Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Keep your helmet tightly strapped up.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Confuse between stunner or sz-r

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
    OK, Frds.. so lets have final voting (with reason for choice by keeping below points)

    1) SZ-R – (Rs. 65,000/-)
    2) GS 150R (Rs. 69000/-)
    3) Honda Unicorn (Rs. 70,000/-)

    Please again consider below points –
    1) which bike is really VFM ??? - SZ-R

    2) which bike will performed by pulling total weight of 200kgs (Pillion and Rider). - GS150R

    3) which bike suits me well as my height is around 6.3” & Pillion height is around 5.10”. - GS150R

    4) which bike is low - on maintains aspects…?? - Unicorn

    5) which his bike surve me for atleast 5 years without major issue like we faced in Bajaj bikes after two years? ( i know most of ppls will vote of honda) - Unicorn>SZ-R~GS150R

    6) which bike having better pickup.. (Keeping our weight in mind) - GS150R~SZ-R

    any other things needs to considered.. please advice
    replies in bold..GS150R will suffice your needs better even though there's tough competition among all three bikes & you can't go wrong with any of them..
    Last edited by 111diablo111; 09-18-2012, 02:35 PM.
    Suzuki Gixxer - Current
    Karizma ZMR <3 - Sold
    Apache RTR160 - Sold
    Honda Stunner - Sold
    LML Energy - Sold

    Comment


    • Originally posted by 111diablo111 View Post
      replies in bold..GS150R will suffice your needs better even though there's tough competition among all three bikes & you can't go wrong with any of them..
      So, it means 65,000 rs bike will serve my purpose.. the same of 70,000 rs bike ???

      Comment


      • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
        So, it means 65,000 rs bike will serve my purpose.. the same of 70,000 rs bike ???
        ya exactly..they all are reliable & have a good heart moreover they all have some plus points over each others..all three companies are well known for their reliable engines & won't ditch you anytime sooner than the other..take your pick & start riding..
        Suzuki Gixxer - Current
        Karizma ZMR <3 - Sold
        Apache RTR160 - Sold
        Honda Stunner - Sold
        LML Energy - Sold

        Comment


        • what i am afraid from GS150R spare parts and availability.. but one side goes against SZ-r is it mileage.. damn now i am confused... can you please help me please vote, other wise spending 4000rs more for gs150r is not a big problem for me.. but i want to be sure shot...

          Comment


          • so finally i sell off my passion pro in 37,000 rs yesterday night... i purchased the same on 27.march.2011, till yesterday it compltd 18700km.. (i saved few money on service and battery needs to be replaced)

            Comment


            • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
              Hi,
              Myself Gagan from Delhi. I am still not able to decide which bike to go for…
              Yesterday, visited to Yamaha Showroom, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi , There I got the under exchange deal for my passion pro which I brought on 27.03.2011, it runs only 18,300 kms.

              The sale person of that showroom offer me exchange value of Rs. 32,000/- & new SZ-R (White color) costing me only Rs.33, 000 /- (On Road price- Rs. 65000 – 32,000).

              So my questions for the owners of this bike are following –

              1) Is this bike is really VFM.
              Ans: The answer is subjective to the need of a person. What you call a VFM is important. Is it that, if it gives you more mileage then its VFM? Or If this bike is maintenance free then its VFM? If you ask me, the pricing it comes it is definitely VFM product by Yamaha, I have been riding it for 1 and half year now. I crashed her 4 times hence my maintenance side went a little high and if you dont drop it then it will ask you do its regular servicing as recommended by Yamaha.

              2) How this bike will performed by pulling total weight of 160kgs (Pillion and Rider).
              Ans: I dont ride it much with pillion, only once I went to mountainous roads with Pillion and pulling a 72 kg pillion with me around 73 kg was never a problem due to its excellent lower end torque.

              3) My height is around 6.3” & Pillion height is around 5.10”.
              Ans: One of my friend is 6'1", he is riding with no problem.

              4) How this bike on maintains aspects…??
              Ans: Like I said regular maintenance and periodic replacement as recommended by Yamaha thats what it takes.

              5) Will this bike surve me for atleast 5 years without major issue like we faced in Bajaj bikes after two years?
              Ans: It should, this bike is launched about 1 and half year ago. Since this is a Yamaha bike durability should not be a problem.

              6) How’s the pickup.. (keeping our weight in mind)
              Ans: Very good. Pulling in second gear from standstill with or without pillion is never a problem.

