Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Collapse
X
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Originally posted by yudhistir View PostYou have no idea about Geometry. Don't you? And so the forks, forming of tubes, double walled rims, and its "Chassis" So, Eddy/Lance/Wiggins are obese/thin fellas? and do the triathletesA Trek will give you light weight chasis, light weight rims, thick tyres, disc brakes, shimano gearsYou have reprhased this from some internet article. You're not knowledgeable about suspensionCostlier bikes will obviously have better rear suspension but on mountain trails, hard tails are as it is better, unless you are coming down-hill where full suspension will be slightly fasterNope. You need to know the difference between steel, cr-moly, Al 6 series vs 7 series, carbon and titanium.Hercules and Hero both have light weight chasis and rims with thicker tyres, disc brakes and shimano gears available in their range nowYou ride a bicycle/bike, you drive a car ----consecutive posts auto-merged-----Go to their website to check it out or a cycle shop and take a test drive+1. OP/Yud, your posts doesn't make sense. Get the facts right as I mentioned. Thanks God! I stopped reading when you saidOriginally posted by Divya Sharan View PostI would suggest you to take your math lessons again. Some reading 29ers Are Faster than 26ers, Study Finds | Bicycling Nope. I can build a bike much faster than you. Your 20 year old Hercules is strong which you dont need to mention it, but you need to be.24" wheels will always be faster than 26"Last edited by Sherl; 05-15-2016, 11:27 AM.Mustard Yellow 2013 200NS - Suave Bloke in the town
Retd. Royal Enfield Electra 5S 2009 CI - Best of CIs ever made.
Giant Talon 0 29er - Rockshox + X5 + Deore + Exilir + Howitzer
Mongoose Tyax Comp - XCM + Deore + Alivio + Draco + Kenda
Trek 4300D Should I say anything about him? He is the Versys of MTBs
Giant AnyRoad Cyclocross build
S-Works Prevail for the head
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
I almost never knew I need forearms to ride hills! And that 24inch wheels are faster! Wow I really learned something.
Folks.. Listen to the man. There's a key msg which says 'wise man knows where to invest... So be wise and don't invest your time trying to explain someone who thinks he's a teacher. You know what is true wisdom..' avoiding situations where you need to use it '.
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
LOL. Thats quite a sound advise. And as wise man I should pick this for being wise.Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostI almost never knew I need forearms to ride hills! And that 24inch wheels are faster! Wow I really learned something. Folks.. Listen to the man. There's a key msg which says 'wise man knows where to invest... So be wise and don't invest your time trying to explain someone who thinks he's a teacher. You know what is true wisdom..' avoiding situations where you need to use it '.Mustard Yellow 2013 200NS - Suave Bloke in the town
Retd. Royal Enfield Electra 5S 2009 CI - Best of CIs ever made.
Giant Talon 0 29er - Rockshox + X5 + Deore + Exilir + Howitzer
Mongoose Tyax Comp - XCM + Deore + Alivio + Draco + Kenda
Trek 4300D Should I say anything about him? He is the Versys of MTBs
Giant AnyRoad Cyclocross build
S-Works Prevail for the head
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Dear Student,Originally posted by Divya Sharan View PostDear teacher, you can take your knowledge (lop sided) and treasure it for someone/some place else
There's a very good reason people knowledgeable enough on the topic have avoided your posts because they make zero sense.
Also since we're googling stuff on motorcycles - google what CS Santosh rides in the Dakar. He's obviously a better off roader than me or you.
Finally, I don't have a mechanic. I work on my vehicles myself.
You're requested to keep your tone in check. You are welcome to post counter arguments if they make sense in a polite manner. You have FB/Twitter for rants but xBhp won't support such activities.
You are free to leave the forum if you don't like it, but stop posting irrelevant stuff.
I am expected to keep my tone in check while you are free to call me a Troll anytime you wish and term my opinion as Blah Blah Blah
Am I not entitled to react ?
I thought XBHP was an open community and not a dictatorship ran by its moderators
If my teachings dont make sense then it is your closed minded single direction view thats causing the hindrance, not the content of my comments
Google everything I stated and you will realize what is right and what is not
I know CS Santosh, too bad he hasnt won the Dakar yet, just completed it multiple times
BTW, Dakar Off-road uses Enduro type bikes, I never mentioned about them, where did that reference come from ?
