Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Look further to stay alive.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2-Stroke Indian Bikes.....

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 2-Stroke Indian Bikes.....

    Dear xbhpians,

    Have some doubts running across my mind for quite sometime now regarding 100-135CC 2-Stroke bikes which were available in India.

    As a case study I would like to consider Yamaha RX-Z 5-Speed & Suzuki Shogun compared against a Pulsar 150 & Honda Unicorn 150. I understand that while considering the power of a bike the BHP/Ton ratio and CC/BHP ratio are quite important as per many bike magazines.

    If we consider BHP/Ton ratio of RX-Z it comes around 121.7 BHP/Ton whereas that of a Unicorn comes around 95.6 BHP/Ton. Now as per some sources, the Top speed of an RX-Z is mentioned around 105Kmph (Stock) and that of a unicorn is 113Kmph (Stock).

    Now, both these machines are close to 14BHP (Unicorn being 13.5 to be precise, which is 0.5 BHP lesser), but still the RX loses out in the top speed segment.

    Likewise if we calculate for a Suzuki shogun the BHP/Ton ratio comes around 133.33 BHP/Ton but as per the road test I had read in Overdrive magazine long back & some advertisement in one of the magazines its given as 105Kmph.

    What I want to know is, how on earth are these newer 4-stroke bikes with 13.5 to 14.5 BHP (150CC Bikes) easily do beyond 110Kmph with more kerb weight compared to our yester years 2-Stokers which weighs not more than 110Kgs.

    In fact in overdrive magazines, in the end there used to be vehicle details given along with price list of various manufacturers & there as well I have seen the top speed of RX 135 5-Speed (14BHP) given as 99Kmph, whereas Pulsar 150 or Unicorns given are in excess of 110Kmph.

    In the sources URL which I have mentioned, even the top speed of HH CBZ & TVS Fiero is more than that of RX-Z !!!!

    Can anyone explain why this top speed issues in case of 2-Stroke Indian bikes ?

    With Regards,
    Karthik..


    Sources:

    :: BIKE TRACK TEST: CBZ - FIERO - RXZ - PULSAR 180

    Shootout HONDA UNICORN v NEW BAJAJ PULSAR 150 DTS-I


    PS: I dont want any battle here as to which is better etc etc, but want the technical reason for 2-Strokes being slower as per the data what i have collected.
    Last edited by karthikdattag; 05-11-2010, 03:29 PM. Reason: Unwanted Data crept in by mistake
    TEAM ENERGY INDUCTION

    www.teamenergyinduction.in

    www.youtube.com/channel/UChH1uoyrjGRxnd2h5p075VQ

    www.facebook.com/groups/125955454213254/

  • #2
    Ouf! That was a long one.

    Approved
    The Wheel was a great invention; Two Wheels with a Motor in between was even better!


    BMW Motorrad Days 2011

    Xbhp's Indo-French Kashmir-Ladakh Tour

    Comment


    • #3
      For the last part about 4 strokers having a higher top speed, well it depends greatly on the engine design and gearing as well. The 2 strokes might have higher acceleration in comparison, but owning to shorter gearing to maximize the power out put, they run out of steam at the top end.

      and iirc the top speed of a RXZ 5 speed is claimed to be 110 kmph as per the company.


      Also for the query before that one. Ill be getting a RX-K block soon. So ill update you on the quality and finish.

      Also is there any difference between a RX-K con rod and indian RX con-rod?? i dont think so, since they are the same bikes?? ( other than the RX-K con rod being imported )


      My offerings to the gods of speed -

      - KTM Duke 200
      - Yamaha RXZ 5 speed


      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by karthikdattag View Post
        I fully agree with him but still feel that 130Kmph should have been reached. I have street raced with RX100, RX 135, RXZ, P200 & ZMA on Mysore-B'lore highway & NICE roads & never lost to them in acceleration or top end, but somehow i feel more could have been extracted out of this motor
        @karthik: We at xBhp do not promote street racing in any way, on road, as well as online. i would request you to take proper care and discipline on public roads. Thanks
        Join xBhp On

        Comment


        • #5
          its too long to discuss about each topics but about four stoke and 2 stroke .2 strokes are faster than 4 stokes and the top speed depend on conditions.

