Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Keep your helmet tightly strapped up.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Pulsar 200NS Vs Duke 200

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • There is no heat all and i am saying this coz i was wearing a half pant during the test ride... And i still wont say about cornering coz didn't get to try it, since road was potholed... But straightline stability is definitely better in 220...be in at 20kph or 60 kph...didn't go beyond that... As MG had also said, the 220 is a better off roader..., now i got that proove... Not only offroading, but also on broken city roads... The flickablility of ns and stability of 220 will be a deadly combo btw scappipng footrests on pulsars is child play.. pulsars especially the 220 and 180ug4 are very very easy to lean and corner but once you lean the bike starts shaking... Upto 60 its okay on a 220 after which cornering is scary, chasis becomes a see-saw and the front and rear wheels tries to go in different ways, handle feels totaly disconnected... But that does not make cornering impossible... Even i corner with my friend's 220 at high speed at chingrighata flyover and just before the starting of lake gardens flyover with continuously scrapping the main stand. Cornering and scrapping on a 220 is very much possible on a 220..but its more like the control of the rider than the own control of the bike... But hit a straightline and it goes like its on rails... My earlier tvs flame had a wonderful chasis...dont know what chasis it had but its an awesum handler... Straight line stability was not there but its the cornering ability...OMG! I could lean on insane angles with absoluty no fear...not to mention i had michelin tyres which aided the handling... The steering was so razor sharp and accurate with wonderful brakes...i had drums on both ends... Wonderful feedback from the chasis...and very forgiving... How did tvs manage to tune the chasis? its like a point and shoot bike...goes exactly where you want it to go... And the low end torque was insane with wheelspins... man i miss that bike...
    Last edited by Rahulbarik; 08-19-2012, 11:44 AM.
    This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

    Comment


    • Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
      As you all know, 200NS has hit kolkata and me being a potential buyer finally got a test ride after a fight with the dealer... Now its time to say how the bike feels:
      Lacks power heavily...where did all those23.5bhp and 18.3nm torque go? Low end torque is very poor...less than even the pulsar 180 in my opinion.. Pulls from after 6k rpm only but there is no feel of the power even at 8k.. The rush factor of220 is not there... Engine is super smooth, gearbox a delight a use, rear disc is too sharp, front disc have very good bite and power but lacks the lever feedback of the 220...
      Bike is light, very flickable, light front end but not as light as duke, fz or rtr... Handlebars lacks the road feedback of the 220, sitting position is very commuterish, rider seats are very wide and soft, pillion seat is also good... Handling is good but nothing groundbraking.. . Expected better handling with a perimeter frame... Stability wise 220 is much better even at slow speeds... Didn't get to try cornering.... Tyres are a definite let down.... Seat is quite high..., killing the engine kill switch switches off everything...ev en the console... pilot lamps or console light dont work untill you switch on the engine...
      I dont think its an upgrade for a 220 owner...
      So which one is more fun to ride..220 or 200ns?
      Its the 220 for me anyday which is more fun...
      .
      But i will be buying the NS still coz its a new bike with some nice features...
      The above post is my personal opinion only...no offence to anyone
      So which one for you? 220 or 200?
      P.S. People calling the ns brakes to be better than duke should see a doctor.... seriously yaar...
      Anyways this is a total straightforward and honest review and nothing is biased...
      Your mention of lack of power puts a grin on my face. That's the beauty of NS. Trust me those surge of power on 220 is just psychological. Though you feel the kick on 220, you can't sustain it for long. Try riding 220 and 200NS side be side, redlining both the bikes for say 5Kms non stop, you will feel the difference!

