Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Always keep the chain well lubricated.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Touring bike needed for LEH

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Touring bike needed for LEH

    Hello friends,
    I want your precious inputs from your rich experience of touring.
    My requirements:
    1)Main purpose of bike is going to LEH coming June ,(no pillion with light luggage) so bike should have
    sufficient torque at low engine rpm to pull on steep inclines in thin air.The bike should not cry while
    climbing.
    2)I do not drive bike at speeds more than 80 kmph.I will normally cruise between 65-80 kmph and will very
    rarely exceed 80kmph.(After seeing a lot of bike accidents on road-i stayed in ghats on mumbai goa highway
    this is my stance).
    3)Bike with decent fuel economy and cheap spares would be welcome but I would not change my bike for at least
    further 6-7years and so good reliability and long term smoothness of engine are required.
    4)After LEH bike will be used for commuting in Pune and for further 400-500 km rides in mountains near
    Pune.Presently I do not like boring rides on plain straight highways and for more longer travel I would board
    the bike in train to the nearest destination.
    5) My budget is 72k onroad and I am interested for a VFM buy but will stretch a bit if its really required
    because I will use the bike for long term so dont want to repent later.
    My assessment till now:
    (Background: Presently I own a 6year old 110 cc TVS Victor GL with 32k kms on odo.,used for 1 day 400 kms
    rides in ghats near Mumbai-Pune.The bike now feels underpowered-showing its age and the engine harsh (not
    smooth).But no problems in bike till now.Only replacement is front and rearwheel bearings,brake shoes and
    battery.)
    1) APACHE RTR:
    I have driven RTR160 and have fallen in love with its acceleration and braking.It makes sense to go for 180 as
    its not much costly than 160.
    Good points: Beautiful acceleration,Handling and braking.No plastic parts to vibrate or break.VFM bike.
    Bad points: Sporty seating position,I heard that a drive of 200+ kms would give a real good back pain.This is
    the only reason why I wont go for this bike,Apache owners please clarify on this point.Vibration?? like
    RTR160? Engine is not smooth like a unicorn but can live with it bcoz of the fantastic throttle response.
    2) Unicorn,HUNK:
    Good points:
    Smooth engine,longer wheelbase,good seating position-Unicorn for Hunk someone can comment as
    compared to Uni.Good torque at low speeds.
    Bad points: Unicorn lacks acceleration and the feel of driving a reasonably powerful bike is not there.Uni
    suspension is hard as compared to its competition.
    3) Pulsar 150,180:
    Good points: Its average in every quality,good aceleration,big bike feel,Brakes have good bite,Fuel economy is
    quite good.Cheapest to maintian,cheap spares and good availability of spares.
    Bad points: Quality is still suspect,Long term reliability 6-7years is in doubt.The firing,smoothness and
    power of the engine goes down considerably in 2-3 years time.(My perception,Pulsar owners can comment)17" poor
    quality alloy wheels.Suspension is hard.
    4) Suzuki GS150:
    Good points:Smooth engine,big fuel tank,good stability.
    Bad points:Easy availability of spares.
    5)Yamaha FZ:
    Good points:
    Only looks (I am least interested in looks for me performance matters).
    Bad points:Lack of Peformance with respect to the money invested.
    6) Karizma-The king of touring:
    Good points:
    Stress free butter smooth engine,Good seating position,Ample amount of low rpm torque,Nice soft
    suspension(heard of),long wheelbase.Most important relaibility.
    Bad points: Spares are very very costly,Unnecessary plastics which vibrate,brake and make our wallet empty.
    Fuel economy is not upto the mark should give at least 40 kms but heard of very poor mileage like 28-32 kmpl.
    7)Pulsar 220:
    Good and bad points are same as pulsar 150,180. Build quality is suspect and long term reliability and engine
    smoothness is a big question mark.(Pulsar owners please comment).The feel that bike has grown old,like engine
    noise,vibration,rattling of panels,roughness of engine,decrease in engine power.All these set up too early in
    the life of Pulsar,thats what my perception is...Please correct If i am wrong.
    8) Royal Enfield:
    Good points: Excellent seating position,Driving pleasure,music to the ears bcoz the thump does not feel harsh even if
    its a 30 year old bike.(I do not like loud thumps,just one with the standard silencer)
    Bad points: Suspect reliability,Over weight.Niggling issues require a lot of precious time from your side
    Due to lack of knowledge I also do not understand which one is good Std 350 or Bullet electra and why?
    Other bikes like R15,Thunderbird etc are beyond my budget and reach.