              7) What is actual mileage (show room guys told me 40-45)
              Ans: I just calculated my bikes mileage about couple of days ago, I have been riding slow between 30-55 kmph due to rain and in City limit I ride slow. I got 49 kmpl, this is with with Reserve to reserve method. Like Yamaha says in the manual, "Mileage depends upon riding habit", if you ride rash, rip it up it will give you less mileage as a matter fact any bike would fetch less mileage. One of the most important part of SZ-R that I found is, The Running-in period of this bike. You follow proper running period and this bike will perform very good.


              I know there are other bikes too, but I am tight on budget, apart from this bike there is only two bikes I liked

              1) Unicorn – Rs 71,000 (On Road)

              2) CBZ extreme. – Rs 75,000 (On Road)
              Ans: Both the bikes are in here for a longer period of time so durability is not an issue over here, for other aspects I cant comment.

              The question here is that, if I am getting good VFM in (Rs. 65,000/-) then why I spend Rs. 10,000 more.
              Ans: Like I said it is VFM if it fit into your definition of VFM. And being cheaper than other 150cc almost 5 digits can make it only a winner over others.

              Please suggest and clear my doubts.

              Thanks
              I posted it on ownership thread but i think you might have missed out on it.

              Mileage - Lowest I got was 38 kmpl due to mistuned carb, highest I got was 55 kmpl, highways above 60 kmph I get around 43-45 kmpl. City 45-50 kmpl.

              As of today I have completed 8th service of my SZ-R, now running on Elf Moto 10W50 Fully Synthetic oil and the engine is even more smooth than before, rev friendly. Mileage is hovering between 45-50 kmpl in City riding, 30-55 kmph with a few burst of redlining on lower gears.

              Please let me know if you have any questions.

              Cheers!

              - Lalit

              Comment


              • 2
                Originally posted by lalitp View Post
                I posted it on ownership thread but i think you might have missed out on it.

                Mileage - Lowest I got was 38 kmpl due to mistuned carb, highest I got was 55 kmpl, highways above 60 kmph I get around 43-45 kmpl. City 45-50 kmpl.

                As of today I have completed 8th service of my SZ-R, now running on Elf Moto 10W50 Fully Synthetic oil and the engine is even more smooth than before, rev friendly. Mileage is hovering between 45-50 kmpl in City riding, 30-55 kmph with a few burst of redlining on lower gears.

                Please let me know if you have any questions.

                Cheers!

                - Lalit
                Ok.. Thanks Lalit.. though i am still not purchased my bikes.. i would like to try UNICORN & STUNNER.. They both look bigger than SZ-R.. & I am getting good mileage in any case.. what you suggest..

                The only think impressed me in SZ-R - it value I got an offer from showroom of 64,500 rs /- (which include the price of accessories like leg guard, sari guard + steelbird helmet)... This sounds very tempting.. apart from this as you told me.. this bike can easily pull off weight of two (around 200 kgs) + it is good for tall person like me...... (Hope you are sure shot on this)...

                Now comes to HONDA .. the things forcing me towards this... are HONDA very good engine (UNICORN).. easily maintenance, availability of part in local market (being so old). + mileage also, same in the case of stunner as i am using these bike within Delhi city with total running of 80 km per day (up & down).

                What other suggestions.... ???

                Comment


                • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                  ... i am using these bike within Delhi city with total running of 80 km per day (up & down).

                  What other suggestions.... ???
                  Ahh!! 80kms both side!! That's a huge number for daily purpose!!
                  Actually you should see 100cc or 125 cc only!! Becuase Petrol price would be hiked again in coming years and I am dead Sure that it will reach 100Rs/liter in 2 yrs.
                  So Unicorn or SZr or P135 are of no use in that sense. Go with some good mileage of 70kmpl+ atlest.
                  Twsiter is a good option.
                  Your second criteria pillion together: Are you travelling with pillion daily 80kms??

                  If yes then only Unicorn but still you will be hit by petrol prices on daily basis. ANd if pillion is occasionally on weekends then go with some good mileage!!

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by somen1984 View Post
                    Ahh!! 80kms both side!! That's a huge number for daily purpose!!
                    Actually you should see 100cc or 125 cc only!! Becuase Petrol price would be hiked again in coming years and I am dead Sure that it will reach 100Rs/liter in 2 yrs.
                    So Unicorn or SZr or P135 are of no use in that sense. Go with some good mileage of 70kmpl+ atlest.
                    Twsiter is a good option.
                    Your second criteria pillion together: Are you travelling with pillion daily 80kms??

