Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Stop braking before you start turning.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

P220 FI: When does One change Clutch Plate?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    @GS - I used to religiously change oil in my car for every 5K kms as per Maruti's oil change interval & once it so happened that the M.A.S.S guys told me the oil is good even after 5K kms. I accepted it with complete disbelief & cursing them for their laziness.

    But I did a grueling 1835 Kms trip in 4 days upto north KA which was after some 2-3K kms clocked on the ODO. Which means, the last oil change had been done about 7-8K kms ago. Not even once I'd any issues & the car behaved absolutely great under cold, hot, highway, bad roads & city jams.

    I'm beginning to strongly believe that unless & until the color of the oil turns black OR the engine tells me something is not right, I'm not willing to change the engine oil for fun. More than being expensive, I like your third point on environment.


    Originally posted by anmol_1990 View Post
    If HH oil is that bad then why the company itself mentioned in manual that the interval has to be 6k?
    Morons, trying to make money, that's all!!!
    Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
    Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
    ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

    Comment


    • #17
      aargee - the color WILL turn black. This is natural and this is what I am trying to say. Black doesn't mean the oil is "burnt".

      Even I believe the MT01 doesn't need an oil change every 5000Km and this is just a ploy to help the service center get recurring income. You know there are no free services if you buy a CBU in India...all paid and all costing upwards of 3000 rupees.

      The user manual states that the first service is at 1000, 2nd at 10000, 3rd at 20000 etc. Basically 10000 Km intervals. But in India they want us to come every 5000Km or lose warranty.

      This is nothing but THIEVERY

      Listen to your machine and do what is necessary. I have the facts and the balls to back up this next statement of mine:

      If you are changing oil under 5000Km then:

      1. You are stupid
      2. You are gullible and easily led on by unscrupulous mechanics
      3. There is something dramatically wrong with your motorcycle (smokey exhaust or dropping oil levels)

      Usually it is the 1st option
      Kriss : 15.06.1981 - 11.10.2009
      You will not be forgotten...RIP

      Comment


      • #18
        Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
        If you are burning engine oil it will be obvious as your 4-stroke will leave a trail of oil smoke. The engine oil will always turn black once you run it in an engine for sometime. This is a natural phenomenon. Now unless your engine oil level is reducing at an alarming rate or you are seeing smoke coming out of your exhaust there is NO reason to change oil so frequently!!

        Please save your money and save the environment. The oil manufacturers would LOVE you to buy new oil every 500Km...you know better now.



        aargee - 1500km oil changes are ludicrous!! I am just staggered at the level of ignorance on Xbhp w.r.t these basic aspects of motorcycle maintenance. When I drain the oil from the MT-01 I can see how discolored it is - this is NATURAL. I am forced to change every 5000Km because I need to maintain my warranty. Once I am out of warranty I am not going to change until the level is dropping or there is unusual engine performance/smoke. I can easily get 7-8000 Km per oil change.
        Are you talking about the synthetics or minerals. But GS-jee dont you think that there is a difference between a multicylindered MT01 & other single cylindered conventional indian bikes??
        Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
        aargee - the color WILL turn black. This is natural and this is what I am trying to say. Black doesn't mean the oil is "burnt".

        Even I believe the MT01 doesn't need an oil change every 5000Km and this is just a ploy to help the service center get recurring income. You know there are no free services if you buy a CBU in India...all paid and all costing upwards of 3000 rupees.

        The user manual states that the first service is at 1000, 2nd at 10000, 3rd at 20000 etc. Basically 10000 Km intervals. But in India they want us to come every 5000Km or lose warranty.
        Well i think that the oil gets more thickened due to more and more carbon deposits in it. So using an oil for that long may cause some problems in morning starts & in proper flow of oil. Doesnt it?? Any clarifications please.
        Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
        If you are changing oil under 5000Km then:

        1. You are stupid
        2. You are gullible and easily led on by unscrupulous mechanics
        3. There is something dramatically wrong with your motorcycle (smokey exhaust or dropping oil levels)

        Usually it is the 1st option
        Am the 2nd one. Warranty issues.
        NOT BEEN THERE NOT DONE THAT

        Comment


        • #19
          @gsferrari: bro, it's about the roads I ride during wknds r overall dusty n bad patches...well, I use the mineral oil, so I do the oil change in 1500+ kms... of course at times, this go on till 2000+ mark also, before changing that...anyway, in my opinion, minerals are not a type to last with carbon deposits & dust particles, for a long unlikely synthetic...anyway, I agree with Aargee in one point, that I do feel the roughness of the engine/clutch/gear, before judging whether to change the oil...
          IMO this is an OT we are heading to...