    Disclaimer:Above assesment is by reading various sites and I have only test driven apache rtr 160,unicorn as of now.
    Inspite of collecting the above material from Xbhp and Various other sites I am confused bcoz I now have only the theoretical knowledge not the practical so need your expert assistance.

    My Questions:

    1) For above requirements which bike i should buy and why?

    2) As I am a sedate driver do I really require a 223 cc(Karizma) for my purpose or a 150cc should suffice? I
    mean will buying a bike of more CC be justified for my driving of 65-80kmph cruising.Will I be able to Utilise the true potential of bike or its just unnecessary investment?Will a 150 cc be able to generate sufficient
    torque to carry me and my luggage over the steep inclines of Chang la?If higher CC will not amount to any significant benefit upto 80 kmph range than I would not like to invest much for higher cc bike.

    3) Is Apaches seating position a strict No-No for long touring?I had a small test drive and my back and hands
    were paining a little,or would i get adjusted to it later?Also is apaches engine suitable for long drives or will it always require me to redline it always to get the true potential out of it?

    4)Karizma can some one share the maintenance cost please am worried about the expensive spares.
    52
    Unicorn
    9.62%
    5
    Karizma
    76.92%
    40
    Apache RTR180
    11.54%
    6
    GS 150
    1.92%
    1

  • #2
    Touring Bike Choice Discussion Approved
    The Wheel was a great invention; Two Wheels with a Motor in between was even better!


    BMW Motorrad Days 2011

    Xbhp's Indo-French Kashmir-Ladakh Tour

    Comment


    • #3
      From your list i would shortlist Hunk/CBZ-X and Pulsar180 . im sure if you maintain a bike well it will last years .

      they are powerful,comfortable and easy to maintain .

      Comment


      • #4
        i cannot answer all of your questions but let me share some thing from my experience.

        1.Out of all the bike you listed karizma will be the most comfortable one for long tours.

        2. If you are looking for a reliable bike that can serve you for 6-7 years
        i suggest you karizma. It is a very reliable and relaxed machine.

        3. Try riding a karizma at 80 km/hour at 5k rpm on 5 th gear you will simply love it ( please note if you buy a karizma and ride on a open highway i bet you will cross 100 easily even though now you are saying you wont cross 80 . Dude it is very stable on 80's so that will inspire you to push for more. Mark my words)

        4. Yes karizma parts are very costly but the fact is that if you maintain your bike properly ( meaning service it in instructed time/km , change oil at correct time ...etc.) the chances of changing parts will be almost nill.
        it is such a relaible bike.

        5. YEs karizmas are not good in mileage department. It will give you 28-32 if you are riding it on 120 or above continously for hours.
        But if you ride at 60-70 or even 80 it will definitly return you 38-42 .
        I used to get 42 when i ride 60-70 on highways.

        6. Yes karizma is having a lot of plastic parts but karizma plastic parts are of very good quality and will not vibrate much . Mine is rock steady till 120. I have tried atleast 3 karizmas of my friends in long drive and never felt the vibrations from the plastic parts .
        Unless broken the plastic parts are rock steady in almost all speed ranges till 120.
        Last edited by Jithu; 11-02-2009, 01:44 AM.
        sigpic

        Comment


        • #5
          @Jithu Thanks a lot for your information. I was looking for exactly the information which you have given about Karizma.
          @Puneet1. Could you tell me between the difference between the seating position of Hunk,Cbz Extreme and Unicorn.
          I feel the Hunk is again made sporty read forward bent style,which I hate bcoz it pains the back during long drives(MY perception).I have been using TVS victor for long which has a very very relaxed seating position.Infact I would term as the best no bending of your back at all is required.
          Also do you think the bikes mentioned by you can tackle the inclines of Leh passes without crying? Your inputs are precious to me...Thanks