          Comment


          • #6
            its all about engine gearing and load..both engines have diff characteristics
            83' RD350 HT
            96' RXG
            97' RXZ
            91'RX100>09'RX165
            2010' HH ZMR

            Comment


            • #7
              TWO strokes are about madness, the rush, the smoke, the noice, the kick, the adrelin rush.

              If you want top speed, do sproaketting man to achieve 130-140kmph on shogun.
              The Magician"

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by jd666 View Post

                Also for the query before that one. Ill be getting a RX-K block soon. So ill update you on the quality and finish.

                Also is there any difference between a RX-K con rod and indian RX con-rod?? i dont think so, since they are the same bikes?? ( other than the RX-K con rod being imported )

                Hey buddy, any updates on these RX-K blocks? I have seen these in person in Yamaha showroom, but have not seen any bike running with it or some performance figures. The port sizes looked similar to a 4TL-10 kit.

                Any new update would be appreciated.
                TEAM ENERGY INDUCTION

                www.teamenergyinduction.in

                www.youtube.com/channel/UChH1uoyrjGRxnd2h5p075VQ

                www.facebook.com/groups/125955454213254/

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by jd666 View Post
                  and iirc the top speed of a RXZ 5 speed is claimed to be 110 kmph as per the company.
                  Correct ... the owner's manual says "use gear 5 for speeds ranging from 50 to 110kmph and above
                  02 Qualis GS
                  03 Zen Carbon
                  62 Jawa 353 "Tank Switch"
                  83 RD350 HT
                  87 Yezdi 350 Twin
                  99 Yamaha YBX
                  03 RXZ 5-speed
                  08 Suzuki Access
                  None Sold!!! All in the Stable

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    @kartik - my block is on the way. once i get my hands on it, i will surely update everyone.


                    My offerings to the gods of speed -

                    - KTM Duke 200
                    - Yamaha RXZ 5 speed


                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Everyone has already mentioned that shorter gearing is the reason why Indian 2 strokes do not have a top speed as high as the 4 strokes. 2 stroke torque curves are not as flat as the 4 strokes. 99% of the total riding done on 2 strokes is done at lower engine speeds where the torque produced by the engine is less..less enough such that the engineers feel the need to make the gearing shorter in order to improve rideability of the bike. Such problems do not exist on 4 strokes because of the much cleaner gas flow and combustion over the entire engine speed range results in much better torque production.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post
                        TWO strokes are about madness, the rush, the smoke, the noice, the kick, the adrelin rush.

                        If you want top speed, do sproaketting man to achieve 130-140kmph on shogun.
                        Seriously Renny u wud be helping me a lot.What kinda sprocketing can bring up that amount of Top end on the Shogun ?????.......suggest me pls.I need to put those mods on my bike.
                        I am now going for a 13/40 Top end increase instead of stock 13/44 which is heavily biased towards acceleration.

                        Also I knew that 2 strokes produced huge amount of low end torque and they did not require shorter gearing.If I consider Yamaha and Suzuki 2 stroke bikes separately,Yamaha always had taller final drive ratio than Suzuki bikes, which means they need not worry about torque.

                        But...but ...but, I am comparing here two bikes
                        take for example,
                        Suzuki Shogun 14bhp/11.4 Nm torque
                        Yamaha FZ16 14bhp/14Nm torque
                        which means a 2T is heavily biased towards Bhp generation,Very good High end.But sorry on low end.Which means if I carry out a sprocket job on My Shogun,it will behave like the R15...........small low end but huge top end.Which means I have to rev the bike hard always in city traffic.While the actual thing comes up on highways.Which is all but very good thing

                        However Yamaha 2ts are different, RX135 produced 12bhp power with 12.25NM torque,looks like an FZ16.So anything cant be concluded here.Hence its different treatment for different bikes.
                        Last edited by MACH50; 05-16-2010, 12:06 AM.
                        Hell's Angel
                        sigpic

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          there is a very interesting comparo between a FZ 16 and a RX100 in this month's autocar or overdrive. It will surely answer a few more questions because even there the RX100 has a higher power to weight ratio than the FZ. Check it out.


