Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Keep your helmet tightly strapped up.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Suzuki GS150R

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by punarvasu View Post
    Everything is because you have posted the results of/your opinions about the modifications on your bike in a public thread where all of us participate in the ongoing discussion.
    I am not at all worried about the effects of the modifications on your bike but expressed my opinions as you yourself did. Please don’t be felt insulted.
    Chill mate..you are free to express ur opinions..I was just trying to say that there is some improvement in acceleration.. so lets take the discussion further and try to find out if there is any real improvement in FE and power

    Originally posted by gmagesh14 View Post
    Absolutely right... Nowadays I used do shift gears at higher rpms frequently... Following full clutch method..

    Within a week of purchase I changed the indicator to no blink mode.. No plan in getting back to it .so I've to change my mind set..

    Riding at speeds of 70-85kmph with more stop and go conditions..sometimes touching 90..
    And even at these conditions too it delivers a good average of 52kmpl approximately (For 2.87litres of fuel - 150kms covered)..

    Without any mods it's already doing its good performance..
    Great!!That is some serious mileage for the riding style you mentioned...I never got above 45kmpl with almost same riding style and petrol was from Trustworthy petrol bunk(SHELL).....
    what i used to get is 105kms for 2.63litres...it comes upto 40kmpl.
    Originally posted by 2strokerama View Post
    Yes. You dont need any mods to reach those speeds. So, it must be the first time manu has redlined his bike in those gears.

    But, this "improved acceleration" can be quantified by launching two gs's side by side to see who is faster.


    Its always good to have skeptics around to keep us grounded.

    Manubhat can give you your answers with proof on both counts. But here is my attempt anyway. Correct me if im wrong.

    Possible reasons that companies dont do this:
    > Like ashwinprakas said, to increase an engine's reliability or operating lifespan.
    > Target audience or price bracket. The bike is targeted at a certain segment for which such additional development expenditure\efforts is not necessary.
    > If in case a demand should arise for a bit more power, companies could respond to this by doing such modification work to the existing design....assuming that they might have already engineered some room to accommodate such modifications into the original design. If joel's modification works, then they have.

    Such room for improvements could also be inherent with any engine design. Or it could be the modifier's insight into engines that lets him see such possibilities for improvements that others fail to.

    Of course, this is all theories and assumptions. But none based on thin air.

    Now onto the FE part....while manubhat can probably supply the facts to dispel your doubts, its not hard to believe that an increase in powr can increase FE as well. Now I dont know how porting can increase FE. But I remember reading somewhere that an increase in compression increases torque by a considerable extent, so that it takes lesser throttle to move a gear at the same speed as it does to move it at lower compression. So, increased FE. But at a cost.

    Lets suppose that there is an increase in FE due to the mods. This FE gain is offset by more strain on engine components due to the mods.

    If there is an increase in torque(which is the point of this mod business), there must be more strain on the piston, crankshaft and all related parts that are now needed to function at a higher pace than usual. So, more wear and tear overall.

    Here, 10% increase in FE means 4.7 kmpl extra over company claimed 47 kmpl(city riding conditions). Thats a savings of about rupees 1500 (at the current petrol rate of ~ rs.73.5 in bangalore) for every 10000 km of operation. More power means chances for increased clutch wear, chain\sprocket wear, tire wear, decreased operating life of spark plug and air filter and god knows what else. So, that FE savings is meagre compared to the potential for escalation of running costs due to faster wear of components.

    + most of the target audience is more than happy with what the vehicle is capable of and probably dont even approach the vehicle's limits.

    So, even if it is possible to increase FE by such mods, its no wonder why suzuki dont do it themselves. No wonder gs150Rs and unicorns are seen as less troublesome than apache's and pulsars that make more power than our bikes do, at the same cost.

    It appears that power output, FE/running costs and longevity of the engine are linked by a balance. Any 2 gains happen at the expense of the third. Or any gain happens at an expense. It is upto you to decide which gain you value more.