                    If yes then only Unicorn but still you will be hit by petrol prices on daily basis. ANd if pillion is occasionally on weekends then go with some good mileage!!
                    No buddy... it total ride .. not more than 80 km (including up & down).. max...

                    Na.. only for weekend ride... i wish i can buy two bike 125 cc (SS 125 or STUNNER) & another one 150 or 220 cc bike.. but this is only wish .. let C when it become reality...

                    any way... SS 125 or STUNNER or SZ-r

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                      No buddy... it total ride .. not more than 80 km (including up & down).. max...

                      Na.. only for weekend ride... i wish i can buy two bike 125 cc (SS 125 or STUNNER) & another one 150 or 220 cc bike.. but this is only wish .. let C when it become reality...

                      any way... SS 125 or STUNNER or SZ-r
                      See my friend very practically, you have a car i see in pic. For weekends you can manage it with that too.

                      And 125 cc would save your lot of money on petrol which can be used on weekend in your car.
                      Any 125 cc would give you a good mileage of 65-70kmpl. Have you test ridden Twister ??? How was that while riding. I have seen some good height people riding it. and it has an awesome average of 70kmpl+.

                      Daily 80kms is really huge i mean it.

                      Don't think on weekend ride buddy, I guess you can neglect that part too. when weekend rides are some thing that you can manage, but daily ride is more imp.

                      from your choice Stunner is good even check twister and shine. SS125 is also good.

                      Note: I and my dad would be approx 200kgs and we roam on Aspire mere 110cc bike with out any issues we ride over hills too as my home is at hilly region,Mmy dad gets an average of 65kmpl+ in purely city.

                      SZr is good but it would give you 50-60kmpl max!! Where as any 125 cc would give you 65kmpl atleast!! and 70kmpl+ max.

                      Choose wisely. And when it's a question of daily ride of 80kms total then Honda is best to be choosen in 125cc segment.
                      Choose from Stunner/Shine/Twister if still you are mad about 150cc then SZr.
                      Last edited by Guest; 09-21-2012, 01:03 PM.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by somen1984 View Post
                        Ahh!! 80kms both side!! That's a huge number for daily purpose!!
                        Actually you should see 100cc or 125 cc only!! Becuase Petrol price would be hiked again in coming years and I am dead Sure that it will reach 100Rs/liter in 2 yrs.
                        So Unicorn or SZr or P135 are of no use in that sense. Go with some good mileage of 70kmpl+ atlest.
                        Twsiter is a good option.
                        Your second criteria pillion together: Are you travelling with pillion daily 80kms??

                        If yes then only Unicorn but still you will be hit by petrol prices on daily basis. ANd if pillion is occasionally on weekends then go with some good mileage!!
                        +100, looking at current economic scenario it feels petrol will reach 100rs/litre earlier than expected. and then goverment will have lame excuse that in pakistan petrol is already 100rs/litre ( God, when will these people stop comparing themselves with pakistan) .

                        somen, but mileage of 70+ kmpl !!!! maximum i heard was 60 kmpl for splendor which is 100 cc.

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                          No buddy... it total ride .. not more than 80 km (including up & down).. max...

                          Na.. only for weekend ride... i wish i can buy two bike 125 cc (SS 125 or STUNNER) & another one 150 or 220 cc bike.. but this is only wish .. let C when it become reality...

                          any way... SS 125 or STUNNER or SZ-r
                          SS125..... this would have been my first choice with eyes closed, 2 years back. Now... my personal opinion is it looks bit outdated.
                          Stunner..... heard big vibrations at speed above 60 Kmph in almost all reviews. ( is it honda, seriously ?? )
                          SZR...... I am probable buyer of this maybe in 1-2 months.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by MoonLight View Post
                            somen, but mileage of 70+ kmpl !!!! maximum i heard was 60 kmpl for splendor which is 100 cc.
                            Nothing like that mate. Twister one of the best mileage deliver!! 70kmpl+ there are few more. I guess sling shot also gives a 70kmpl.
                            There was a chart shared by Antz Bin some where and that chart had much better mileage figures of 100cc .
                            BTW my Aspire 110cc 12 yrs old gives an average of 65kmpl in city.
                            check this:


                            edit:
                            Source: http://www.speedmasti.com/bike-scoot...bikes-mileage/
                            Indian Manufacturer and Models Effective Overall Mileage kmpl
                            Bajaj Discover 100 DTS-Si 86
                            Hero Honda S Splendor (Super Db ES) 80
                            TVS Flame SR/DS 80
                            Hero Honda CD Down 77
                            Hero Honda Glamour Fi 75
                            Honda CB Twister(kick-drum, self-drum, self-disc) 75
                            Yamaha Gladiator Type RS/SS 70
                            Mahindra Stallio 68
                            TVS Star Sport 66
                            Yamaha Alba KS/ES/G5 66
                            Bajaj Platina 100 65
                            Honda CBF Stunner(ES) 65
                            TVS Scooty Pep+ 64
                            Hero Honda Passion Plus 63
                            Hero Honda Splendor Plus 63
                            Honda CB Shine 63
                            TVS Apache RTR 160 FI 63
                            TVS Jive 62
                            Bajaj Pulsar 150 DTS-i 60
                            Hero Honda Hunk 60
                            Honda CB Unicorn 60
                            Yamaha Ceux S 60
                            Hero Honda CBZ Xtreme 58
                            Honda Activa 55
                            Honda Aviator(drum/disc) 53
                            Honda Dio 52
                            TVS Wego 52
                            Bajaj Pulsar 180 DTS-i 50
                            Hero Honda Pleasure 50
                            Yamaha FZFazer/F16/FZ-S 48
                            Mahindra Duro 48
                            Mahindra Flyte 48
                            Mahindra Rodeo SYM 46
                            Yamaha YZF-R15 43
                            Hero Honda Karizma 41
                            Bajaj Pulsar 220 DTS-i 40
                            Bajaj Pulsar 220 S 40
                            Royal Enfield Electra Standard 35
                            Royal Enfield Thunderbird Twinspark 34
                            Honda CB1000R 17
                            Honda CBR 1000RR Fireblade 16
                            Honda VFR 13
                            Last edited by Guest; 09-21-2012, 03:40 PM.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by somen1984 View Post
                              Ahh!! 80kms both side!! That's a huge number for daily purpose!!
                              Actually you should see 100cc or 125 cc only!! Becuase Petrol price would be hiked again in coming years and I am dead Sure that it will reach 100Rs/liter in 2 yrs.
                              So Unicorn or SZr or P135 are of no use in that sense. Go with some good mileage of 70kmpl+ atlest.
                              Twsiter is a good option.
                              Your second criteria pillion together: Are you travelling with pillion daily 80kms??

                              If yes then only Unicorn but still you will be hit by petrol prices on daily basis. ANd if pillion is occasionally on weekends then go with some good mileage!!

                              See again i liked stunner, unicorn, sz-r and SS125......


                              Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                              No buddy... it total ride .. not more than 80 km (including up & down).. max...

                              Na.. only for weekend ride... i wish i can buy two bike 125 cc (SS 125 or STUNNER) & another one 150 or 220 cc bike.. but this is only wish .. let C when it become reality...

                              any way... SS 125 or STUNNER or SZ-r
                              Originally posted by somen1984 View Post
                              See my friend very practically, you have a car i see in pic. For weekends you can manage it with that too.

                              And 125 cc would save your lot of money on petrol which can be used on weekend in your car.
                              Any 125 cc would give you a good mileage of 65-70kmpl. Have you test ridden Twister ??? How was that while riding. I have seen some good height people riding it. and it has an awesome average of 70kmpl+.

                              Daily 80kms is really huge i mean it.

                              Don't think on weekend ride buddy, I guess you can neglect that part too. when weekend rides are some thing that you can manage, but daily ride is more imp.

                              from your choice Stunner is good even check twister and shine. SS125 is also good.

                              Note: I and my dad would be approx 200kgs and we roam on Aspire mere 110cc bike with out any issues we ride over hills too as my home is at hilly region,Mmy dad gets an average of 65kmpl+ in purely city.

                              SZr is good but it would give you 50-60kmpl max!! Where as any 125 cc would give you 65kmpl atleast!! and 70kmpl+ max. - IF Szr is good option then OK...

                              Choose wisely. And when it's a question of daily ride of 80kms total then Honda is best to be choosen in 125cc segment.

                              Choose from Stunner/Shine/Twister if still you are mad about 150cc then SZr.
                              - I am not mad.. but again .. shape matter for me with the machine... stunner and Sz-r..

                              Originally posted by MoonLight View Post
                              +100, looking at current economic scenario it feels petrol will reach 100rs/litre earlier than expected. and then goverment will have lame excuse that in pakistan petrol is already 100rs/litre ( God, when will these people stop comparing themselves with pakistan) .