      And I also have gut feeling, that because of the high saddle position, you guys feel the 220 to be more fun and a better handler, it's not the case once you get used to the commuterish yet sporty riding style of 200NS. I recently tried to take on a corner on my friends 220 (just 5 months old), on the same road as I did my NS, and hell I got scared mid corner at 70Kmph or so. A mid corner correction and braking me scared even more. The next moment I was back to NS, where i'm now most comfortable. Strange for the fact I rode a 220 for 3 years, and 35000Kms! And yeah, the 220s have got the MRF ZAPPER soft compound tires. I think it's just matter of putting some soft rubber to see the real potential of then P200NS.
      Last edited by rahuldevnath; 08-19-2012, 01:01 PM.
      Been There, Done That; Better!

      Comment


      • Originally posted by rahuldevnath View Post
        Your mention of lack of power puts a grin on my face. That's the beauty of NS. Trust me those surge of power on 220 is just psychological. Though you feel the kick on 220, you can't sustain it for long. Try riding 220 and 200NS side be side, redlining both the bikes for say 5Kms non stop, you will feel the difference!

        And I also have gut feeling, that because of the high saddle position, you guys feel the 220 to be more fun and a better handler, it's not the case once you get used to the commuterish yet sporty riding style of 200NS. I recently tried to take on a corner on my friends 220 (just 5 months old), on the same road as I did my NS, and hell I got scared mid corner at 70Kmph or so. A mid corner correction and braking me scared even more. The next moment I was back to NS, where i'm now most comfortable. Strange for the fact I rode a 220 for 3 years, and 35000Kms! And yeah, the 220s have got the MRF ZAPPER soft compound tires. I think it's just matter of putting some soft rubber to see the real potential of then P200NS.
        its true its more about getting accustomed to the bike i guess.... Today i am complaining a bit but i know, when i get used to the bike then it will be me who would love the bike... After 2 months i will contradict myself for sure but that power thingy part...everyone said its linear and doesn't have a punch... But i found it a bit too linear for my liking... but i will surely get used to the bike i just loved the rev friendly nature, smoothness, gearbox and the throttle reaction...pure bliss...
        Anyways do yo intend to do any mod to the engine kill switch? Coz it shuts off everything...i would love to have a kill switch which switches off the engine only... And would also like the pilot lamps to light up without starting the engine... And does this bike have that stupid BCU thing? Its a real pain to bypass it and local electricians dont like to mess with it
        This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

        Comment


        • Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
          exactly the same reasons why i am going for ns over 220...its old... And i NEVER said 220 is flickable than ns. Ns is much more flickable than 220 but 220 is more stable... And ns nose dive is well controlled...not as gud as a fz... Handling of ns is nothing exceptional... Its just good...not scary... Even i feel how yamaha managed to get the fz so right... What i still feel is with a perimeter frame and such a long wheelbase, the handling leaves a lot to be desired... And would have loved bit more feedback on the front brakes...
          @dip: clutch is very tight and very far...with zero freeplay...
          i decided to test ride ns the hard way and i really gave it some stick .. the sales rep was shit scared and grabbed my shoulders tightly .. while cornering i felt that p220 runs wider than ns .. also after my ride i noticed smell of burn engine and my friend showed me fumes coming from the engine .. the engine was so hot that it was felt from around 10feet away and the engine was idling at 2500rpm after my ride ( i guess it was scared too)..i test the machine at all revs so i redlined ns quite a few times during test ride ...the speedo was disconnected so i didnt get to see the speeds i was riding it at ,, but it was scary speeds for sure .. i noticed and reported vibrations just cuz i rode it at high rpms .. you guys should also test the bike at all rev ranges once ... you will know what i am talking about ...there is need to go emotional saying "poor new ns " .. i test all the machines that way cuz its my money in the end and i want to know everything about the machine before buying .. tested cbr250 , r15 , duke , ns , p220 the same way before buying duke ..

