Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

All the gear all the time (ATGATT).

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Is the Karizma losing its appeal?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally posted by vrugonnab View Post
    Well technically you missed the chance of owning two of the best bikes out there within your budget and of course they are Duke 200/CBR250. But, of course you liked ZMR, enjoy your ride.
    he had to miss R15 as its in different category among all three mentioned bikes..so apparently he missed only one bike which he could consider n that's CBR250..if Honda can improve its A.S.S then its a great product..
    Suzuki Gixxer - Current
    Karizma ZMR <3 - Sold
    Apache RTR160 - Sold
    Honda Stunner - Sold
    LML Energy - Sold

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by 111diablo111 View Post
      Karizma might not be the fastest Indian bike but still it has more then decent enough power for Indian roads & still its quicker then many other bikes on roads even after so many years but then main thing which it can do better than any of its competitor is "touring", it still is no doubt one of the best sports tourer available in the country & ZMR took it one step further with a most important tech according to me for high altitude locations i.e Closed loop FI,few other features are helpful too while touring..

      given an another chance I personally will go for ZMR again..or might go for CBR250 that's it, there's no other product which can replace a bike like ZMA/ZMR..

      There's no doubt that R15 is a great machine but they both have different kind of byers..i mean how can you tour on R15 like a ZMA or How can you score smashing time laps on ZMA like R15..they both are VERY different products & if a buyer has to buy a bike for touring then it'll be a foolish decision to choose a sports bike like R15 over a sports tourer like ZMA/ZMR..

      According to me Karizma is an overall package which might not over-shine its competitor on any perimeter but still it has power,touring capabilities,reliability,looks(which are subjective though,i love how ZMR look as well I still love ZMA-R),good FE in an improved Karizma & every other ingredient which a biker want from a bike like it..

      Karizma HAS its charm in the heart of its lovers..though even we are sad to see how Hero is treating a bike like legendary Karizma..

      to summarize all - Karizma is Rahul Dravid among Indian Bikes..few other bikes may exceed it in "numbers/digits" but still its reliable & dependable as "The Wall"

      Please.. enough of nostalgia, nobody is denying that it's a good product, but it's dated now without any doubt. It's lost it's appeal, youth isn't considering this bike anymore. Back then, till the time P220Fi came in, there wasn't any bike that can be compared to Karizma. But now, there are just too many of them. I suspect, even the all new P150 once it is in market will be comparable to Karizma. That's how dated Karizma has become! a P150 born in 2001 has gone through dramatic improvements, significant technical upgrades and soon will be looking Karizma into eye on many parameters.
      Let's bring down the monster of corruption to it's knees.. please visit http://ipaidabribe.com/

      Comment


      • #33
        I think it has already lost its appeal.....specially now after Newer pulser and CBR launch anyone would agree..
        Last edited by sachin1111; 03-11-2012, 04:55 AM.

        Comment


        • #34
          Why not a Poll???

          @Payeng,

          This was an option between Yes or No so why so much discussion and not a Poll????
          Whats there in a signature?

          Comment


          • #35
            Originally posted by Enthusiastic View Post
            @Payeng,

            This was an option between Yes or No so why so much discussion and not a Poll????

            Good suggestion. Poll added



            Comment


            • #36
              The problem in India is that there is a lack of segmentation in terms of a bike's utility and everything comes down to pricing.. You see a sports model, a street naked and a tourer, everything in the same price bracket and people start comparing them..And that is where they lose the plot.

              Yes, the karizma is outdated but it does it's job well and Im sure no one denies that. Brand wars aside, it was a brilliant product which lost out due to Heros priorities..
              It all begins with a thumb-start -- Oh, wait, I forgot the kill-switch

              Comment


              • #37
                Originally posted by srini View Post
                The problem in India is that there is a lack of segmentation in terms of a bike's utility and everything comes down to pricing.. You see a sports model, a street naked and a tourer, everything in the same price bracket and people start comparing them..And that is where they lose the plot.