                              somen, but mileage of 70+ kmpl !!!! maximum i heard was 60 kmpl for splendor which is 100 cc.
                              Yep, You are right buddy.

                              Originally posted by MoonLight View Post
                              SS125..... this would have been my first choice with eyes closed, 2 years back. Now... my personal opinion is it looks bit outdated.
                              Stunner..... heard big vibrations at speed above 60 Kmph in almost all reviews. ( is it honda, seriously ?? ) - ​but i heard that problem can be solved with changing sprocket (hope i am right)

                              SZR...... I am probable buyer of this maybe in 1-2 months.
                              - again its also my fav but have you seen stunner's height with tubeless tyre that cost only Rs.61,000 with 11 bhp power .. apart from this szr is only 12 bhp... with cost of rs 65,000/- , with no tubeless tyre.. now what you say on this.....

                              Originally posted by somen1984 View Post
                              Nothing like that mate. Twister one of the best mileage deliver!! 70kmpl+ there are few more. I guess sling shot also gives a 70kmpl.
                              There was a chart shared by Antz Bin some where and that chart had much better mileage figures of 100cc .
                              BTW my Aspire 110cc 12 yrs old gives an average of 65kmpl in city. - It does not mean that I dont want those bike which enable to pull me.. & walks like elephant..
                              check this:


                              edit:
                              Source: Indian Bikes Mileage - Mileage for Indian Bikes in 2011
                              Indian Manufacturer and Models Effective Overall Mileage kmpl
                              Bajaj Discover 100 DTS-Si 86
                              Hero Honda S Splendor (Super Db ES) 80
                              TVS Flame SR/DS 80
                              Hero Honda CD Down 77
                              Hero Honda Glamour Fi 75
                              Honda CB Twister(kick-drum, self-drum, self-disc) 75
                              Yamaha Gladiator Type RS/SS 70
                              Mahindra Stallio 68
                              TVS Star Sport 66
                              Yamaha Alba KS/ES/G5 66
                              Bajaj Platina 100 65
                              Honda CBF Stunner(ES) 65
                              TVS Scooty Pep+ 64
                              Hero Honda Passion Plus 63
                              Hero Honda Splendor Plus 63
                              Honda CB Shine 63
                              TVS Apache RTR 160 FI 63
                              TVS Jive 62
                              Bajaj Pulsar 150 DTS-i 60
                              Hero Honda Hunk 60
                              Honda CB Unicorn 60
                              Yamaha Ceux S 60
                              Hero Honda CBZ Xtreme 58
                              Honda Activa 55
                              Honda Aviator(drum/disc) 53
                              Honda Dio 52
                              TVS Wego 52
                              Bajaj Pulsar 180 DTS-i 50
                              Hero Honda Pleasure 50
                              Yamaha FZFazer/F16/FZ-S 48
                              Mahindra Duro 48
                              Mahindra Flyte 48
                              Mahindra Rodeo SYM 46
                              Yamaha YZF-R15 43
                              Hero Honda Karizma 41
                              Bajaj Pulsar 220 DTS-i 40
                              Bajaj Pulsar 220 S 40
                              Royal Enfield Electra Standard 35
                              Royal Enfield Thunderbird Twinspark 34
                              Honda CB1000R 17
                              Honda CBR 1000RR Fireblade 16
                              Honda VFR 13

                              Yaar frankly i dont believe in these figure...

                              My replies are in bold please suggests.
                              Last edited by jammbuster; 09-21-2012, 04:31 PM.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by jammbuster View Post

                                See again i liked stunner, unicorn, sz-r and SS125......

                                You are bend towards SZr more.
                                Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                                - I am not mad.. but again .. shape matter for me with the machine... stunner and Sz-r..

                                If shape does matters then SZr looks far better then Stunner, where as you have two models in market with approx same looks i.e Stunner and Ignitor
                                Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                                - again its also my fav but have you seen stunner's height with tubeless tyre that cost only Rs.61,000 with 11 bhp power .. apart from this szr is only 12 bhp... with cost of rs 65,000/- , with no tubeless tyre.. now what you say on this.....
                                Cost and features is now your concern...so why not Stunner which is 1 bhp less and has tubeless tyres
                                Originally posted by jammbuster View Post
                                Yaar frankly i dont believe in these figure...

                                My replies are in bold please suggests.

                                Some where this figures are actual, if you lessen it by say 5kmpl then too it's ok, R15 figures are more than what they have mentioned

                                Now you decide which bike you want Stunner or SZr ?? features or power ?? Cost or requirement ??

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X