    ---------

    @manubhat:
    test out against a stock GS, preferably one that has run lesser than yours.....and let us know man. Acceleration and mileage wise.We are curious.
    well said 2strokerama
    Iam not fully sure about the performance and FE yet...Am just trying to learn everyday through forums and discussions...
    Also Am more curious than you to know how my GS performs with stock Bike....I was thinking about the same from yesterday..As am riding her more and more,i feel that there is only a slight improvement over stock... We should also see that only the head has been modified so the gain wont be much...
    Am not able to differentiate between how fast the bike was before and how fast it is now? so i need all your valuable suggestions guys...

    MSN are you listening..Ping me if ur free today..lets do a test run
    Last edited by manubhat; 02-23-2012, 03:44 PM.
    Never argue with an idiot. He will drag you down to his level and then beat you with experience.

    Comment


    • I am from bangalore and i will be happy to test out the bike. I have also contacted joel recently and he also said that he would maybe look at my bike..so...i would like to see first hand the difference if any...PM if you are keen to ride...

      @ALL - Has someone confirmed the actual reserve capacity of our bike. I have a feeling it is not 3.5 approx as advertised but less than 3...has anyone checked this??
      KM

      ------------------------------

      Cometh the hour cometh the man...

      Comment


      • Originally posted by manubhat View Post
        Chill mate..you are free to express ur opinions..I was just trying to say that there is some improvement in acceleration.. so lets take the discussion further and try to find out if there is any real improvement in FE and power


        Great!!That is some serious mileage for the riding style you mentioned...I never got above 45kmpl with almost same riding style and petrol was from Trustworthy petrol bunk(SHELL).....
        what i used to get is 105kms for 2.63litres...it comes upto 40kmpl.


        well said 2strokerama
        Iam not fully sure about the performance and FE yet...Am just trying to learn everyday through forums and discussions...
        Also Am more curious than you to know how my GS performs with stock Bike....I was thinking about the same from yesterday..As am riding her more and more,i feel that there is only a slight improvement over stock...
        Am not able to differentiate between how fast the bike was before and how fast it is now? so i need all your valuable suggestions guys...

        MSN are you listening..Ping me if ur free today..lets do a test run
        Gs150r can do well with a rear disc brake or at least bigger front disc, a full DC setup, fiber chain cover, tubeless tyres, and ligther aluminium footpegs and clutch and brake levers, etc., can be of benefit, but suzuki does not think so and you cant say they are wrong. They follow certain criteria while designing.

        Similarly, just because the manufacturer does not modify ports for extra power, does not mean it cannot be done. Modifying the ports, exhaust, etc., will change the sound and character of the bike, which the majority of target buyers may not like, and hence suzuki wont do it.

        All manufacturers design bikes for a specific target audience and target competition, giving just enough features to better the competition. Also, the bike is designed to a particular price point and to conform with govt regulations.

        There is a balance between power, mileage, and reliability. More of one can be achieved at the cost of the others. But manufacturers try to maintain an ideal balance between these keeping target audience and price in mind. They go with the idea of one-size-fits-most (not all).

        But some manufacturers would prefer to make different products for different target buyers, without spending much on designing a new bike, so they just increase piston size.

        Example, the P150, P180, and P220 are all based on same engine, but P180 and P220 get bigger bores. Obviously, this extra power is achieved at slight loss of reliability, because the same P150 crankshaft, etc has to handle extra loads from the bigger bores. But still there are many who want this extra power and dont care about longterm reliability.

        The gs150r target audience is the commuter-tourer, and suzuki probably assume that most of these riders would not go above 80 kmph and this is its safe limit, both for bike and rider. Though the bike is cabable of going 120 kmph, but that would mean riding in its upper limits.

        For better performance, suzuki would rather make a new sporty 150cc like R15 or a new 250cc, rather than just modifying their 150cc.

        Over three 3 years, Suzuki have made changes in gs150r, but these changes are minor. Suzuki will not deviate from their target buyers commuter-tourer requirements. This is in a way good from suzuki, as they keep their larger target audience happy. So any improvement to gs150r from anyone else is welcome, especially for those seeking outright performance. If the person paying for the modification is happy, only then he would suggest it others.