Feel free to deactivate my account if you find me flouting the forum rules anytime, this ain't the only forum in the world, as it is its actually being used for Marketing rather than knowledge sharing nowadays
----consecutive posts auto-merged-----
Do you mean to say the Geometry of a Hero/Hercules bicycle is wrong ? How can even a single human ride it ? Wouldnt it cause their body to get crooked ?Originally posted by Sherl View PostYou have no idea about Geometry. Don't you? And so the forks, forming of tubes, double walled rims, and its "Chassis" So, Eddy/Lance/Wiggins are obese/thin fellas? and do the triathletes You have reprhased this from some internet article. You're not knowledgeable about suspension Nope. You need to know the difference between steel, cr-moly, Al 6 series vs 7 series, carbon and titanium. You ride a bicycle/bike, you drive a car ----consecutive posts auto-merged----- +1. OP/Yud, your posts doesn't make sense. Get the facts right as I mentioned. Thanks God! I stopped reading when you said I would suggest you to take your math lessons again. Some reading 29ers Are Faster than 26ers, Study Finds | Bicycling Nope. I can build a bike much faster than you. Your 20 year old Hercules is strong which you dont need to mention it, but you need to be.
Are you a Triathlete ? Is everyone on this forum a Triathlete ? Triathlete is a sport, of course they will use the most expensive stuff to get a performance edge, Do you participate in Triathlon even once in a year ? A Triathlete is not just a cyclist, he is a Triathlete, there is a difference, Triathlons are endurance based where he is expected to swim, cycle and run
Do you play soccer in your city ground wearing professional soccer shoes too ? Are you that low in skill and that much in need of assistance from your tools ?
Does a cyclist who would cycle on road 2 hours a day or over mountain treks over the weekend need to get the same cycle a Triathlete does ? I dont think so
Thank You for comparing my knowledge to Google search results, makes me feel proud of myself
Thinner 29" Road tyres will run faster (see your milkman's cycle tyre) as they are meant to do so, re-read my post entirely again, my comment of 24" tyres was specific to off-road tyres (see any pro off-roader's video on youtube), do you even know the different types of tyres ?
You may be able to build a bike faster than me, but I can disassemble and assemble in the time it takes you to just assemble a bike, I can do twice the work you can do in the same amount of time, see the length of my posts as a proof for the same, I type 10 times you can type
Lets not get into steel, carbon, titanium discussion, as I already said, if you are a weak built person, you will find a normal bike heavy and hence would want the lightest chasis possible, if a milkman can ferry his heavy bicycle all day long, whats your excuse for ferrying something equally heavy for a couple of hours ? Do you go out racing with against motorcycles ? Do you even cycle on the roads or just in your joggers park ? All these factors come into play to determine what kind of a cyclist you are
What's the top speed you have achieved on an expensive light weight bicycle ? Have you compared it to what you can achieve on a normal bicycle ?
How many calories do you burn when you cycle an expensive light weight bicycle ? Have you compared it to what you can achieve on a normal bicycle ?
Do you even track this stuff ?
Here is what a pure cyclist is supposed to be :
----consecutive posts auto-merged-----
How many up-hill and down-hill passes have you had ?Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostI almost never knew I need forearms to ride hills! And that 24inch wheels are faster! Wow I really learned something.
Folks.. Listen to the man. There's a key msg which says 'wise man knows where to invest... So be wise and don't invest your time trying to explain someone who thinks he's a teacher. You know what is true wisdom..' avoiding situations where you need to use it '.
During bunny hop you are supposed to lift up the front with the strength of your arms, needs strong forearms
When going up-hill there are times where you are supposed to pick up the cycle and carry it, needs strong arms
When going down-hill all your body weight is onto your arms, if you dont have stong forearms, sooner or later you are bound to get RSI, have seen quite a few guys suffer due to it
Experience teaches, guess you are not so experienced to realize it yet
Check this Video :
Now Question yourself, Would you be able to do any of this without strong forearms ?
