Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
New ZMA or P220 DTS-i?
Collapse
X
-
I beg to defer. There are proper air channeling vents on ZMR. The engine will be durable than its close competitors.Originally posted by pulsating220 View Postalso with the absence of liquid cooling a full fairing is a disaster in the long run.
It is not all about 'Power' all the time and a P220 is not leagues ahead of a ZMR. There are other good 'plus' points to ZMR over a P220. ZMR is for those who wants enough power on highway (yes, it has enough power on highway to cruise at 100-100 kmph for whole day).
The instrumentation in my Avatar pic is not 'ZMR'. It is VFR1200. BTW, I am not the owner of a ZMR yet.Originally posted by kochumvk View Post**>Love the instrumentation cluster on your ZMR
Last edited by ravi@17bhp; 02-12-2010, 02:34 AM.HH Karizma (Current) || CBF Stunner PGM-FI || Honda CB Unicorn Dazzler
Honda Aviator || Kinetic Flyte || Kinetic Blaze || HH Splendor
Two ZMAs, 9 Days in Western Ghats
Comment
-
Please do not take marketing lines used by various manufacturers too seriously
^^fail to understand what road presence has to do with a motorcycle and motorcycling?
it goes well with a custom/cruiser, that is what they are designed for,
if any motorcycle puts a bigger smile than the ones you are considering, you have your answer
and someone may prefer a P-135LS over P-150(i would) many would not, so as individuals, see what suits you
Comment
-
Originally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostI beg to defer. There are proper air channeling vents on ZMR. The engine will be durable than its close competitors.
It is not all about 'Power' all the time and a P220 is not leagues ahead of a ZMR. There are other good 'plus' points to ZMR over a P220. ZMR is for those who wants enough power on highway (yes, it has enough power on highway to cruise at 100-100 kmph for whole day).
The instrumentation in my Avatar pic is not 'ZMR'. It is VFR1200. BTW, I am not the owner of a ZMR yet.
the p220 dtsi can cruise at 120 constantly too dude...so doesnt the 220 have an edge over zmr over cruising??I RuLe Da HeAvEn, I RuLe Da heLL,I RuLe Da UnIvErSe, As HuMaNiTy FeLL
sigpic
http://www.orkut.co.in/Main#Profile?...79612188840642
http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#!/...00000077242611
Comment
-
how many custom cruiser do you actually see on the indian roads which demand AHEM-AHEM "road presence" ?? i am a student of journalism & mass comm,and tv reporting is my forte,shot a review of the zmr vs p220 for my college and i stood 2nd! so,NO MARKETING LINES (atleast from my end)!Originally posted by sheelpriye View PostPlease do not take marketing lines used by various manufacturers too seriously
^^fail to understand what road presence has to do with a motorcycle and motorcycling?
it goes well with a custom/cruiser, that is what they are designed for,
if any motorcycle puts a bigger smile than the ones you are considering, you have your answer
and someone may prefer a P-135LS over P-150(i would) many would not, so as individuals, see what suits youwhen the strech is empty, my bike tells me to wring its throttle and give my commands!
Comment
-
That is what they are used for, POSING and all the customs cruisers DEMAND Road presence,they are nicheOriginally posted by pulsating220 View Posthow many custom cruiser do you actually see on the indian roads which demand AHEM-AHEM "road presence" ??
i wasn't saying this to you, my post just happened below yoursso,NO MARKETING LINES (atleast from my end)!
and yes, i asked you--what does motorcycle and motorcycling have to do with road presence?
Marketing lines is about people believing the tag"the fastest Indian"/Racing DNA and hence forth
Comment
-
Originally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostI beg to defer. There are proper air channeling vents on ZMR. The engine will be durable than its close competitors.
It is not all about 'Power' all the time and a P220 is not leagues ahead of a ZMR. There are other good 'plus' points to ZMR over a P220. ZMR is for those who wants enough power on highway (yes, it has enough power on highway to cruise at 100-100 kmph for whole day).
A p220 will not be as stressed as zmr at 100 kmph . 220 will do 100 at 6200 rpm, well below the red line.And the 220 is tall geared the fifth is so tall.
ZMR will be a calm machine any way.
Where is the red line on ZMR?
Is there any genuine HH designed stuff on ZMR ??Originally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostThe instrumentation in my Avatar pic is not 'ZMR'. It is VFR1200. BTW, I am not the owner of a ZMR yet.

But still it looks good.
And the RTC is an added advantage.