        @manu. The modification has just started. It could be too early to compare performance with stock gs150r.
        Last edited by antonysg; 02-23-2012, 04:25 PM.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by KIRTIMANNAN View Post
          I am from bangalore and i will be happy to test out the bike. I have also contacted joel recently and he also said that he would maybe look at my bike..so...i would like to see first hand the difference if any...PM if you are keen to ride...

          @ALL - Has someone confirmed the actual reserve capacity of our bike. I have a feeling it is not 3.5 approx as advertised but less than 3...has anyone checked this??
          the last one bar on the digital meter refers to approx 3.5 ltrs
          after the bike hits reserve i believe it would be around 2.5 Ltrs
          Sarcasm is my automatic response to stupidity

          Currently Using Gusto |Enfield Bullet 500 | Ecosport Titanium+ Diesel

          Comment


          • Can I install Honda Unicorn's leg guard or any same size leg guard bought from an automobile dealer and install in GS ? Mine is crushed. Will it create stability issues with another brand's leg guard or what.? U got my point I hope...
            " A man is also known by the bike he rides :D "

            Comment


            • Originally posted by manubhat View Post
              Great!!That is some serious mileage for the riding style you mentioned...I never got above 45kmpl with almost same riding style and petrol was from Trustworthy petrol bunk(SHELL).....
              what i used to get is 105kms for 2.63litres...it comes upto 40kmpl.
              My GS is very pocket friendly compared to my HH P+.. I used to get around 45-50kmpl when riding at 70kmph's in passion plus with less comfort and safety... I used to fill UNLEADED Petrol from random bunks (mainly HP & Indian Oil & sometimes BP)...

              Comment


              • Originally posted by gmagesh14 View Post
                My GS is very pocket friendly compared to my HH P+.. I used to get around 45-50kmpl when riding at 70kmph's in passion plus with less comfort and safety... I used to fill UNLEADED Petrol from random bunks (mainly HP & Indian Oil & sometimes BP)...
                i live in the same area where manubhat lives and using the same petrol bunk
                my driving style is like 5 or 6 kms per day and used to fill 2 ltrs almost every 8 or 10 days once.

                speed is not more than 45 or 50 as the ridding place is small and narrow roads

                moreover almost 50% of the times the pillion + rider weight to-gather is 150+
                the mileage am getting is in between 44 to 48 kmpl.
                Sarcasm is my automatic response to stupidity

                Currently Using Gusto |Enfield Bullet 500 | Ecosport Titanium+ Diesel

                Comment


                • Originally posted by MSN1 View Post
                  i live in the same area where manubhat lives and using the same petrol bunk
                  my driving style is like 5 or 6 kms per day and used to fill 2 ltrs almost every 8 or 10 days once.

                  speed is not more than 45 or 50 as the ridding place is small and narrow roads

                  moreover almost 50% of the times the pillion + rider weight to-gather is 150+
                  the mileage am getting is in between 44 to 48 kmpl.
                  Hmmm.,FYI most of the times I ride w/o pillion.. And I weigh 57kg.. I used to travel about 0 - 400kms a day., depending upon my work...

                  I'd covered 8500kms+ in 126days...

                  My bike is in for 4th service.. Expected to get it on Saturday..
                  Last edited by gmagesh14; 02-24-2012, 12:51 AM.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by MSN1 View Post
                    the last one bar on the digital meter refers to approx 3.5 ltrs
                    after the bike hits reserve i believe it would be around 2.5 Ltrs
                    hehe, but last week i rode for some 100kms after hitting reserve and the bar still didn't begin to blink

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by punarvasu;775653[FONT=Verdana
                      If you can reach 12000 rpm, the speed will be 47, 81, 109, 130, 148 and 170 kmh in respective gears. No modifications are needed to reach this speed if you can push the bike to that extent.
                      Have you ever reached 12,000rpms on your own bike ????