          Originally posted by MACH50 View Post
          The Duke 200 I got,

          Is Ultra Fast,
          Is Ultra refined at gears,
          Gets hot in slow traffic,
          Snatches under 1500 rpms.
          Has already clocked 67 kms - under motoman's break-in.
          Made a Pulsar 220S feel insecure in just a single gear 4th for the Duke- I was just loading and unloading the engine as per motoman's method

          This bike is a high end Streefighter for sure.............maybe the best in the KTM Duke family too..........so it seems

          My cousin too took a test ride and his mature decision of going for the 200NS changed to the boyish decision of going for the Duke 200 and bath in adrenaline !!!
          snatchy feeling is below 2000rpm..
          this is the most exciting bike in city currently available within 3lakhs range .. i find it more exciting than ninja 250 in city ...

          Originally posted by Toxicbiker View Post
          rightly said bro....200 is better in terms of tech and newbie feel....but what I wouldn't agree with you is the cornering ability of 220 in respect to NS ,,,...NS is flickable than 220 but in cornering 220 is more stable...thats what I felt...and yes...Yamaha is Yamaha when it comes to handling.....I can always say..if my Fazer had a 200-220 cc heart with a mere 4bhp power more it would have been the best....man the handling part is undoubted in this fazer..which NS lacks....

          bro...that is the reason Yamaha is the World champion in Moto GP without having the most powerful bike....the handling scores more than 100 in Yamaha...I personally tested many bikes but the feedback and handling is unmatched with Yamaha...
          sadly yamaha will only come up with a global 250cc only during late 2013 .. they are currently working on 3 scooters .. one scooter ( ray ) this diwali and other two to follow ..
          anything lesser than duke after owning fz would have been a disaster for me ..
          yamaha takes a lot of time to develop a flagship but it turns out to be the best and flawless .. quality, precision and perfection is the main aim of yamaha ..

          Originally posted by Shibadip View Post
          In our short TD (by me and @toxicbiker), the heat wasn't felt on our legs or anything..
          When the bike was put back on the Showroom, I checked the engine heat by keepng my finger on it, and it did felt hotter than any other engine would have expected to be..
          ride it to its limits during test ride guys ..

          Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
          There is no heat all and i am saying this coz i was wearing a half pant during the test ride... And i still wont say about cornering coz didn't get to try it, since road was potholed... But straightline stability is definitely better in 220...be in at 20kph or 60 kph...didn't go beyond that... As MG had also said, the 220 is a better off roader..., now i got that proove... Not only offroading, but also on broken city roads... The flickablility of ns and stability of 220 will be a deadly combo btw scappipng footrests on pulsars is child play.. pulsars especially the 220 and 180ug4 are very very easy to lean and corner but once you lean the bike starts shaking... Upto 60 its okay on a 220 after which cornering is scary, chasis becomes a see-saw and the front and rear wheels tries to go in different ways, handle feels totaly disconnected... But that does not make cornering impossible... Even i corner with my friend's 220 at high speed at chingrighata flyover and just before the starting of lake gardens flyover with continuously scrapping the main stand. Cornering and scrapping on a 220 is very much possible on a 220..but its more like the control of the rider than the own control of the bike... But hit a straightline and it goes like its on rails... My earlier tvs flame had a wonderful chasis...dont know what chasis it had but its an awesum handler... Straight line stability was not there but its the cornering ability...OMG! I could lean on insane angles with absoluty no fear...not to mention i had michelin tyres which aided the handling... The steering was so razor sharp and accurate with wonderful brakes...i had drums on both ends... Wonderful feedback from the chasis...and very forgiving... How did tvs manage to tune the chasis? its like a point and shoot bike...goes exactly where you want it to go... And the low end torque was insane with wheelspins... man i miss that bike...
          i hated p220 for its weight and suspensions ..
          Last edited by Rohan200ns; 08-19-2012, 01:50 PM.

