard.

                            Originally posted by bhosleganesh View Post
                            milage of FZ, is it atleast 40? Most of Owners(from Owners thread) have quoted it between 35-42.
                            Yeah right depending on the riding I ve got mileage ranging from 35 - 42. I would say on a mean average I get 40kmph on my FZs
                            "I set out running but I take my time, a friend of the devil is a friend of mine. If I get home before day light, just might get some sleep tonight" - The Grateful Dead.

                            The Stable - 2009 Yamaha FZS (Baby Beast) & 2010 YAMAHA YZF R15 (Anjuna Sunset).

                            Wishlist - Kawasaki Ninja 250r, YAMAHA R6 and Bullet standard 500 with the CI engine and a handpainted Goa Chic helmet.

                            www.facebook.com/powerslave666

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by bhosleganesh View Post
                              I want to know which bike is good for driving in city in 150+ CC range.
                              Please suggest a bike on following criteria.

                              -Fuel Efficiency
                              -Driving Confort
                              -Handling on City Roads.

                              Following things dont matter.
                              -Top Speed, Power, Feel, Look etc etc

                              I am considering one of these
                              Apache 160 RTR or Apache 160 RTR FI or Yahama FZ-S , you can add to the list (Pulsar Fans, please excuse )

                              Additional Details:-
                              Height: 5'5''
                              To be Used for:- Commute to office(approx 12km one way)
                              Budget :- 70K(can pay more if there is a reason)
                              First Time Bike User
                              Please mention Milage of the Bike ur talking about for city riding (if u know)
                              I have heard about (Sucking or Not) Apache tyres, please mention ur view points.
                              for your preference unicorn is fit for you:
                              -Fuel Efficiency ~ 55 kmpl
                              -Driving Comfort - uni is well known for it
                              -Handling on City Roads. --- very good

                              You will truly feel like wing rider as Honda claims.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X