Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

All the gear all the time (ATGATT).

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

YAMAHA FZ-S or TVS APACHE RTR 180 ?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    alright.......i've been through all sorts of research until now...
    I'll get my money,by the end of this month.
    80% chance now for the new apache rtr 160.
    considered the mileage factor.that is why i dropped the 180.
    i'll let you guys informed,whatever bike i buy(ie,fz-s or rtr160)....

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by Nithyan.S View Post
      alright.......i've been through all sorts of research until now...
      I'll get my money,by the end of this month.
      80% chance now for the new apache rtr 160.
      considered the mileage factor.that is why i dropped the 180.
      i'll let you guys informed,whatever bike i buy(ie,fz-s or rtr160)....
      if possible buy rtr 180,mileage difference is hardly 3-5 kmpl,but you get a better ride.
      and the question remains why do i race?
      every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

      #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
      #overkill is underrated.
      #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
      #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

      (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

      Comment


      • #33
        First decide you want superb handling and macho styling or agility....in my personal experience on both the machines Apache is not that good handling machine and in terms of looks though its subjective it doesn't comes near FZ series...and more of all please go for a test ride for the real feel....if you want raw power only go for Pulsars like 200ns or 220...mileage factor will almost be same..I have a Fazer and before buying that I had test ridden both of these and I can say refinement and performance wise Yamaha is way ahead than TVS....mileage wont be a big concern if you drive properly as I am getting around 43-44 in the city itself...
        Heart Meets Soul when you ride...


        Life is Calling for you....
        sigpic

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally posted by Toxicbiker View Post
          and performance wise Yamaha is way ahead than TVS....
          not really if you pit fz series against rtr series.
          and the question remains why do i race?
          every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

          #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
          #overkill is underrated.
          #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
          #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

          (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

          Comment


          • #35
            Hey man,

            People here are having great dig on FZ. Bit of increase in displacement and bit of more power is not the matter. It's the product.

            Jusst go and see the number of threads for FZ compared to Apache 180, you will be surpised.

            Just think about Yamaha Rx 100. The 15 year old even sells for its cost price on second hand.

            You must also understand that Fz is a proven bike which resurrected Yamaha company. Just don't compensate for a bit higher power and cc and whatever low or high-end they speak blah blah.

            TVS guys can't keep their bikes for more than 5 years right from TVS fiero and apache 150 and now soon they may disappear apache 160.

            I will tell you go for FZ and you will not regret and you will save money with peace of mind.

            The only thing is SVC guys, they are not upto the standard but still if you want your bike to stay long and well with you then go for FZ.

            Comment


            • #36
              Originally posted by jonahmano View Post
              Jusst go and see the number of threads for FZ compared to Apache 180, you will be surpised.
              so you choose a bike according to the no of post?
              Originally posted by jonahmano View Post
              Just don't compensate for a bit higher power and cc and whatever low or high-end they speak blah blah.
              a bit higher power....gosh man...you are yet to ride a rtr i guess
              Originally posted by jonahmano View Post
              TVS guys can't keep their bikes for more than 5 years right from TVS fiero and apache 150 and now soon they may disappear apache 160.
              a 5 year cycle is good for a product right?
              Originally posted by jonahmano View Post
              I will tell you go for FZ and you will not regret and you will save money
              you are paying premium over normal 150 cc and your fuel expenses of fz are almost equal to rtr.so how are you saving money?
              and the question remains why do i race?
              every finishing line is the begining of a new race.

              #i have learnt to manipulate my own adrenaline and the perception of biking is different.
              #overkill is underrated.
              #how random roads may appear there is always a destination.sigpic
              #i don't subscribe to co-incidence,either it is the rider or the other moron on the road

              (:)people keeps on saying add spark to life, bajaj got hold of that idea and added an extra spark to bike.

              Comment


              • #37
                Even though 150 vs 150 cc has been done to death. For your sake here are a few liners from my end:

                FZ/Fazer/FZ-S:

                The Good Side:
                1) Low end grunt
                2) Super fun at cornering very confidence inspiring thanks to rear tire.
                3) Refined engine
                4) Grippy tires
                5) Mileage around 40-45 kmpl based on riding habits
                6) Spare parts not that expensive
                7) Robust engine and good braking power even with a drum at the back. My stock brakes are still strong even after 22,000 kms.

                The Bad Side:
                1) Tires are soft compound.. Doesn't like pot holed and nail loaded roads.
                2) Post 85 kmph struggles to hit 90+ kmph and beyond
                3) If run in not done properly, mileage goes down drastically to 28-30s kmpl
                4) Poor 35 watt headlight not good for highways.


                RTRs

                The Good Side
                1) Good fun with power at the top end.
                2) Availability of ABS as an option
                3) Mileage pretty decent
                4) Parts also not that expensive
                5)Price point better.
                6) Cornering not that bad

                The Bad Side
                1) Vibey engine compared to Yamaha's
                2) Don't like the low end torque
                3) Stock TVS tires suck and are prone to slipping when raining. Change to MRFs
                4) Not sure about the quality control, the RTR owners can fill in on this one.