          Comment


          • Originally posted by Rohan200ns View Post
            i decided to test ride ns the hard way and i really gave it some stick .. the sales rep was shit scared and grabbed my shoulders tightly .. while cornering i felt that p220 runs wider than ns .. also after my ride i noticed smell of burn engine and my friend showed me fumes coming from the engine .. the engine was so hot that it was felt from around 10feet away and the engine was idling at 2500rpm after my ride ( i guess it was scared too)..i test the machine at all revs so i redlined ns quite a few times during test ride ...the speedo was disconnected so i didnt get to see the speeds i was riding it at ,, but it was scary speeds for sure .. i noticed and reported vibrations just cuz i rode it at high rpms .. you guys should also test the bike at all rev ranges once ... you will know what i am talking about ...there is need to go emotional saying "poor new ns " .. i test all the machines that way cuz its my money in the end and i want to know everything about the machine before buying .. tested cbr250 , r15 , duke , ns , p220 the same way before buying duke ..


            snatchy feeling is below 2000rpm..
            this is the most exciting bike in city currently available within 3lakhs range .. i find it more exciting than ninja 250 in city ...



            sadly yamaha will only come up with a global 250cc only during late 2013 .. they are currently working on 3 scooters .. one scooter ( ray ) this diwali and other two to follow ..
            anything lesser than duke after owning fz would have been a disaster for me ..
            yamaha takes a lot of time to develop a flagship but it turns out to be the best and flawless .. quality, precision and perfection is the main aim of yamaha ..


            ride it to its limits during test ride guys ..


            i hated p220 for its weight and suspensions ..
            i tested ns the hard way... thumbed the starter, first gear and zip zap zoom... The showroom guy was shouting in fear... Shifted 1-2nd gear at 10k and 2nd to 3rd at 9k, then slowed down, braked hard and the rear skidded... Rear brake is awesum...and good lever feedback...front brake is powerful but lacks feedback...and over potholes ht becomes slightly unsettled... This bike really needs better tires... I didn't feel even the slightest of heat and mind it i was wearing a very short half pant so my legs were totally exposed... Vibration was minimal...just a high frequency tingling on the frame... Rpm never rose to 2.5 even after repeted thrashing by me and two other friends... Maybe your test ride bike had a problem...
            Its true, yamaha reacts late but it does it does with a bang... Even if they plonk in a 250cc mill in current r15 it will blow away the competition...
            Yamaha= handling
            Honda= engine
            Bajaj= a mix of everything the cheap way... the desi solution for desi requirement
            This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
              i tested ns the hard way... thumbed the starter, first gear and zip zap zoom... The showroom guy was shouting in fear... Shifted 1-2nd gear at 10k and 2nd to 3rd at 9k, then slowed down, braked hard and the rear skidded... Rear brake is awesum...and good lever feedback...front brake is powerful but lacks feedback...and over potholes ht becomes slightly unsettled... This bike really needs better tires... I didn't feel even the slightest of heat and mind it i was wearing a very short half pant so my legs were totally exposed... Vibration was minimal...just a high frequency tingling on the frame... Rpm never rose to 2.5 even after repeted thrashing by me and two other friends... Maybe your test ride bike had a problem...
              Its true, yamaha reacts late but it does it does with a bang... Even if they plonk in a 250cc mill in current r15 it will blow away the competition...
              Yamaha= handling
              Honda= engine
              Bajaj= a mix of everything the cheap way... the desi solution for desi requirement
              even i think that the ns which i tested had improperly fitted plastic panels ..
              yes r15 can easily do with a much bigger engine .. i would happily pay more than 2 lakhs for a 250cc yamaha ..

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Shibadip
                Are you sure of this News??

                Absolutely agree

                I'm still an amature rider, and not comfortable with hard riding.
                But @toxicbiker, and @rahulbarik says, they both rode it hard, and the heat issue was not there.