Guess this explains everyones fascination on this thread with light weight bicycles, they dont have a good build and instead of focussing on building themselves they just go and buy a really expensive cycle which in the end will be counterproductive as it does not makes you stronger or better, just fills up for your shortcomings
Try cycling a normal bike on the mountains, you will realize what you are lacking within minutes
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Mods: Now that you have the green signal, you can go ahead and ban people who just know about boasting about themselves.
Others : Youncan continue your discussion, lets just behave that some people dont even exist on this forum, lets just ignore them, they are not worth wasting our precious time.Fare thee well xBhp, All the best for being the biggest name in corporate world
FAQs-RTR owners
Helmet Range
Your Friendly MotoVlogger
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Yudhishtir u r a self proclaimed teacher! Kool be that .... But don't call out on anyone's else's experience without knowing him/her, https://www.strava.com/athletes/152873 , that's 20k.kms that's just from time I've been using strava. As far as I'm concerned ive owned all types of bikes expect titanium. And a good bike can go a long way for serious cycling. You may disagree that's your call but it doesn't make you right, neither does it give you to personally call out on people's experience if they differ from your opinion. Your tone makes me feel you're a 'I know it all' kinda person, but never presume others know less. That's my only advice to you. As far as those who are serious about discussing cycling in general will continue to do so without personal mudslinging.
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
I am actually thinking of approaching Danny and just force him to switch to Hercules/Hero. WTH is he doing riding a carbon fibre & blah blah bike??? Those stunts can be done on any god damn cycle, as per 'O Supreme Lord who speaks only truth & nothing else'!!"HASTA LA VICTORIA, SIEMPRE !" - Chesigpic
http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/18983-spicy-sour-sweet-short-honeymoon-trip.html
http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/20306-pursuit-swarghat.html#post716409
http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/2...sary-trip.html
http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/2...adventure.html
http://www.xbhp.com/talkies/tourer/2...j-monsoon.html
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
I beat you in 2016.Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostYudhishtir u r a self proclaimed teacher! Kool be that .... But don't call out on anyone's else's experience without knowing him/her, https://www.strava.com/athletes/152873 , that's 20k.kms that's just from time I've been using strava. As far as I'm concerned ive owned all types of bikes expect titanium. And a good bike can go a long way for serious cycling. You may disagree that's your call but it doesn't make you right, neither does it give you to personally call out on people's experience if they differ from your opinion. Your tone makes me feel you're a 'I know it all' kinda person, but never presume others know less. That's my only advice to you. As far as those who are serious about discussing cycling in general will continue to do so without personal mudslinging.

Mustard Yellow 2013 200NS - Suave Bloke in the town
Retd. Royal Enfield Electra 5S 2009 CI - Best of CIs ever made.
Giant Talon 0 29er - Rockshox + X5 + Deore + Exilir + Howitzer
Mongoose Tyax Comp - XCM + Deore + Alivio + Draco + Kenda
Trek 4300D Should I say anything about him? He is the Versys of MTBs
Giant AnyRoad Cyclocross build
S-Works Prevail for the head
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
I don't bother using fit calculators for that reason, as long as a bike size is in the ballpark, i will happily set it up for comfort! I believe in the Peter White article on bike fit.Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostIn cycling while size has some science to it, it's more to do with personal liking as well. a 5'7" - 6" height person is luckiest in this regard as a bigger range of sizing & cockpit adjustment is available to them based on how their personal preference is. eg I'm a 5'10" and I've had a 54cm Saroni, Surly 56cm, my current Scott is 52cm, Cinelli is 53 & Olmo is 55
. But again not all bikes have exact same stem lengths or stack heights. So that way I've had a range of stems too. My Cinelli has a 95mm, Soctt 110mm, Olmo 100mm and I had Surly with 100. then 90 and 85! I'm from old school thought, so For me It basically boils down to what the bike is for, how it's gonna be ridden & then the cockpit & reach & drop etc is decided accordingly over a period. Tough the general philosophy is Racing bikes/ speed demons needs to be shorter frame, Touring needs to be bigger/biggest in your size range & endurance/ serious recreation falls somewhere in between.