Any one raced ZMR with 2009 p180(17.02 ps) or RTR 180 on a highway?
What was the results?
Comment
-
Did I say P220 is not a cruiser?Originally posted by satan69in View Postthe p220 dtsi can cruise at 120 constantly too dude...so doesnt the 220 have an edge over zmr over cruising??
I reiterate again and again and again, P220 is more powerful than a ZMR. What I would like to say is 100 kmph speed is enough for touring on Indian highways and do not take the Karizma out of the league just for the sake of 10 kmph speed edge. There are still a large section of people who likes its refinement, reliability, and the durability of the engine. It is still an able handler. That is why people are still buying it. If P220 is everything, why people are buying a ZMA?
We have to explain the positives and negatives and allow the members to choose based on them. Now, do not say P220 has all positives.
I would like respect for both bikes. It pinches when somebody ridicules.
There is a joint venture between Honda of Japan and Hero of India. Hero gets technology from Honda and pays royalty for that. Now that the technology of Honda is good, Hero Honda's bikes are good. Hero Honda does not have an R&D, because they are paying to get the technology from Honda. Hero Honda is not copying technology from Honda ; they are just buying the technology from Honda. VFR1200 is a Honda product, so there is no scope for copying. You said the design is good, then why bother who designed it. Ultimately, we need to see how good the product that we use is good.Originally posted by kochumvk View PostIs there any genuine HH designed stuff on ZMR ??
But still it looks good.
Last edited by ravi@17bhp; 02-12-2010, 01:46 PM.HH Karizma (Current) || CBF Stunner PGM-FI || Honda CB Unicorn Dazzler
Honda Aviator || Kinetic Flyte || Kinetic Blaze || HH Splendor
Two ZMAs, 9 Days in Western Ghats
Comment
-
Originally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostThere is a joint venture between Honda of Japan and Hero of India. Hero gets technology from Honda and pays royalty for that. Now that the technology of Honda is good, Hero Honda's bikes are good. Hero Honda does not have an R&D, because they are paying to get the technology from Honda. Hero Honda is not copying technology from Honda ; they are just buying the technology from Honda. VFR1200 is a Honda product, so there is no scope for copying. You said the design is good, then why bother who designed it. Ultimately, we need to see how good the product that we use is good.
I was unaware about the absence of an R&D team for HH.
But still have the following doubts:
Will Honda supply serious engineering stuff to HH sice Honda is directly operating in India ?
Is it not a shame HH is unable to mature like bajaj and tvs?
Comment
-
Hero Honda is serving well to the commuter segment in India for years and they are happy with it. Every company going Bajaj or TVS way may not be good. When things are fine why to disturb it. Remember Hero HOnda is world's largest bike maker for the 9th consecutive year. So, the technical colloboration is working very well for them and naturally they do not want to distrub that. They may form an R&D if the contract with Honda ends.Originally posted by kochumvk View PostI was unaware about the absence of an R&D team for HH.
But still have the following doubts:
Will Honda supply serious engineering stuff to HH sice Honda is directly operating in India ?
Is it not a shame HH is unable to mature like bajaj and tvs?
Regarding passing technology to Hero HOnda from Honda, I agree there may be some glitches, but everything is based on their contract. We do not know what exactly happening there. But, Hero honda is able to get latest technology from Honda and the examples are the Unicorn engine in Xtreme and Hunk, the newly developed 100 cc engines in CD deluxe and splendor NXG, and not to forget the PGM-FI Glamour, and finally the new ZMR with latest technology (but the engine is old).HH Karizma (Current) || CBF Stunner PGM-FI || Honda CB Unicorn Dazzler
Honda Aviator || Kinetic Flyte || Kinetic Blaze || HH Splendor
Two ZMAs, 9 Days in Western Ghats
Comment
-
Again I say, there are people like you and there are people like me. Initially I too felt the urge to go higher speeds, but after some experience, felt 100 kmph is best to keep things under control.Originally posted by satan69inevery individual has his own speed limit while touring....we cant just assume that 100kmph is enough for touring....depends on the roads as well...for ex he bangalore hyderbad highway is very good and hence my average touring speed was 125kmph....in these roads,a person on a zmr or zma will feel the need for more speed...heck i felt i need a ninja when i was doing 135 on vijayawada vizag highway on my 220...
