Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Keep your helmet tightly strapped up.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Which bike to upgrade to, from a P220

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Which bike to upgrade to, from a P220

    For a typical P220 owner looking for a change in bikes with a price tag less than 2 lakhs, the only options are the duke200 and the cbr250. Okay the r15 v2.0 is also a consideration but climbing down the cc ladder al the way to 150 cc is not something he considers ( No offence , its a wonderful bike and nothing else in the indian market can handle the way it does, probably only the baby ninja ). The 220 is actually a jack of all kind of bike. Good tourer as well as commuter ( lets leave tracks out of it ).
    Both the cbr as well as duke are good urban commuters. Hence , the question lies in reliability and touring capabilities. Honda seemed to have a rough patch with the initial lot of cbrs but I'm guessing the quality is back to being top notch. Also, how does the duke feel to ride on the highway ?
    To to sum everything up, Which of the two would be the best replacement for a P220 and why ?
    WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
    Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

    DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
    sigpic
    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

  • #2
    Query approved.
    (Been There Done That) x 3.25

    Comment


    • #3
      A used Kwacker 250 makes the most sense.

      A KTM or a CBR will make you regret your decision.

      Comment


      • #4
        duke for city riding and occasional highway riding while cbr for extensive touring.a used ninja if found at 2 lac is a great deal,but check if it well-worshipped.
        and the question remains why do i race?
        every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

        #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
        #overkill is underrated.
        #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
        #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

        (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

        Comment


        • #5
          Frankly Ashwin, After living with the P220 for almost 3 years, The only thing I can think of as an upgrade, is the Baby Ninja, or better, the middleweight Ninja 650R. Anything else that even holds promise of coming close to 'proper' upgrade is the 'yet to be unveiled' Duke 350 (Or even better if they make an Adventure 350 ). Anything else, I am afraid, is not a 'proper' upgrade.
          Advice is a form of nostalgia.
          Dispensing it is a way of fishing the past from the disposal, wiping it off, painting over the ugly parts and recycling it for more than it's worth.

          Antz Travelz!! | South India Exploration Ride | Leh Triplog (Work in progress)

          Comment


          • #6
            At least a Ninja 250R has to be considered. A feeble increase in power and upgrading by mere 30cc and paying around 100k more (considering that P220 will get at least 50K resale - if you want to sell it that is!) isn't a very good deal IMO.
            +1 HyperRetard
            Search the marker for a used Ninja if you are low on budget. Else you may want to get one of those Classic 500 bulls if you like the thump and plan to tour a lot.

            Cheers!
            sigpic

            Comment


            • #7
              I cannot classify myself into just one category ( touring , commuting etc ). Im a 21 year old engineering student so yes Im a daily commuter. Im also a Weekend corner craver and a highway junkie as well. So far , my 220 has not disappointed me but Im just looking for a change. So far, the only thing thing that comes close is the cbr250. Reasons are simple:

              1) I cannot burden my parents with the initial and maintenance costs of the ninja250. I shall get myself something like that when I can afford one myself.

              2) Left to me , Ideally I would like a duke with the touring capacity of the ceeber but gotta wake up and face that rude b***h REALITY.

              3) So a Jack of all is something that I need.

              Personally the cbr seems apt and with a few tweaks in the handling and performance department ( Joel already has a few things lined up for the baby ceeber ), it will make a pretty good upgrade.

              Im still in split minds so Ill just take some more time to mull over things. I dont want to rush this decision. Thanks for all your inputs guys ..
              Till then, Im just enjoying my rekindled love for my 220 which seems to be a pretty impressive package which Joel has made even better

              PS: A used kwacker may cost less than 2lacs but till the whole bike along with spares is locally made, maintenance will still burn a massive hole in my pocket. Although, the most logical choice is a used Ninja250, the more practical one for me being the cbr.
              Last edited by ashwin208; 04-04-2012, 01:24 PM.
              WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
              Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

              DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
              sigpic
              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

              Comment


              • #8
                I've been sitting on a 220 for 4.5 years...and a stock one at that mind you

                The Ninja 250R is an upgrade alright, but with the kind of the spare part prices incase of a fall and the initial cost of picking one up. I find it a little too much on offer for a little too much of what you give (read: money!). The Ninja 650R seemed like a better deal though! But then again its out of my reach.

                The CBR250R is not an upgrade for someone coming from a 220, and a Joel'd one at that! Same story for the Duke200. Simply put the jump is a little too small to be called an "upgrade"!

                My current hopes are pinned on the Duke350 which at this point seems like the only logical upgrade. Unless ofcourse I bag a bundle of cash and pick up the either of the Ninja (depends on the size of the bundle! )
                _________________________
                LoneWolfRides©

                Comment


                • #9
                  If I remember correctly you have just got bare minimum mods done on your 220 from Joel. Today on his thread, he has posted that the big bore kit is ready.

                  My advice, go for a full blown kit from Joel, it will be a fraction of the cost of buying a cbr. And at the same time you can enjoy the cheap spares of Bajaj

                  Like you said, you are 21 and its not proper to burden your parents for another fancy bike, when you already have a good one. Enjoy your souped up 220 with a little more buck and a lot more bang. Go easy on the wallet and upgrade to a big bike when you start earning!

                  By then you will have many more options. Hopefully!!!
                  Biking is not about what you have between your legs, its all about how well you use it!!!!!!!