                          My offerings to the gods of speed -

                          - KTM Duke 200
                          - Yamaha RXZ 5 speed


                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by RKOLI1983 View Post
                            Everyone has already mentioned that shorter gearing is the reason why Indian 2 strokes do not have a top speed as high as the 4 strokes. 2 stroke torque curves are not as flat as the 4 strokes. 99% of the total riding done on 2 strokes is done at lower engine speeds where the torque produced by the engine is less..less enough such that the engineers feel the need to make the gearing shorter in order to improve rideability of the bike. Such problems do not exist on 4 strokes because of the much cleaner gas flow and combustion over the entire engine speed range results in much better torque production.

                            That was a neat explaination given. Let me just put in some good practical gear ratio figures of some of the common bikes & let see if we can get more inputs from all the experts here.
                            GEAR 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th
                            RX 135 4-Speed 3.180 2.000 1.370 1.000 NA NA
                            RX 135 5-Speed 3.180 2.000 1.370 1.043 0.958 NA
                            FZ16 2.714 1.789 1.318 1.045 0.875 NA
                            SHOGUN 3.083 1.867 1.278 0.954 NA NA
                            FIERO 2.910 1.660 1.210 0.950 NA NA
                            P 150 2.930 1.880 1.380 1.080 0.920 NA
                            CBZ 2.769 1.722 1.263 1.000 0.838 NA
                            R 15 2.833 1.875 1.364 1.143 0.957 0.840
                            ZMA 2.769 1.722 1.263 1.000 0.815 NA
                            RD 350 2.571 1.777 1.318 1.040 0.888 0.785



                            I think if you can see there is not much of a difference between an RX135 4-Speed & Fiero ratios, but still there is some appriciable difference between the top speeds of both these machines (I am comparing stock to stock here).

                            Same thing goes true for RX 135 5-Speed vs. P150 vs. FZ-16.

                            I fully agree that the speed-torque (N-T) curve is quite different for 2-Stroke vs. 4-Stroke, but my question remains, Is BHP/Ton & CC/BHP not important at all for an IC Engine ?

                            An RX 135 is such a light machine with 14BHP, but still is not able to match the top speed of a P150 or a Unicorn (in stock condition).

                            And one more thing here, the sites i had mentioned in the opening thread are really reputed ones & the straight line speed was tested using GPS and not the bike Speedo unit. Also car-bike magazines like overdrive & auto-india are really reputed again & why would they simply mention top speed of RX 135 as 99Kmph ? Trust me, they had given the top speed of Gladiator as 108Kmph & this had really made me thinking.

                            And if we have to go by what company says, then while launching R15, company showroom had banners displaying a 145Kmph top speed, but we all know the true top speed is only 130Kmph which was measured by these reputed car-bike agencies.

                            All you guys can pick up an old edition of overdrive (2002-2004) & check it out for yourself.

                            All i am saying is, it feels sad to be smoked by a newer 4-stroker & only option left is to modify the existing 2-stroke, which always is not a good option.

                            - Karthik..
                            TEAM ENERGY INDUCTION

                            www.teamenergyinduction.in

                            www.youtube.com/channel/UChH1uoyrjGRxnd2h5p075VQ

                            www.facebook.com/groups/125955454213254/

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Gearing is not the only factor, the absolute engine rpm also matters. where a RX135 will not rev to above 8000 rpm, a fiero will go to 9000-10,000 rpm.


                              My offerings to the gods of speed -

                              - KTM Duke 200
                              - Yamaha RXZ 5 speed


                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X