                Correctly put

                Even a fazer would be a perfect tourer with a 250cc heart
                btw a friend of my brother got robbed by pbk kolkata for the first servicing of duke... They charged him 3500 for the service... Total rip-off... Now he is almost crying
                This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Rohan200ns
                  i dont know why but i love naked bikes more than fully faired bikes .. my next upgrade will definitely be a ducati monster 795 .. working towards it ,, looking at 3-4 years down the line ..
                  My liking is exact opposite buddy...I just love faired bikes.
                  And my next upgrade will be Ninja 250 2013, unless Yam comes up with something in that segment...
                  Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
                  btw a friend of my brother got robbed by pbk kolkata for the first servicing of duke... They charged him 3500 for the service... Total rip-off... Now he is almost crying
                  Tell ur Bro's friend about the efficiency of solving a case after filing an FIR in BAjaj's C.Care.
                  Also ask for our commission for giving this precious advise
                  sigpic
                  Relationships change, evolve, and it goes deep.
                  Only thing I can say - "The storm is coming"

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by Shibadip View Post
                    My liking is exact opposite buddy...I just love faired bikes.
                    And my next upgrade will be Ninja 250 2013, unless Yam comes up with something in that segment...

                    Tell ur Bro's friend about the efficiency of solving a case after filing an FIR in BAjaj's C.Care.
                    Also ask for our commission for giving this precious advise
                    hahaha...already told him yesterday
                    This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

                    Comment


                    • MODS:- this thread is going gross OT, full of sms lingo/slang and what not.

                      do something.
                      sigpic

                      Tyre Sizes _ Spark Plugs

                      Headlight Focus _ Fork Oils

                      All India xBhp Couple Riders Thread

                      Ashtavinayak + Shirdi
                      Purandar
                      Raigad
                      Dapoli
                      Aurangabad
                      Kaas Plateu & Thoseghar Waterfalls
                      Purandar

                      Comment


                      • @toxicbiker and rahulbarik -- did you guys like the alloy wheels design of ns ?

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by Rohan200ns View Post
                          @toxicbiker and rahulbarik -- did you guys like the alloy wheels design of ns ?
                          not at all liked the alloys of ns... It looks like some kind of a flower...looks girlie...same goes for the handle... Wana exchange your duke alloys with my ns?
                          This Tail Is Japani Tail (spell as you like)

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by Rahulbarik View Post
                            not at all liked the alloys of ns... It looks like some kind of a flower...looks girlie...same goes for the handle... Wana exchange your duke alloys with my ns?
                            i liked ns alloys when i saw them in pics ( seemed to look different and fresh ),, but hated its design after i saw it in flesh ..it doesnt go well with the muscular lines of the bike's body .. i like gloss paint on alloys but ns has matt finish i guess .. the only alloys i like are of fz , fazer , R15 v2.0 and duke ..i wouldnt exchange any part of duke ...
                            duke's alloys are lighter and wider ..
                            i would suggest you to keep the bike in complete stock condition for a minimum of 2000kms as there are chances that you will get used to the handle bar ..

                            Comment


                            • Didn't wanted to post in this thread( i think there is a cold war going on here)
                              I am owner of blue NS since three days (yipee) and i can vouch for uts below written qualities :

                              it is as flickable as a 125 cc bike( my old yamaha gladiaor)

                              it is smooth but not that much in first 150 kms, so don't judge it by that.

                              seats are very comfortable( both of them)

                              vibrations have gone away( 130 on odo)

                              a headturner for sure

                              feels relaxed in 6th gear at 60( so should give good FE)
                              Last edited by Hiteshjain6188; 08-22-2012, 09:26 PM.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by Rohan200ns View Post
                                @toxicbiker and rahulbarik -- did you guys like the alloy wheels design of ns ?
                                nope bro...the alloy stuff is not looking very macho in my opinion....

                                Originally posted by Rohan200ns View Post
                                i liked ns alloys when i saw them in pics ( seemed to look different and fresh ),, but hated its design after i saw it in flesh ..it doesnt go well with the muscular lines of the bike's body .
                                absolutely correct..
                                Heart Meets Soul when you ride...


                                Life is Calling for you....
                                sigpic

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X