          Motorsport is fun. Safety is a mandate. Be in shape & ride long

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
            I have the facts and the balls to back up this next statement of mine:

            If you are changing oil under 5000Km then:

            1. You are stupid
            2. You are gullible and easily led on by unscrupulous mechanics
            3. There is something dramatically wrong with your motorcycle (smokey exhaust or dropping oil levels)

            Usually it is the 1st option
            i don't think so.

            Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
            the color WILL turn black. This is natural and this is what I am trying to say. Black doesn't mean the oil is "burnt".
            yes. of-course it will. mineral oil.

            For synthetic oil... i agree with you bout the 5000kms.
            in my post at the top of the page... i've mentioned i change fully-synth oil at 7000 kms.
            so does that make me 2000 clicks wiser than you?

            i was talking about mineral having to be changed way more frequently.

            i know the difference an oil change (mineral-oil) makes
            when changed at 2200kms as opposed to 5000kms.

            chalk n cheese. quite literally.


            But... for a single cylinder, air-cooled pulsar... for me... 3000kms is the upper limit for mineral oil.

            .
            .
            sigpic

            Comment


            • #21
              Originally posted by JonnyRider View Post
              Folks,
              My steed has crossed 42K kms mark on the odo. In last couple of months is suffered few problems, each of which remind me that it needs more care now as the parts ageing. I had to change the fuel pump & fuel injector few weeks back. I do change the engine oil almost @1500KM ride interval. So, here's the question...How to check/know if the gear-box & clutch-plates are through their ages and needs to be replaced? Anyone, if has done it on his P220 FI, please suggest me out. How to know/feel that it's time to change them? Folks, help me plz.
              If you are running stock front and rear tyres. Then your bike should do 83 Kmph @ 6K RPM in 5th Gear. If its doing lesser then in all *probability* your clutch plates are worn out and slipping.

              For most people its usually changed anywhere from 20-28K. But can change wildly with riding pattern and condition.

              Oil change interval depends on how hard you are riding your and which oil you are using. Craptrol doesn't last even 1K kms. If you don't want to spend much towards Oil, get the Valvoline Premium 4T Semi-Synth Oil. Its just a little bit more expensive than Mineral oil and lasts about 2.5-3K kms.

              @GS: Thanks to the 'brilliant' engineering from Bajaj the engine oil doesn't last as long as most other engines. Hence the earlier change interval.
              _________________________
              LoneWolfRides©

              Comment


              • #22
                Many posts advising to change clutch plates when problem arises. Not one addressing when its reasonable time for a change. Meaning, its not a problem yet but soon will be. I'm interested to know what kms would be reasonable on the average. I'm the type who like to change things before problem arises .

                Comment


                • #23
                  @gs ferrari.....

                  @gsferari sir,
                  wht ever my experiance is ,the indian car scenario changed a lot.
                  a 80 s amby or fiat 1100 used to destroy oil anything between 7500kms in patrol engines.
                  but at the same time the diesels are gen used to drink oil from 3k-4k.
                  but the scenario changed with nicer engines from 90 s onwords.
                  maruti 800s,1000s or others used oils for more then 7500kms.
                  i was shocked when i saw my dads maruti zen mpfi 02 model clocked more then 10,000kms but still when i checked the dip stick,the level was same,no drop.the biggest shock was the color.it was roughly same as a new one.
                  i checked my uncles new santro,it also showed the same charecter,amazing.
                  the 2000 model indica with idi disel engine used to black en oil within 5k and used to change in 7500kms.
                  diesel 2.6 lit di engine of scorpio showed the same charecter as the indica but the oil drop was very very less,even after clocking 178000 kms without any engine overhaul.
                  the new scorpio mhawk is having a oil change interval of 15,000 kms,and the oil level dont drop,it gets blacked though but the viscosity is maintained.

                  my experiance with bikes(indian) are a bit different.may be because they are air cooled and no oilfilter in the system.
                  my pulsar 180 ug2 which ibrought back in 2005 used to drop oil level after 1000kms.but the viscosity was maintained,i must add.days past,years past,newer bikes,newer models,newer models came out.i saw a change when i used valvoline for the first time.the oil drop was minimal.but still it needed topup.currently after shifting to motul ,the oil drop continues but the oil stays good upto 4000kms with,bit topups are required after every 1200kms.
                  my brothers newer bigger pulsar 220 ,easyly uses oil.no or very very less drop.also the oil stays good even up to 5k.a small top up is needed at 3k .
                  so i feel if the bikes having water cooling,oil filter etc the engine oil life can be extended.
                  sigpic
                  RIDE AND DRIVE SAFE AND PLEASE CHANGE THE PICTURE ON INDIAN ROADS.
                  my thoughts,my area,my game....
                  http://vmtm.blogspot.com/
                  IF YOU LOVE MAINTAINING YOUR RIDE..http://nexgenbikes.com/site/