          Comment


          • #6
            even my take would be on karizma. Its not because I own one, but as I have tested its capabilities, for riding around 500-600 kms a day couple of days. Tested in all kind of weathers, frozen, frying hot, altitudes, snow..! It never dissapointed me.
            I rode her for 6500kms & 21 days, but not a single day I was sitting home with a body or back-ache. Afterall, its mere my point of view. But I dont think, most of the people around will disagree to it being highly 'comfortable' & 'reliable' for touring.


            Blog : Mumbai - Leh - Mumbai : 21 Days, 6500kms. Journey to Heaven..June'09
            GreatIndianRide - West India on a 110cc for over a month
            Mumbai-Leh-Mumbai - A Sequel : July'11 (Blog coming soon)

            Comment


            • #7
              I would suggest the ZMA. +1 to all of jithu's points.
              I feel the Hunk is quite heavy on the front. It lacks power( my opinion).
              As Jithu said, try riding the ZMA @ 80kmph @5000rpm. The feel is better than the " I FEEL LIKE GOD " -Avenger/Eliminator advertisement.
              Never Argue with an Idiot !!!
              He will bring you down to his level and beat you with his experience.

              Comment


              • #8
                and i thought ENFIELD BULLET always ruled leh.
                but given ur list of bikes,go for ZMA closed eyed.

                Originally posted by amit_purohit20 View Post
                Is Apaches seating position a strict No-No for long touring?I had a small test drive and my back and hands
                were paining a little,or would i get adjusted to it later?Also is apaches engine suitable for long drives or will it always require me to redline it always to get the true potential out of it?
                dont even put "touring" and "RTR" together....
                the bike is strict no no for touring,it'll make ur back ache,palm ache,and shoulders too...
                the riding position feels good for 40-50kms but gets too tiring after that...you wont ever get "adjusted" to it.

                the RTR needs rev to make it perform and if you need power outta it you have to keep it above 5000,the engine is very good but vibrates like hell in 5200-6300 region which translate to 68-75 kmph and that's the idealin touring speed sometimes.

                for a track day it's brilliant, for touring it sucks big time.
                Last edited by rennycornelius; 11-02-2009, 06:12 PM.
                The Magician"

                Comment


                • #9
                  I would say take your trusty old Victor to Leh, come back, sell it&get a ZMA/ZMR.
                  Quench my thirst with gasoline!

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by Coplay@180 View Post
                    I would suggest the ZMA. +1 to all of jithu's points.
                    I feel the Hunk is quite heavy on the front. It lacks power( my opinion).
                    As Jithu said, try riding the ZMA @ 80kmph @5000rpm. The feel is better than the " I FEEL LIKE GOD " -Avenger/Eliminator advertisement.
                    Pssst.. The same is possible on a P220 Dtsi.. But thats for those pure power enthusiasts..(like me).

                    For the record..
                    80@5k
                    95@6k
                    108@7k (No vibes at this point AT ALL i.e. between 103-112)
                    122@8k
                    135@9k
                    144@10k

                    have'nt ventured further as yet. But people have also reached 150


                    It was labelled Best tourer among ZMA/R15/A180 by Overdrive Sep'09 due to its superior cruise speed, FE, Lighting, Braking and overall stress free character. Being priced 1k less than a ZMA, gives much better bang for the bucks. And with a city FE of 40+(mild ripping) I could'nt ask for anything more.

                    Also regarding reliability and durability queries, you can contact senior P220 DTS-Fi owners who have done 30k km+ because bothe these bikes share everything apart from the fuel injection model and rear sprocket.

                    P.S.: @ Thread starter.. I have graduated from 111.6 cc Caliber after riding th Caliber for 4 years in Pune Traffic.