                Cheers,
                A quote by a toilet, " use me well, keep me clean, i would never tell anybody whatever i have seen.." :P

                Comment


                • #38
                  I am not saying you to buy Apache RTR Series ...
                  but as i own it i will tell you my honest review about bike

                  Handling, As good as you can bend it... one of the most easiest zig zagger i can say even on traffic...

                  Pick up :- Incomparable.

                  Cornering :- Easily in category of NS & Duke... its Fun & easy to do cornering..

                  Braking :- Again, the best Brakes available in Indian Market (Without ABS), With ABS there is no match ...

                  Mid End Torque :- Very Good. Won't dissapoint you...




                  Cons are As below ,

                  Viby Engine at Certain RPM's ...
                  After 110km/h Bike doesn't seems to be gripping on Road very hard, feel like you will be flying offf sooon
                  Heavy Rain & rear Tyre will be on air again

                  RTR wont dissapoint you in any Case for sure, very fun loving Riding bike .. \m/
                  Pride & Prejudice: Ladakh Ride,

                  Ride To Raajmachi - Highway, Off Roading, Tent fire & Dhamaal

                  Madness in Rajasthan - Travelogue
                  www.facebook.com/shahbaz008

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by sayank10 View Post
                    so you choose a bike according to the no of post?

                    why not? a bike's reliability, re-sale value, and product interest depends on how much they talk about the bike, surely your Apache is no match to FZ in this matter

                    a bit higher power....gosh man...you are yet to ride a rtr i guess

                    I rode Apache RTR 160 and it was just one year old, felt like I'm riding a 10 year old bike. What are you going to do with that power. Here in India the speed limit of bike is 50km/hr. Forget about revving @120km/hr.

                    a 5 year cycle is good for a product right?

                    It is very good to recycle a product for people like you who have money to spend every year on new bikes. I know how much I wandered around for my Fiero F2 for want of parts. I even had to travel another state to get a brake pad. The more early the bike vanishes the more less you will get the re-sale value

                    you are paying premium over normal 150 cc and your fuel expenses of fz are almost equal to rtr.so how are you saving money?
                    I was talking about spending 95k on Apache RTR ABS, it is better to buy FZ-S for 82k and save money. And about mileage, the new Yamaha FZ-S will give 45km/l.

                    Finally I want to say that you must understand why FZ is so costly because it is reliable. people still buy it because it is Yamaha. As RX still sells so will FZ

                    Long live YAMAHA


                    Answers in Bold, final thoughts in bold italic

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      I recommend Going for FZ against Apache...
                      Don't Honk Unnecessarily

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        To: The Thread Starter,

                        FZ16 is anytime a better product over the RTRs, (Just assuming that you are looking to buy a bike to be your everyday companion and not for racing purpose)

                        Reason,

                        1) RTR 180 is quicker than FZ by a few secs, is that a deciding factor to you? are you going to hit 0-100Kmph in xxyy secs every time?

                        2) FZ has the best handling capabilities next to the R15 and the RTR can never be a match to it for smooth daily rides. At 100Kph you have more road stability and confidence than the RTR.

                        3) FZ has the best suspension system for daily rides, coz RTRs are stiffer and track oriented.

                        4) To my eyes the FZ is always a tad better than any street bike out there, get the FZ in a new shade and you are sure to be noticed.

                        5) Mileage almost the same.

                        6) On the FZ you sail smooth and stress-free unlike the RTR with its unpleasant vibrations, which may annoy you in a period of time.

                        7) Even without ABS the FZ offers a quick and sharp bite and never heard/witnessed brake locking.

                        8) Engine refinement, FZ is from YAMAHA and RTR is from TVS, you should be knowing the difference.

                        In simple terms if you get the FZ you will be a silent....happy man, Riding everyday just like having coffee with your loved one on a Sunday evening. Whereas with the RTR your ride becomes a rola-costa everyday, good for a short spin and not advisable for a longer commitment.
                        Last edited by HarishK; 07-16-2012, 11:53 AM.
                        https://www.facebook.com/harishtheboss

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by Nithyan.S View Post
                          I'm 20 yrs old...5'4'' inch tall..60 kg.
                          I've been riding a kinetic till this date...I will be buying a bike coming august.
                          I'm confused with Yamaha Fz and the Tvs apache rtr 180.
                          Problem is that I like both bikes very much.....my major considerations are STYLE AND POWER....i'll be riding only 20kms everyday.
                          I rode both bikes,still could'nt make a decision.
                          While Fz scores for its super looks,apache tops in power...my parents are only concerned with the price and they ask me only to go for the less costly one...
                          but i dont want to make a decision just like that...Which gives more value to money? I've heard very good about the superb yamaha engine,and that TVS falls behind in riding quality and spare parts....But still I like the sound and throttle of rtr...so...really in a dilemma....please guys.....help me
                          I have personal experience on both the machines.
                          According to me both are very different in specification and performance,
                          in FZ u ll get very smooth engine, cool styling, but lags in power and throttle response.