                  Give your details here if you want to help your fellow xBhpian stranded in your city

                  Touring Blog: Cycling in Mongolia!

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Praful View Post

                    The CBR250R is not an upgrade for someone coming from a 220, and a Joel'd one at that! Same story for the Duke200. Simply put the jump is a little too small to be called an "upgrade"!
                    Alright , let me rephrase, it will make a decent "change"

                    Also, @the monk:
                    Yes Ive been in constant touch with Joel. The big bore does seem very impressive. But to what end purpose ? While the 220 has a very good engine, none of the peripherals are as well designed. In short, according to me, the 220 is not your typical long term bike .. I dont see it being very reliable or enjoyable beyond 4 years-ish. Its a vfm do it all pocket rocket but not a vfm do it all "forever" kinda pocket rocket if you get what I mean

                    And yes I know people have used the 220 for hell of a lot of kms. Praful's 220 (fi but still a 220 ) is a standing example of how much the bike can be pushed. People have clocked more than 50k kms on the dtsi alone. But still ..

                    Or the whole changing bike , etc etc is just exams blues But makes for an interesting discussion anyway so bring it on
                    Last edited by ashwin208; 04-04-2012, 01:47 PM.
                    WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
                    Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
                    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

                    DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
                    sigpic
                    http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by ashwin208 View Post
                      the only thing thing that comes close is the cbr250. Reasons are simple:

                      1) I cannot burden my parents with the initial and maintenance costs of the ninja250. I shall get myself something like that when I can afford one myself.

                      2) Left to me , Ideally I would like a duke with the touring capacity of the ceeber but gotta wake up and face that rude b***h REALITY.

                      3) So a Jack of all is something that I need.

                      Personally the cbr seems apt and with a few tweaks in the handling and performance department ( Joel already has a few things lined up for the baby ceeber ), it will make a pretty good upgrade.

                      Im still in split minds so Ill just take some more time to mull over things. I dont want to rush this decision. Thanks for all your inputs guys ..
                      Till then, Im just enjoying my rekindled love for my 220 which seems to be a pretty impressive package which Joel has made even better

                      PS: A used kwacker may cost less than 2lacs but till the whole bike along with spares is locally made, maintenance will still burn a massive hole in my pocket. Although, the most logical choice is a used Ninja250, the more practical one for me being the cbr.
                      Since you already own a joel modded P220, I hope you do realize the fact that any mod that increases the output would lead to a compromise on the life of the machine. Plus you will only be able to get the modifications done on the CBR after the warranty period ends.
                      Do consider the above two points before you buy any other bike. I'd suggest that since you are just 21 now and can afford to wait, don't rush things right now. We just might see some real kickass bikes in India i the near future considering the way the bike market is opening up.
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by ashwin208 View Post
                        Alright , let me rephrase, it will make a decent "change"
                        A change is a "lateral" shift.. An upgrade is a "vertical" shift!

                        Now why would you want to move laterally?


                        Unless you're buying a bike to impress chicks coz the P220 just doesn't cut it these days
                        _________________________
                        LoneWolfRides©

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by ankitshringi View Post
                          Since you already own a joel modded P220, I hope you do realize the fact that any mod that increases the output would lead to a compromise on the life of the machine. Plus you will only be able to get the modifications done on the CBR after the warranty period ends.
                          Do consider the above two points before you buy any other bike. I'd suggest that since you are just 21 now and can afford to wait, don't rush things right now. We just might see some real kickass bikes in India i the near future considering the way the bike market is opening up.
                          Joel's mods do not make the engine unreliable because none of his mods are extreme. On the contrary, all his mods are aimed at improving combustion efficiency. This stresses the engine less so his tuning sort of improves the reliability. And FYI, my bike has stopped giving problems after joelling. The world of mods is very tricky my friend, get it right and all parameters become better. Its only when the mods are not perfect that it goes wrong and messes things up. There are many Bikes tuned by raceconcepts on the forum itself and many more outside and everyone , me included are super satisfied.
                          But yes , warranty is a consideration.
                          Enough of the Modding bit.
                          Back to topic..

                          Originally posted by Praful View Post
                          A change is a "lateral" shift.. An upgrade is a "vertical" shift!

                          Now why would you want to move laterally?


                          Unless you're buying a bike to impress chicks coz the P220 just doesn't cut it these days
                          Actually dad suggested I change over to something else ... So naturally Im all excited about it
                          And the chick department has been taken care of. I dont need the ceeber for it
                          WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
                          Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
                          http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

                          DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
                          sigpic
                          http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Well i was under the impression that any mod will effect the life of the bike. But maybe it is not that way after all! But CBR after you own a joel mod P220? Dunno... it's your call anyways.
                            Wish you luck with the CBR then

                            Cheers!
                            sigpic

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by ankitshringi View Post
                              Well i was under the impression that any mod will effect the life of the bike. But maybe it is not that way after all! But CBR after you own a joel mod P220? Dunno... it's your call anyways.
                              Wish you luck with the CBR then

                              Cheers!
                              Most likely its going to be "Joel modded" cbr after Joel modded 220. But long time to go .. Till then Im just gonna enjoy my 220
                              WARNING : This bike has been Joel-ed
                              Tuned By Raceconcepts : Mutant P220
                              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/pit-stop...tml#post716856

                              DIY : How to put a clock on your motorcycle
                              sigpic
                              http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/do-yours...otorcycle.html

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X