Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

The slower the vehicle, the quicker it can turn.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

P220 vs CBR250 vs CBR150 ?????

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • P220 vs CBR250 vs CBR150 ?????

    Hi Guys,

    Currently I am using a 2004 model pre-used ZMa for the last 1 yr. Now I want to upgrade. Need your help in doing so.

    My Requirements :

    1. Comfortable
    2. Reliable
    3. Low maintainance
    4. Such a bike which can be used to take ladies as pillion and also give me pleasure of riding while I am alone.

    As per my requirement I shortlisted ZMA, P220 & CBR. BUt CBR being too expensive was thrown out of equation. But the Autoexpo agin made me fall for CBR. Now I am confused between P220, CBR 150 & CBR 250.

    Pros & Cons as per my research

    P220
    Pros

    - Peppy engine.
    - Good power in both mid range & Top.
    - Projector lights
    - Most affordable

    CONS

    - Reliability. I dont want to circle around the SC every now and then

    CBR250 - Everything about this bike attaracts me. But an onroad price of 1.65l seems to be out of budget.

    CBR150 - Not yet launched but as per the conversation with the Honda guy at Expo, its made for the people who cannot afford CBR 250. Speculated to be priced around 1.2l.

    The only point about both CBR's is incase of a crash, the H/L assembly is the first thing to break and a expensive one.
    The 2nd point is if I go for a 150cc @ 1.2l, why not a 250 for 1.6l.

    Gosh....I am so damn confused!!!!!!!!
    Siddhartha
    ZMA (2004) - SOLD
    CBR250R(2012)....



  • #2
    query approved.
    (Been There Done That) x 3.25

    Comment


    • #3
      Dude, if you can afford it, get the CBR 250. It's in a different league from the others and obviously the one you really want.

      Otherwise it's the CBR 150 or R15 V2 you should be looking at.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by boomshiva View Post
        Dude, if you can afford it, get the CBR 250. It's in a different league from the others and obviously the one you really want.

        Otherwise it's the CBR 150 or R15 V2 you should be looking at.
        R15 is totally out of question. Either its CBR or P220. CBR250 has my heart but the price seems to be more....thats the reason was looking towards CBR150 but read somewhere its got its power at high revs.like the R15 whereas my use mostly would be in city which wojld need mid-range power.
        Siddhartha
        ZMA (2004) - SOLD
        CBR250R(2012)....


        Comment


        • #5
          from ZMA to CBR 150 !!!...
          I dont think that would be any way an upgrade...
          Better , you save a little more and wait a little more,then get a CBR 250...
          HH Dawn - TVS Star City - Yamaha Gladiator - TVS RTR 180 - Honda CBR 250R - Yamaha R3

          Comment


          • #6
            come on dude i hope your dilemma is gonna end you up in a duke

            Comment


            • #7
              I don't know why you said r15's out of your question. If r15's out, then cbr150 should also be out. Because these both bikes are track tools and are almost same. And cbr150's got very less torque. So just consider p220 or cbr250. I say you save some bucks and buy cbr250, it's an awesome tourer, honda smoothness etc etc!!
              Peacee
              Four wheels can move your body, but two wheels can move your soul

              Comment


              • #8
                Bike dilemma

                This might be of some help. All personal views, of course...

                From your requirements, I think the P220 would be the ideal bike.

                http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/1...eedback-3.html


                Review of the CBR 250R


                It is still early days to write a comprehensive review of the bike: I have had it for less than a month and only 1210 kms on the odo. Yet, some issues are worth mentioning.

                The Ergonomics. To me, the very first prerequisite for a GT bike is comfort. The CBR is NOT a GT bike but will be used as such due to its long legs. Now, there is a catch in the ergonomics. If one sits close up to the fuel tank, the posture is more upright, there is less weight on the arms and the back is strained less. But and BUT, one's crotch is jammed up and after some time, the penis and scrotum feel numb. Also, the edges of the seat press up at a place where the elastic of the under brief pinches on some nerve leaving the butt with a very peculiar pain, not ache. Not good, not good at all. So one shifts back and the rear of the seat is quite wide and immediately, the pain reduces and one is actually comfy, in the "front" and the "rear" if you know what I mean. But and BUT, within minutes, the weight on the fingers, the lower arm and the triceps increases to a point where one again shifts ahead. Thus, on a long journey such as the one I made, one is continuously moving back and forth, bartering one discomfort for the other. In the end, all parties involved are aching. After 80 kmph, the wind starts hitting the helmet in right earnest. A practical cruise speed would be about 80 to 90 kmph. Grading: Since she IS NOT a GT bike, 8 out of 10.