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    When the clutch plates start slipping (the clutch may not go fully out, or takes a few seconds to go fully out) then its definitely time for a check. We have to check the plates and basket for all signs of wear and replace if neccessary.

                    I myself have replaced it when my Bike ODO touched around 11K Kms.. See it depends upon how the Bike is ridden also. If you are engaging and disengaging a lot, it may result in wear and tear quite often. I have seen quite a few friends of mine whose clutch plates are still intact, crossing 20K kms..

                    Whenever the Bike is getting serviced, its better to check with the service Engineer, whether the plate needs replacement or not. They are the best person to tell at that point of time.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by kaynmantis View Post
                      Many posts advising to change clutch plates when problem arises. Not one addressing when its reasonable time for a change. Meaning, its not a problem yet but soon will be. I'm interested to know what kms would be reasonable on the average. I'm the type who like to change things before problem arises .
                      P220 DTSi has reco clutch assembly, going by the standards of that company a replacement at 30K is reasonable. There is no thumb-rule for wear and tear of clutch plates. However there will be symptoms like reduced pick-up, reduced speed of vehicle as against the rated RPM (in a given gear)**
                      If the bike is ripped a lot then replacement has to be done earlier. Hope this helps...

                      (**) For instance Achiever's speed is 60kmph in 5th gear at 4700 rpm, between 25-30K odo reading the speed would be lesser say 55kmph at same RPM (in same gear)...it's time to replace !!!
                      Last edited by vipin_s; 02-24-2011, 07:31 PM.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Sorry to dig this back up but I use mineral oil in my MT-01 and still change every 5000 only because I HAVE to. For a single cylinder pulsar 3000 is still too early. Well - your money...our environment. You know what is best
                        Kriss : 15.06.1981 - 11.10.2009
                        You will not be forgotten...RIP

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
                          Sorry to dig this back up but I use mineral oil in my MT-01 and still change every 5000 only because I HAVE to. For a single cylinder pulsar 3000 is still too early. Well - your money...our environment. You know what is best
                          you use mineral oil in MT 01 quite strange..i have R15 i use the SS yamaha lube that SVC pour at every service but after 1000kms and so... i feel bike becoming rough...gear shifts and all....and after changing engine oil bike again becomes smooth...what you will say on this?
                          We xbhpians pledge to wear helmet while riding

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Originally posted by RhythmRana99 View Post
                            you use mineral oil in MT 01 quite strange..i have R15 i use the SS yamaha lube that SVC pour at every service but after 1000kms and so... i feel bike becoming rough...gear shifts and all....and after changing engine oil bike again becomes smooth...what you will say on this?
                            Why is it strange to use Mineral Oil in the MT-01? Your reasons please?

                            What oil are they using in your bike? Give me specifics. Does the R15 have an oil filter? If yes - do they replace this as well?

                            There is some other problem with your bike if you are eating up oil at this rate...perhaps psychologically you guys have been brainwashed into this "Oil Badli Karo" movement. A good engine shouldn't need an oil change under 5000Km.
                            Last edited by gsferrari; 04-14-2011, 05:30 PM.
                            Kriss : 15.06.1981 - 11.10.2009
                            You will not be forgotten...RIP

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Originally posted by gsferrari View Post
                              Why is it strange to use Mineral Oil in the MT-01? Your reasons please?

                              What oil are they using in your bike? Give me specifics. Does the R15 have an oil filter? If yes - do they replace this as well?

                              There is some other problem with your bike if you are eating up oil at this rate...perhaps psychologically you guys have been brainwashed into this "Oil Badli Karo" movement. A good engine shouldn't need an oil change under 5000Km.

                              +1 on this.
                              If we feel harshness, most of us feel that it is because of engine oil. it is not the only reason.
                              Whoever feels that engine is harsh due to engine oil (less than 3000 km) ,
                              Get bike serviced without changing oil. You will notice that it was not because of oil. It was something else. Might be a loose chain, unlubed chain, blocked air filter.. etc.
                              sigpic

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X