                Yes, the karizma is outdated but it does it's job well and Im sure no one denies that. Brand wars aside, it was a brilliant product which lost out due to Heros priorities..
                Very well said Srini. People are comparing ZMR, Pulsar 200NS, R15 but all are different bikes,
                Karizma ZMR - Sports Tourer
                Pulsar 200 Naked Sports - Sports Street Fighter
                YZF R15 - Sports Track Utility.

                It depends on what kind of bike the rider wants. Pricing aside, comparing 3 bikes having different utility is just disrespecting all of them.
                Whats there in a signature?

                Comment


                • #38
                  Originally posted by Enthusiastic View Post
                  Very well said Srini. People are comparing ZMR, Pulsar 200NS, R15 but all are different bikes,
                  Karizma ZMR - Sports Tourer
                  Pulsar 200 Naked Sports - Sports Street Fighter
                  YZF R15 - Sports Track Utility.

                  It depends on what kind of bike the rider wants. Pricing aside, comparing 3 bikes having different utility is just disrespecting all of them.

                  Touring Bike..??

                  The Karizma was/has never ever sold/positioned as a "Touring" bike by Hero.

                  The touring capabilities of the Karizma was actually "discovered" by enthusiasts like xBhpians.. That too just because the Karizma had good low end torque compared to other bikes (barring the Royal Enfields). But now the CBR250R (actually positioned as a Sports Touring bike which but I don't quite agree.. but still..) beats it on the Torque scale.


                  Since its launch in 2003 Hero has always positioned/sold the Karizma as a "PREMIUM" bike. The Karizma R even till date carries the "Premium Sports" tag on the bike and the Karizma ZMR is positioned as.. well.. "Above All".

                  Therefore never mind the Track/Street/Touring capabilites of a bikes/bikes, it is the PREMIUM Sheen that is wearing off the Karizma R/ZMR.


                  [P.S: By the way apart from so called "Touring", people also use the Karizma for "Commuting" (domain of street bikes), "Stunting" (domain of street fighters), and also "Racing" (domain of track bikes)... both in stock and modified form

                  Because this is India.. and we are Indians]



                  Last edited by payeng; 03-11-2012, 12:39 PM.

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by payeng View Post
                    Touring Bike..??

                    The Karizma was/has never ever sold/positioned as a "Touring" bike by Hero.

                    The touring capabilities of the Karizma was actually "discovered" by enthusiasts like xBhpians.. That too just because the Karizma had good low end torque compared to other bikes (barring the Royal Enfields). But now the CBR250R beats it on the Torque scale.


                    Since its launch in 2003 Hero has always positioned/sold the Karizma as a "PREMIUM" bike. The Karizma R even till date carries the "Premium Sports" tag on the bike and the Karizma ZMR is positioned as.. well.. "Above All".

                    Therefore never mind the Track/Street/Touring capabilites of a bikes/bikes, it is the PREMIUM Sheen that is wearing off the Karizma R/ZMR.


                    Thanks for the info
                    Agreed Karizma has nothing to be considered as a premium product apart from the 223cc engine and full fairing of ZMR.
                    Whats there in a signature?

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally posted by srini View Post
                      The problem in India is that there is a lack of segmentation in terms of a bike's utility and everything comes down to pricing.. You see a sports model, a street naked and a tourer, everything in the same price bracket and people start comparing them..And that is where they lose the plot.

                      Yes, the karizma is outdated but it does it's job well and Im sure no one denies that. Brand wars aside, it was a brilliant product which lost out due to Heros priorities..
                      The problem in India is not that people start comparing bikes w.r.t. pricing. The problem here is that the Manufacturers think that India is filled with dumb people who wouldn't understand it if they made segments amongst the motorcycles.

                      Well, I have a newsflash for these *super smart* manufacturers. Cars were segmented a long time back and now nobody compares a Polo 1.6 to a Indigo CS even though, the former (Hatchback) priced higher than the latter (sedan) The segments overlap each other in terms of pricing but still everyone is clear on what not to compare with what.
                      Last edited by antz.bin; 03-11-2012, 01:03 PM. Reason: Polo 1.6
                      Advice is a form of nostalgia.
                      Dispensing it is a way of fishing the past from the disposal, wiping it off, painting over the ugly parts and recycling it for more than it's worth.