                A word about the arm pain. Due to the posture, one tends to grip the clip-ons with fists clenched tighter than on normal bikes. This causes cramping in the fingers, the inside of the lower arm and the triceps. I am considered to have strong arms and shoulders and yet, it was a good 3 days before that typical nerves related pain eased. For these 3 days, it was difficult to hold a pen; the arms feel almost lifeless and ached like I had been hit on the funny bone.

                Raising the height of the clip-ons by just 2 inches should increase the comfort level manifold. Once I have settled down here, I will get 2 suspension bolts machined with an extra 2 inches of head space and two 2 in spacers. This will turn the CeeBee into an excellent tourer, I hope...

                The InstrumentationThe SwitchgearI would have expected a much higher quality of this on the CBR. All switches are strictly cost-cutting, parts bin stuff and have to be handled gingerly lest they break, specially those that are used frequently e.g. the horn, turn indicator and flasher. Heck, the Honda scooters have higher quality stuff. Grading: 6 out of 10

                The Paintwork The quality, per se, is good. Two small bubbles have formed under the silver coloured paint of the inner fairing on either side of the headlight. When I tried to smoothen one out with a soft handkerchief, the paint peeled away exposing the black coloured base colour of the fairing. No accepted at all, Honda. Grading: 6 out of 10

                The BrakesThe Engine. Till the first oil change, the engine sounded harsh, dry, scruffy and set my teeth on edge. Now, after 1200 kms/ oil + filter change, it is much, much smoother. The counter balancer does a fantastic job and it is only at tick over that the crankshaft torque causes the characteristic up and down heave of the chassis and those too are very small migrations from the horizontal. Grading: 8 out of 10

                The Clutch. Is super light. The engaging span is generous so there is no sudden all out or all in kind of a response. The levers seem to be billet aluminium and are soft to the touch. Grading: 9 out of 10

                The Gearbox. Is slick and positive shifting. No false neutrals. From the toe down 1st, it goes straight to the toe up 2nd without snagging in the intervening neutral. While downshifting it does, at times, slot into neutral and an extra sharp tap is needed to go to 1st. This is as per design, I suppose. The ratios are well spaced. These days, the engine is still new and 80 kmph is at exactly 5000 rpm in top. I think that with more running done, the rpm will reduce at the same speed. I personally wish for a higher 6th to get an advantage of about 1000 rpm at this speed. Till 4th, she will purr around town, needing an occasional downshift to 3rd. 5th is good for overtaking and 6th is strictly for the highway. Grading: 8 out of 10

                The Throttle Response. On my bike, the throttle free play was set way too much for my style and the EFI felt jerky. It felt much smoother once I had reduced the free play to about 3/4 of an inch. Again, after the servicing, it is still better. Also improved in the response on wringing open the twist grip, especially in 3rd and 4th. She just shoots ahead and in a few seconds is at triple figures. On the highway, this eases overtaking to the point of being a no-brainer - just notch down one, twist, zip past, notch up one and cruise. Grading: 8 out of 10

                The SuspensionThe Fuel ConsumptionThe Lights The high and low beam are both superb in intensity and envelope. Again, one stupid glitch: the right hand front number plate holder arm interferes with the beam adjustment rotary gear. As soon as I get some free time, I am going to re-locate the number plate to sit between the rear view mirror mounts. It would look better there and hopefully act like a splitter plate to direct the airflow over the helmet at 80 kmph +. The indicator relay could have incorporated a muted beeper to alert the rider to cancel it timely because in the CBR (big bummer), there is NO auto cancellation of the turn indicators a la Pulsar 200/220. Honda, this is really, really cheap. Grading: 8 out of 10.