                          In RTR u ll get brute power, very excellent throttle response, advanced features like petal disc brakes on front and rear,ABS(optional) Super meter console with facility to store three high speeds and 0-60 timing, and very comfortable riding posture for ur height, Quality is not a matter if u r a good rider maintain ur bike with out skipping periodic services.the only corn i found in rtr is the vibration, what ever u do , how ever u maintain vibration will exist, it is nothing but inborn.

                          both the bikes are good in handling,and city riding. If u r an enthusiast seeking for better throttle response, touring ability, better high speed, u want to store ur high speeds, Advanced features like ABS, u dont worry about spending some extra k rupees U shoul go for apache.

                          If u want very smooth engine, u use only for daily commute, less price tag u should go for FZ S

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Originally posted by HarishK View Post
                            To: The Thread Starter,

                            FZ16 is anytime a better product over the RTRs, (Just assuming that you are looking to buy a bike to be your everyday companion and not for racing purpose)

                            Reason,

                            1) RTR 180 is quicker than FZ by a few secs, is that a deciding factor to you? are you going to hit 0-100Kmph in xxyy secs every time?

                            If a Bike is few seconds quicker then other that means some1 has done some work over there, a Hard work. One see all aspect while buying a new bike.


                            2) FZ has the best handling capabilities next to the R15 and the RTR can never be a match to it for smooth daily rides. At 100Kph you have more road stability and confidence than the RTR.

                            Well that was blind Comment I would say, forget r15!!! under 1.20lakh RTR is best in terms of handling & cornering, u can ask any FZ owner how they are comfirtable with Cornering at high speed, add Braking to that & there is no match in this segmant


                            3) FZ has the best suspension system for daily rides, coz RTRs are stiffer and track oriented.

                            Is it ?MIG with Spring add isnt a good suspension ?Comm'on :/

                            4) To my eyes the FZ is always a tad better than any street bike out there, get the FZ in a new shade and you are sure to be noticed.

                            Buying bike to get noticed ? []

                            5) Mileage almost the same.

                            6) On the FZ you sail smooth and stress-free unlike the RTR with its unpleasant vibrations, which may annoy you in a period of time.

                            *Depends*... Yes FZ is smooth no doubt.

                            7) Even without ABS the FZ offers a quick and sharp bite and never heard/witnessed brake locking.

                            Apache with or w/o ABS got best braking. *Period

                            8) Engine refinement, FZ is from YAMAHA and RTR is from TVS, you should be knowing the difference.

                            What was that ? :O

                            Replied In Bold
                            Pride & Prejudice: Ladakh Ride,

                            Ride To Raajmachi - Highway, Off Roading, Tent fire & Dhamaal

                            Madness in Rajasthan - Travelogue
                            www.facebook.com/shahbaz008

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Originally posted by avinashtherider View Post

                              both the bikes are good in handling,and city riding. If u r an enthusiast seeking for better throttle response, touring ability, better high speed, u want to store ur high speeds, advanced features like abs, u dont worry about spending some extra k rupees u shoul go for apache.

                              If u want very smooth engine, u use only for daily commute, less price tag u should go for fz s

                              bingo
                              +111111
                              Pride & Prejudice: Ladakh Ride,

                              Ride To Raajmachi - Highway, Off Roading, Tent fire & Dhamaal

                              Madness in Rajasthan - Travelogue
                              www.facebook.com/shahbaz008

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Originally posted by shahbaz63 View Post


                                If a Bike is few seconds quicker then other that means some1 has done some work over there, a Hard work. One see all aspect while buying a new bike.

                                RTR is faster than FZ, but that doesn't mean FZ will be at standstill. Take my word, In daily city traffic ride both the bikes will perform almost the same. Coz mostly daily riders don't shift often to generate peak torque as racers do in tracks.

                                Well that was blind Comment I would say, forget r15!!! under 1.20lakh RTR is best in terms of handling & cornering, u can ask any FZ owner how they are comfirtable with Cornering at high speed, add Braking to that & there is no match in this segmant

                                The FZ can do all that an RTR can do at the corners with more confidence. At-least you got to accept the fact that FZ has got MRF Zappers, while RTRs have got TVS tyres on them (Goto to RTR ownership thread for more info).

                                Is it ?MIG with Spring add isnt a good suspension ?Comm'on :/

                                Not sure what you meant by this comment, so a MIG twin is better than Monoshock? Common bro, we are guiding someone, not arguing.

                                Buying bike to get noticed ? []

                                So why the RTR FI got the orange shade? I hope it was to draw attention and get noticed. Not sure what was so funny here.

                                *Depends*... Yes FZ is smooth no doubt.

                                Thats because the bike is comparatively a better package for daily use.

                                Apache with or w/o ABS got best braking. *Period

                                Needn't comment on RTR brakes, but FZ still does serve the purpose without any glitches.

                                What was that ? :O

                                Both Yamaha and TVS are into bike manufacturing, to know about the reputation and standards, kindly do some research on them.The engine refinement goes as per the respective manufacturer's reputation.

                                Hope that answers
                                Last edited by HarishK; 07-16-2012, 02:23 PM.
                                https://www.facebook.com/harishtheboss

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X