                      Antz Travelz!! | South India Exploration Ride | Leh Triplog (Work in progress)

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Originally posted by payeng View Post
                        But now the CBR250R (actually positioned as a Sports Touring bike which but I don't quite agree.. but still..)
                        Who positioned it? Its a sports bike & marketed as Sport Quarter for One World; some bloke who is for or against the bike added that touring word to it!!!

                        Source - http://world.honda.com/CBR250R/
                        Last edited by aargee; 03-11-2012, 12:16 PM.
                        Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
                        Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
                        ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by antz.bin View Post
                          The problem in India is not that people start comparing bikes w.r.t. pricing. The problem here is that the Manufacturers think that India is filled with dumb people who wouldn't understand it if they made segments amongst the motorcycles.
                          The manufacturers are actually smart.. they are right in making out that the normal Indian consumer is actually.. "dumb".

                          They know well that its the "Snob Value" which determines the pricing of the vehicle rather than the actual utility/purpose. How else can one justify the premium just for the Fazer for that "half fairing + twin headlight + extra weight" on what essentially is the same FZ16?


                          Originally posted by antz.bin View Post
                          Well, I have a newsflash for these *super smart* manufacturers. Cars were segmented a long time back and now nobody compares a Vento 1.6 to a Indigo CS even though, the former (Hatchback) priced higher than the latter (sedan) The segments overlap each other in terms of pricing but still everyone is clear on what not to compare with what.
                          Even to a car noob like me, I can make out that the Vento has more snob value that the Indigo (which is equivalent to a Taxi to me).. hence the premium. Ultimately its Snob Value "Pemiumness" which commands a premium (of course the performance + ownership experience has to be commensurate).


                          Originally posted by aargee View Post
                          Who positioned it? Its a sports bike & marketed as Sport Quarter for One World; someone who like or against the bike added that touring word to it!!!
                          I have my reasons for it.. but lets not drag that to this thread.
                          Lets save it for some other day, some other thread.



                          Last edited by payeng; 03-11-2012, 12:44 PM.

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Karizma has lost its appeal?? VISUALLY-Yes,TECHNICALLY-it stll has something left.
                            But its no more a premium bike.
                            Hero can still sell it as a mass bike(like CBZ extreme),if they make some serious changes in looks, just like the new extreme.
                            If they cant touch the engine,so be it . it can still carry on for next five years with some visual upgrades(and seriously a monoshock)....
                            Consider this- It does every thing better than the Fazer,but Fazer takes the cake here,for its breathtaking looks.
                            Last edited by sambit; 03-11-2012, 12:22 PM.
                            HH Dawn - TVS Star City - Yamaha Gladiator - TVS RTR 180 - Honda CBR 250R - Yamaha R3

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Originally posted by payeng View Post
                              But now the CBR250R ([I]actually positioned as a Sports Touring bike which but I don't quite agree
                              Originally posted by payeng View Post
                              I have my reasons for it
                              Payeng...you serious??? Both are your statements right?

                              Originally posted by payeng View Post
                              but lets not drag that to this thread
                              Quite agree. We'll stop with this!!!
                              Skill is what keeps you on a Motorcycle
                              Awareness + Skill is what keeps you out of harm's way
                              ATGATT + Awareness + Skill means you might Live To Ride another day

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Originally posted by antz.bin View Post
                                Well, I have a newsflash for these *super smart* manufacturers. Cars were segmented a long time back and now nobody compares a Vento 1.6 to a Indigo CS even though, the former (Hatchback) priced higher than the latter (sedan) The segments overlap each other in terms of pricing but still everyone is clear on what not to compare with what.
                                Even Vento is a sedan not a hatchback, Polo is the hatchback version on Vento. In any case Vento is much superior to Indigo CS and the price difference is justified.

                                And coming to Karizma, yeah it has lost its appeal. In my opinion not just visually but even technically. Especially the ZMA. ZMR may be having some features but its engine is still the same. The FI is there but the extra cost isn't really worth the gains as compared to ZMA.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X