                Comment


                • #9
                  ^^Hey icemang

                  Which CBR you own? STD ver??
                  Suzuki GS150R(Balck) 2009- 2012
                  Yamaha R15 V2(LE white) 2012 and Honda Dio V2 Matte

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I think a good pair of aftermarket clip ons will help if you want a more upright posture for touring/long rides. Should ease the stress on arms, wrists, shoulders, back, and from what I read, scrotum and penis

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      from your query it seems like you are inclined towards faired bike.i would not suggest downgrade but you could consider fazer but pillion comfort is at premium.most of your riding will be involved with in city limits so won't suggest 250 cc.you may want to wait for new pulsar series or go for rtr 180 abs
                      and the question remains why do i race?
                      every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

                      #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
                      #overkill is underrated.
                      #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
                      #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

                      (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        after ZMA, there is no possible upgrade..
                        get another ZMA/R.. or upgrade to CBR250..

                        ZMA owner shifting to P220.. are you kidding me .. engine smoothness and reliability all going for a toss..
                        CBR250 or another ZMR.. you don't have options dude..



                        CBR 150 can only be moved to if you want a more sporty smaller high rev engine, then why not take the boss.. R15..


                        i see only cbr250 is the only logical choice..

                        ride on..

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Hi Guys,

                          Currently I am using a 2004 model pre-used ZMa for the last 1 yr. Now I want to upgrade. Need your help in doing so.

                          My Requirements :

                          1. Comfortable
                          2. Reliable
                          3. Low maintainance
                          4. Such a bike which can be used to take ladies as pillion and also give me pleasure of riding while I am alone.

                          As per my requirement I shortlisted ZMA, P220 & CBR. BUt CBR being too expensive was thrown out of equation. But the Autoexpo agin made me fall for CBR. Now I am confused between P220, CBR 150 & CBR 250.

                          Pros & Cons as per my research

                          P220
                          Pros

                          - Peppy engine.
                          - Good power in both mid range & Top.
                          - Projector lights
                          - Most affordable

                          CONS

                          - Reliability. I dont want to circle around the SC every now and then

                          CBR250 - Everything about this bike attaracts me. But an onroad price of 1.65l seems to be out of budget.

                          CBR150 - Not yet launched but as per the conversation with the Honda guy at Expo, its made for the people who cannot afford CBR 250. Speculated to be priced around 1.2l.

                          The only point about both CBR's is incase of a crash, the H/L assembly is the first thing to break and a expensive one.
                          The 2nd point is if I go for a 150cc @ 1.2l, why not a 250 for 1.6l.

                          Gosh....I am so damn confused!!!!!!!!



                          Hi Bro,

                          I understand the kind of confusion that your going through. We all go through the same phase in our lives at least once but you need to realize what suits your needs the best. Upgrading from a ZMA to a CBR 250 does make sense if you have that extra bucks and if your heart is inclined towards the CBR 250. It also seems that you have shortlisted 220f which is also a great machine but when it comes to trading a ZMA for it, its not a good idea. You already own a ZMA and i am sure you know its strengths and weaknesses and is well versed with the mechanism of a ZMA. I would rather suggest you to trade your old ZMA for a new Karizma R which would best suit your requirements or if you need the extra goodies ZMR is also an option.

                          PS: Its just my personal opinion guys, if i have written anything incorrect please feel free to correct me.
                          Last edited by zma@mybabe; 01-22-2012, 11:12 AM.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            dude if u want to join the crowd then go for cbr250 or r15 or if u want to get noticed then definately go for p220f the fastest indian buddy

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              as payeng told me you can opt for zma-r and save money upto 20k than buying zmr.zmr is bulky and not easy to maeuver in city traffics.zmr only offers fi and latest goodies.fi will be helpful in cold starting in the morning and linear throttle response.the other advantages of fi are more of academic and not tangible to day to day rider.p220 is torque monster, fun to ride.you can wait for new generation pulsars to b unveiled.cbr 150 and 250 are good machines.if you have the moolah thengrab them
                              and the question remains why do i race?
                              every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

                              #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
                              #overkill is underrated.
                              #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
                              #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

                              (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X