                      I guess not, that is why you are jotting down theoretical figures here.

                      In doing so, you have discounted the weight ,aerodynamic drag, engine power ,compression ratio and gearing ratio of the bike it seems.

                      I admit that there are a lot of tools over the net which will show those theoretically possible figures after factoring in gearing ratios and tyre size, but none of them are meant for the specifications imparted by the GS150R in stock conditions.

                      I say this, not to you personally, but in answer to your doubt that, my GS150R does reach 12,000rpms in sixth gear clocking 127kmph on a normal plain highway(no downhill) in presence of cross winds.
                      I admit it is not a stock bike and that difference can be felt,my stock GS150R in a similar situation could have at the best done 119kmph and would have taken eons to reach that 127-130kmph zone.But the mods on my bike has shown the effects.

                      I have clocked 95kmph in 3rd, 105kmph in 4th, 115kmph in fifth and 127 kmph in sixth on my boosted bike.......all in redlining zone of 11,500rpms.
                      I can blatantly say that it is not possible on a regular GS150R.

                      I have done nothing to decrease the weight of my bike , not even changed stock tyres and brakes.......but I feel my bike surely has got an upper hand.

                      Now, coming to the question when the power and mileage both are mutually benefited..................., you have to say that why paid engineers at big corporations do not apply such tech right--
                      But I can tell you, half a century back, many cars with big engines made as much performance as our 150cc bike does now, with a lot lower mileage........reliable technology always evolves the vehicles,but raw race tech is for the track not for the general public, hence engineers have to think about the revenue from everyone while building a machine.But ultimately raw tech makes it to public in a refined acceptable way.

                      Everyday folks won't go and buy a Busa or ZZR1400 with a lot of low(but reasonable)mileage and rocket ship like power, but still they are produced for folks who earns and yearns them and they are sold too.

                      I am impressed and inspired by Joel's work on Manubhat's bike- however little difference it makes and my friend(who gifted me his self-made supercharger/developed it for my bike) has already started working on his own ways of increasing my bike's Volumetric efficiency, so that the boost can be used more efficiently, and we would start with porting- just what Joel has done on Manu's bike.
                      Hell's Angel
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                      • My New GS150R

                        Hi guys,
                        Finally I've got my new GS150R Black 2012 model. Will be uploading pics soon. The odo read 3.8KM (ODO only showed 3 KM but trip meter was more precise).
                        Took it to Gurudwara (as instructed by parents and friends). Not driven long, since I got it ready late evening. But enjoyed riding it a lot(sort of craze of riding). Though there is one minor prob, one pilot light not working so dealer said he'll replace the whole front thing with new one(I couldn't wait for another piece as I'll have to join office from Monday). Also, gear shifting seems quite different from the previous GS150R, in my old bike I couldn't get Neutral(except when engine was off) and in new GS150R, when changing from 1st to 2nd gear, neutral was messing up.
                        WARNING: Objects seen in the mirror are disappearing rapidly.
                        MyGS150R.in
                        IaMmE.in

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by Gagan0123 View Post
                          Hi guys,
                          Finally I've got my new GS150R Black 2012 model. Will be uploading pics soon. The odo read 3.8KM (ODO only showed 3 KM but trip meter was more precise).
                          Took it to Gurudwara (as instructed by parents and friends). Not driven long, since I got it ready late evening. But enjoyed riding it a lot(sort of craze of riding). Though there is one minor prob, one pilot light not working so dealer said he'll replace the whole front thing with new one(I couldn't wait for another piece as I'll have to join office from Monday). Also, gear shifting seems quite different from the previous GS150R, in my old bike I couldn't get Neutral(except when engine was off) and in new GS150R, when changing from 1st to 2nd gear, neutral was messing up.
                          Heartiest Congrats for you my friend.........I can understand your feelings , that you are uploading the fact that you are now the owner of this wonderful machine, such late at night.