To be honest Monk for 70k this bike is a killer, full Carbon frame+fork, mid-range components and very good wheelest & top-notch cockpit components. A single Deda bar costs 4k & stem costs 2.5k alone. These are not what you get in a OEM bike unless you're buying flagship or top line bikes. If you're interested get it, you can check with some of the Bangalore bikers like Venkateshwara, Anatha, Arvind from Happy earth about me & Prabuddha
& this deal. The reason he's selling the Fuji is he's just built an expensive custom steel bike from Psynide and actually needs space. If I myself didn't already have a carbon & other 3 bikes this would be mine.
The carbon is what is the most attractive to me thoughBicycle fitting is a subject most people find quite mysterious. Fitting systems with charts and graphs, computer software, measuring devices and "rules of thumb" make for a lot of confusion. But I believe it's really quite simple. Bicycle fit involves compromises. Compromises between comfort and performance, quick acceleration and handling stability, top speed and "taking in the scenery".
I have a steel framed Planet-X Kaffenback with 105, Mavic wheels and Schwalbe Marathon Plus 35mm tyres (Did i mention i like comfort
) In fact i did consider asking Psynide for a frame, that didn't happen, but maybe sometime in the future.
The question is not whether this bike is a good deal. It clearly is and the cycling community in India is relatively small, so easy to cross check bikes/ cyclists
The question for me is do i really need another bike, which i will use for the same purpose! The advantage being that this bike will be lighter and faster, but my legs will continue to be as unfit!
The Planet-X i bought from Vandit in Andaman. So the entire transaction was done based on trust, without me actually having seen the bike or even knowing the gentleman. Even my first bike the Trek 4300 was bought from someone in Bombay whose name i don't even know! Needless to say, the last thing i am worried about is your friends Fuji turning out to be a Hero Jet
Biking is not about what you have between your legs, its all about how well you use it!!!!!!!
Give your details here if you want to help your fellow xBhpian stranded in your city
Touring Blog: Cycling in Mongolia!
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Well when I read kaffenback my eyebrows went up... Vandit is my good friend 😀. Believe me you must buy a Carbon if not this one still, I bought one just to understand what's the hype. Initially I was comparing it with my favorite steel bike but I realized later that carbon is a different thing altogether. I still love riding cromoly bikes. And honestly after riding so many bikes I realized that its not the materials which matter as such, the crux of the matter is the geometry and the nuances of the setup which is the true flavor of the bike. And I that I found a personal liking to Italian stage geometry. Which says why my 2 best bikes are Italian. Both opposite end of the spectrum in materials, purpose and age... Yet both have that same flavor while riding. Both are completely different yet same in crux, both sublime handlers yet with a nip and equally comfortable. I guess I'm sounding like a wine connoisseur than a cyclist!
Anyway point is unless you try different types and bikes you don't really know how flavourful they are. The whole game of how components then affect the package is a different ball game all together. You know me and Prabuddha my partner many times exchange bikes for a ride just to taste more flavours 😁.
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Hehehe 2015 N 2016 haven't really been good for cycling. Too much bogged down with work. Hoping to change that after the heat wave passes off. As such my randonneuring days are over I'm a weekend warrior as of now.Originally posted by Sherl View PostI beat you in 2016.


Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
I love my Kaffe to bits. With a steel frame and no extra curves that you see on modern cycles, a lot of the 'dilli cyclists' think i am riding a painted Hero Hawk or something! Probably why i like it even more! That and the fact that most people haven't heard the name of the company, much less the model!Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostWell when I read kaffenback my eyebrows went up... Vandit is my good friend 😀. Believe me you must buy a Carbon if not this one still, I bought one just to understand what's the hype. Initially I was comparing it with my favorite steel bike but I realized later that carbon is a different thing altogether. I still love riding cromoly bikes. And honestly after riding so many bikes I realized that its not the materials which matter as such, the crux of the matter is the geometry and the nuances of the setup which is the true flavor of the bike. And I that I found a personal liking to Italian stage geometry. Which says why my 2 best bikes are Italian. Both opposite end of the spectrum in materials, purpose and age... Yet both have that same flavor while riding. Both are completely different yet same in crux, both sublime handlers yet with a nip and equally comfortable. I guess I'm sounding like a wine connoisseur than a cyclist!