HH Karizma (Current) || CBF Stunner PGM-FI || Honda CB Unicorn Dazzler
Honda Aviator || Kinetic Flyte || Kinetic Blaze || HH Splendor
Two ZMAs, 9 Days in Western Ghats
Comment
-
Originally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostHero Honda is serving well to the commuter segment in India for years and they are happy with it. Every company going Bajaj or TVS way may not be good. When things are fine why to disturb it. Remember Hero HOnda is world's largest bike maker for the 9th consecutive year. So, the technical colloboration is working very well for them and naturally they do not want to distrub that. They may form an R&D if the contract with Honda ends.
Regarding passing technology to Hero HOnda from Honda, I agree there may be some glitches, but everything is based on their contract. We do not know what exactly happening there. But, Hero honda is able to get latest technology from Honda and the examples are the Unicorn engine in Xtreme and Hunk, the newly developed 100 cc engines in CD deluxe and splendor NXG, and not to forget the PGM-FI Glamour, and finally the new ZMR with latest technology (but the engine is old).
sales figures justifies your point.
Though most will be from commuter segment.
Consider the case when our automotive industry seriously matures..
When XSX R 600, R6 etc are manufactured in india..
RTR 600 RR, Pulsar 600 dtsfi etc keeps up to the league...
then Honda will start producing CBR 600 here...
Then Where is the room for HH?
Will they get a CBR motor for karizma then?
All these may be my dream..
Take it in that sense
Comment
-
What I mean to say is above 100 kmph speeds are not good on our bike chasses. Controling things will be very difficult with our bike frames in tricky situations. You can do 140 speeds with good control on 250cc NInja and bigger bikes, and their frames are made for that.Originally posted by satan69inwell,anything could happen at any speed...be in 50 or 100 or 150...a bullet guy may say 60 is the average touring speed and its best in that speed to keep things under control right...but as you said,there are people like me and people like you...but its not proper to state that 100kmph is enough for touring..
...here we can assume two sub categories under touring...a fast tourer and a relaxed tourer....zma,zmr falls under the relaxed tourer when compared to touring speed of 220..but when compared to a ninja,220 will be the relaxed tourer compared to the 140kmph touring speed on ninja
..
also the touring speed depends on roads and many highways are being reinstated...so who knows,in the future the touring speed in India may be 230kmph of R1
You cannot just say that anything can happen at lower speeds too, and then I say anything can happen when you walk too. Cruising at higher speeds (anything above 110 kmph) on our bikes is not safe on indian roads. It would involve extra risk. It is not that you cannot do more speeds, but it is always risky with indian roads and the type of bikes.
I am telling this because, I want all the riders to return home safe. You will understand this one day.
I hope you have watched 'Million Dollar Baby'. If so, remember what Clint always says.
We will get back to the topic from here.Last edited by ravi@17bhp; 02-12-2010, 04:18 PM.HH Karizma (Current) || CBF Stunner PGM-FI || Honda CB Unicorn Dazzler
Honda Aviator || Kinetic Flyte || Kinetic Blaze || HH Splendor
Two ZMAs, 9 Days in Western Ghats
Comment
-
That is basically done by selling eons and eons on Splendor and Passion, even i recommend them to anyone looking for a fool-proof commuting motorcycleOriginally posted by ravi@17bhp View PostWhen things are fine why to disturb it. Remember Hero HOnda is world's largest bike maker for the 9th consecutive year. So, the technical colloboration is working very well for them and naturally they do not want to distrub that.
how do you think they managed to eek out 1PS extra from CBZ Extreme and Hunk motors compared to the butter smooth UnicornThey may form an R&D if the contract with Honda ends.
i won't call them latest, far from it and FI is hard to incorporate else i don't see a significant advantage of a ZMR over carb ZmaHero honda is able to get latest technology from Honda and the examples are the Unicorn engine in Xtreme and Hunk, the newly developed 100 cc engines in CD deluxe and splendor NXG, and not to forget the PGM-FI Glamour, and finally the new ZMR with latest technology (but the engine is old).Last edited by MG; 03-02-2010, 03:07 PM.
Comment
-
I don't know what you guys will say if you ride a hayabusa everydayOriginally posted by kochumvkYou will say 130 insted of 110 if you own a 220 dtsi instead of Karizma
and i would chose a P-220 over a HH Karizma as the disadvantages of a P-220 more than make up by its advantages
and all of this boils down to the rider who is considering the motorcycles
and please--
No rantings/flamings/sms type language and mine is bigger/better than yours,we have had enoughLast edited by sheelpriye; 02-12-2010, 07:28 PM.
Comment



Comment