                          God bless you and your bike, ride safe - be happy
                          Hell's Angel
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by chiron View Post
                            hehe, but last week i rode for some 100kms after hitting reserve and the bar still didn't begin to blink


                            the bar suppose blink at approx of less than 1 ltr petrol remains

                            as i said earlier if reserve is approx 2.5 ltrs with 1.5 ltr 100kms continues log drive is possible assuming 60+ kmpl

                            Any way Digital fuel level indicator is not as reliable like the analogue one
                            Sarcasm is my automatic response to stupidity

                            Currently Using Gusto |Enfield Bullet 500 | Ecosport Titanium+ Diesel

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by MACH50 View Post
                              Have you ever reached 12,000rpms on your own bike ????

                              I guess not, that is why you are jotting down theoretical figures here.

                              In doing so, you have discounted the weight ,aerodynamic drag, engine power ,compression ratio and gearing ratio of the bike it seems.

                              I admit that there are a lot of tools over the net which will show those theoretically possible figures after factoring in gearing ratios and tyre size, but none of them are meant for the specifications imparted by the GS150R in stock conditions.

                              I say this, not to you personally, but in answer to your doubt that, my GS150R does reach 12,000rpms in sixth gear clocking 127kmph on a normal plain highway(no downhill) in presence of cross winds.
                              I admit it is not a stock bike and that difference can be felt,my stock GS150R in a similar situation could have at the best done 119kmph and would have taken eons to reach that 127-130kmph zone.But the mods on my bike has shown the effects.

                              I have clocked 95kmph in 3rd, 105kmph in 4th, 115kmph in fifth and 127 kmph in sixth on my boosted bike.......all in redlining zone of 11,500rpms.
                              I can blatantly say that it is not possible on a regular GS150R.

                              I have done nothing to decrease the weight of my bike , not even changed stock tyres and brakes.......but I feel my bike surely has got an upper hand.

                              Now, coming to the question when the power and mileage both are mutually benefited..................., you have to say that why paid engineers at big corporations do not apply such tech right--
                              But I can tell you, half a century back, many cars with big engines made as much performance as our 150cc bike does now, with a lot lower mileage........reliable technology always evolves the vehicles,but raw race tech is for the track not for the general public, hence engineers have to think about the revenue from everyone while building a machine.But ultimately raw tech makes it to public in a refined acceptable way.

                              Everyday folks won't go and buy a Busa or ZZR1400 with a lot of low(but reasonable)mileage and rocket ship like power, but still they are produced for folks who earns and yearns them and they are sold too.

                              I am impressed and inspired by Joel's work on Manubhat's bike- however little difference it makes and my friend(who gifted me his self-made supercharger/developed it for my bike) has already started working on his own ways of increasing my bike's Volumetric efficiency, so that the boost can be used more efficiently, and we would start with porting- just what Joel has done on Manu's bike.
                              My sincere best wishes to you and your bike and the porting you are planning to do on your bike, MACH50.

                              And read this carefully with a calm mind as it seems that you haven’t read the posting of mine which you have quoted here.


                              A normal, stock, unmodified GS without rocket booster like that your engineer friend designed specially for you reaches 95 kmh at 11350 rpm in third gear, 105 kmh at 10500 rpm in forth gear, 115 kmh at 10100 rpm in fifth gear and 127 kmh at 9000 rpm in sixth gear. I don’t know whether these engine rpm is reachable or not because I have never tried to reach there mainly because I am not a bike racer.

                              If your bike reaches that speed at 11500 rpm as you claimed or if the tachometer shows 11500 rpm at that speeds, your bike needs urgent thorough checking. I cannot say whether the tachometer, speedometer, gears, sprockets, engine or whatever is faulty, but I am sure that your bike is in a very critically faulty condition.

                              COOL DOWN, my dear friend and dash to the service centre or a good local mechanic with your boosted bike.

                              (Busa or ZZR1400 is out of my range. So not interested in them).
                              Last edited by punarvasu; 02-24-2012, 09:06 AM.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by Gagan0123 View Post
                                Finally I've got my new GS150R Black 2012 model.
                                Congratulations.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X