Anyway point is unless you try different types and bikes you don't really know how flavourful they are. The whole game of how components then affect the package is a different ball game all together.
I have ridden carbon, briefly. But never owned anything from that cool material. Except if you consider Carbon Paper we used as kids
A risky statement. If you had missed out the word 'bikes', it would have had a whole different meaningYou know me and Prabuddha my partner many times exchange bikes for a ride just to taste more flavours 😁.
Biking is not about what you have between your legs, its all about how well you use it!!!!!!!
Give your details here if you want to help your fellow xBhpian stranded in your city
Touring Blog: Cycling in Mongolia!
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
@monkey Bad ass mind.Originally posted by The Monk View PostI love my Kaffe to bits. With a steel frame and no extra curves that you see on modern cycles, a lot of the 'dilli cyclists' think i am riding a painted Hero Hawk or something! Probably why i like it even more! That and the fact that most people haven't heard the name of the company, much less the model!
I have ridden carbon, briefly. But never owned anything from that cool material. Except if you consider Carbon Paper we used as kids
A risky statement. If you had missed out the word 'bikes', it would have had a whole different meaning
What bike did you ride in Mongolia??
But I really like those curves in the *bikes*!Last edited by Sherl; 05-18-2016, 03:40 PM.Mustard Yellow 2013 200NS - Suave Bloke in the town
Retd. Royal Enfield Electra 5S 2009 CI - Best of CIs ever made.
Giant Talon 0 29er - Rockshox + X5 + Deore + Exilir + Howitzer
Mongoose Tyax Comp - XCM + Deore + Alivio + Draco + Kenda
Trek 4300D Should I say anything about him? He is the Versys of MTBs
Giant AnyRoad Cyclocross build
S-Works Prevail for the head
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Quite frankly, I never started the mudslinging, you can go through the posts again to check the same, yes, I am a self proclaimed teacher as I dont have a B. ED degree yet, what you have mentioned applies to all, hence, they shouldn't be assuming my experience, that includes you as well, just because I prefer a heavy cheap bicycle doesn't mean I haven't had experience with any jazzy stuff you might have used, you don't even know my physique nor the bikes I have ridden, on the other hand I can clearly see you slender built from your pic and can make an opinion very clearly, which I already have in my previous post as a general consensus for the cyclists in this thread. Never presume someone who has a different opinion than yours has less knowledge and don't just follow into other opinions without checking the facts first.Originally posted by Kaushik Iyer View PostYudhishtir u r a self proclaimed teacher! Kool be that .... But don't call out on anyone's else's experience without knowing him/her, https://www.strava.com/athletes/152873 , that's 20k.kms that's just from time I've been using strava. As far as I'm concerned ive owned all types of bikes expect titanium. And a good bike can go a long way for serious cycling. You may disagree that's your call but it doesn't make you right, neither does it give you to personally call out on people's experience if they differ from your opinion. Your tone makes me feel you're a 'I know it all' kinda person, but never presume others know less. That's my only advice to you. As far as those who are serious about discussing cycling in general will continue to do so without personal mudslinging.
Comment
-
Re: How to select a bicycle according to your needs and budget?
Never knew, xbhp had a thread for cycles.
Well, I started in to the cycling scene two years ago, once I moved to Sweden. The whole experience was pleasant with me clocking close to 5000 kilometers. I almost bought a roadie, a cheap one 60 K INR last year. But postponed my decision as I wasn't quite sure on how long I will be here in Sweden. But now, I got a good offer and will be here for next seven years at least.
So, dropped by Bianchi showroom here which I only window shopped before and drooled over all their bikes.
I will be getting Bianchi Intrepida Ultegra and the following.
Jacket, shorts
Saddle bag
Tools and spares
Rear view mirror
Gloves
Bottle cage, I believe one will come with the bike, need to check.
Pedal and shoes (free with the bike).
Pump
Future
Garmin 810 performance bundle (by September '16)
Interesting to see a different view on expensive bikes here on the forum, well, different strokes for different people, eh?
Anyway, hope to add more value to this thread in coming months.
Will definitely share my experiences here.
Last edited by ecenandu; 06-07-2016, 09:02 PM.
Comment



Comment