                    Primary objective: Reach Leh in 2010.
                    Last edited by antz.bin; 11-02-2009, 06:51 PM.
                    Advice is a form of nostalgia.
                    Dispensing it is a way of fishing the past from the disposal, wiping it off, painting over the ugly parts and recycling it for more than it's worth.

                    Antz Travelz!! | South India Exploration Ride | Leh Triplog (Work in progress)

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by antz.bin View Post
                      Being priced 1k less than a ZMA, gives much better bang for the bucks. And with a city FE of 40+(mild ripping) I could'nt ask for anything more.
                      +1 to that. P220 is the best bang for buck "Sports Tourer" if you may call it. I am not sure how it would perform at high altitudes since the new 220 has a carb unlike the FI in the older models.

                      But i have been on a ride of 500kms two way and i also did not exceed 80kmph. It was very comfortable and no issues with the seating at all!!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        @antz.bin We both have the same objective,we both started with 100cc bikes, might be we both will reach together to LEH in 2010.

                        Can somebody also comment on Unicorn(Hunk,CBZ extreme) climbing abilities in LEH terrain. Are they able to climb with sufficient power or they cry a lot and just somehow pull themselves to the finish.??

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Hi amit you have not mentioned your height and all, if u r tall like 5.8 + then i suggest go for karizma without any doubts, as rtr, hunk and other bikes i have not heard that much used for long trips, again pune to delhi in a car it takes almost 18+ hours driving continously, so you can think how much will it take on bike, and above all hero honda service centers are available every city of india, pulsar 220 and all are good bikes for perfrormance but karizma is the king of tourers, and agian you told the problem of engine nt crying or issues while climbing in that case you can check the thread and i think there is a bolt adjustment for karizma so it moves easily on upward ghats, and handling pagal nala and all you will need bike with good grip and height to balance, so i feel karizma is the winner.

                          Again when it comes to spare like cables and all i agree karizma are costly but they last long while bajaj cost the same but are not that long lasting
                          Secondly after touring you can use the bike in pune as it handles offroad and onroad potholes of pune very well, as i myself stay in pune and i know how karizma handles the potholes without giving backpains as i am driving my friends karizma from last 3 months.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post
                            and i thought ENFIELD BULLET
                            dont even put "touring" and "RTR" together....

                            the riding position feels good for 40-50kms but gets too tiring after that...you wont ever get "adjusted" to it.

                            for a track day it's brilliant, for touring it sucks big time.
                            I agree that the RTR isnt the most ideal tourer around. But it isnt as painful as the above post makes it sound.At least as far as my experience on it is concerned.
                            If you have decent roads, the RTR will be good. But since you are talking about Leh , I would suggest ZMA or the Bullet.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Hi amit you have not mentioned your height and all, if u r tall like 5.8 + then i suggest go for karizma without any doubts, as rtr, hunk and other bikes i have not heard that much used for long trips, again pune to delhi in a car it takes almost 18+ hours driving continously, so you can think how much will it take on bike, and above all hero honda service centers are available every city of india, pulsar 220 and all are good bikes for perfrormance but karizma is the king of tourers, and agian you told the problem of engine nt crying or issues while climbing in that case you can check the thread and i think there is a bolt adjustment for karizma so it moves easily on upward ghats, and handling pagal nala and all you will need bike with good grip and height to balance, so i feel karizma is the winner.

                              Again when it comes to spare like cables and all i agree karizma are costly but they last long while bajaj cost the same but are not that long lasting
                              Secondly after touring you can use the bike in pune as it handles offroad and onroad potholes of pune very well, as i myself stay in pune and i know how karizma handles the potholes without giving backpains as i am driving my friends karizma from last 3 months.
                              My height is 5 7" am overweight 84kg. I have no problem with saddle height of any bikes till now I think so....

                              If I can stretch my budget I will go for Karizma (am not sure about the budget now sorry -confused lot of constraints) but If i cant then can someone comment about Honda Unicorn,Hunk? Do they both have same riding posture? Hunk seems to have sporty riding position and to add to it the pillion seat is short which means less space to carry my luggage on it. What is Hunks and Unicorns average?

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X