Since '02 xBhp is different things to different people. From a close knit national community of bikers to India's only motorcycling lifestyle magazine and a place to make like-minded biker friends. Join us

Castrol Power 1

Red to green – let the cager go first.

Our Partner

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

TVS Apache RTR 180

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
    Well i think this question is more apt at the What Bike thread. Anyways, comparing P220 with an RTR180 these are the pros and cons that they have:

    1. RTR180 is a better handler any given day. Period. If you want a more flickable bike which is fun to negotiate the traffic then RTR wont disappoint you. P220 takes a little more effort in this regard.
    2. RTR's initial pickup is equal (or better as some would say although by a very small margin) to that of P220. But i dont think you will be racing with a P220 if you buy an RTR or vice versa that these milliseconds would matter to you. But as the speed builds up, the 40cc extra obviously makes its presence felt and leaves the RTR behind. Having a better top end than RTR, the P220 engine is more relaxed at the same rpm than RTR which is good if you are into touring.
    3. Suspension wise, the RTR's suspension is made for the track and hence feels a little stiff on the bad patches of road. P220 DTSI's suspension has been stiffened after DTSFI but still its better on the bad patches and not as good as RTR on the track or even for that matter on the twisties.
    4. Looks are relative so i wont go into the debate of which bike looks better.
    5. Riding position of the RTR is more on the sportier side than the P220. But its only a matter of getting used to before you feel comfortable.
    6. Mileage is something plus minus 40kmph for the RTR, while the P220 DTSI has been known to give a variable mileage for different riders if you go through the P220 DTSI ownership thread.
    7. Vibrations are there in the RTR from 4k to around 5.5k which is the speed zone of 55 to 68. P220 on the other hand is almost vibe free till you cross the 6.5k rpm. Now since you will be driving in the city, the RTR's vibe zone will have to experienced more than often as thats the speed we generally ride in cities.
    8. Straight line stability of P220 is better compared to RTR.

    Now coming down to the reliability, both the companies are reliable in present times. But face it, whatever bike you buy here, you will be facing some or the other problems, be it minor or major. In my city the Bajaj Probiking is much better than the TVS SVC. I dont know about your city. Ask some owners in your city about the SVC.
    These were all the differences i could note about the two great bikes. See what you can bear with and what you cannot and then make your choice. Also others in this forum might add to the points i have mentioned. Take note of that too.
    In south region TVS SVCs are doing good job

    Comment


    • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
      Well i think this question is more apt at the What Bike thread. Anyways, comparing P220 with an RTR180 these are the pros and cons that they have:

      1. RTR180 is a better handler any given day. Period. If you want a more flickable bike which is fun to negotiate the traffic then RTR wont disappoint you. P220 takes a little more effort in this regard.
      2. RTR's initial pickup is equal (or better as some would say although by a very small margin) to that of P220. But i dont think you will be racing with a P220 if you buy an RTR or vice versa that these milliseconds would matter to you. But as the speed builds up, the 40cc extra obviously makes its presence felt and leaves the RTR behind. Having a better top end than RTR, the P220 engine is more relaxed at the same rpm than RTR which is good if you are into touring.
      3. Suspension wise, the RTR's suspension is made for the track and hence feels a little stiff on the bad patches of road. P220 DTSI's suspension has been stiffened after DTSFI but still its better on the bad patches and not as good as RTR on the track or even for that matter on the twisties.
      4. Looks are relative so i wont go into the debate of which bike looks better.
      5. Riding position of the RTR is more on the sportier side than the P220. But its only a matter of getting used to before you feel comfortable.
      6. Mileage is something plus minus 40kmph for the RTR, while the P220 DTSI has been known to give a variable mileage for different riders if you go through the P220 DTSI ownership thread.
      7. Vibrations are there in the RTR from 4k to around 5.5k which is the speed zone of 55 to 68. P220 on the other hand is almost vibe free till you cross the 6.5k rpm. Now since you will be driving in the city, the RTR's vibe zone will have to experienced more than often as thats the speed we generally ride in cities.
      8. Straight line stability of P220 is better compared to RTR.

      Now coming down to the reliability, both the companies are reliable in present times. But face it, whatever bike you buy here, you will be facing some or the other problems, be it minor or major. In my city the Bajaj Probiking is much better than the TVS SVC. I dont know about your city. Ask some owners in your city about the SVC.
      These were all the differences i could note about the two great bikes. See what you can bear with and what you cannot and then make your choice. Also others in this forum might add to the points i have mentioned. Take note of that too.
      ^^Very well put up!!

      Even if both bikes cater to enthusiasts needs, there is a vast difference in the character between these two bikes!!

      sigpic

      Comment


      • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
        Well i think this question is more apt at the What Bike thread. Anyways, comparing P220 with an RTR180 these are the pros and cons that they have:

        1. RTR180 is a better handler any given day. Period. If you want a more flickable bike which is fun to negotiate the traffic then RTR wont disappoint you. P220 takes a little more effort in this regard.
        2. RTR's initial pickup is equal (or better as some would say although by a very small margin) to that of P220. But i dont think you will be racing with a P220 if you buy an RTR or vice versa that these milliseconds would matter to you. But as the speed builds up, the 40cc extra obviously makes its presence felt and leaves the RTR behind. Having a better top end than RTR, the P220 engine is more relaxed at the same rpm than RTR which is good if you are into touring.
        3. Suspension wise, the RTR's suspension is made for the track and hence feels a little stiff on the bad patches of road. P220 DTSI's suspension has been stiffened after DTSFI but still its better on the bad patches and not as good as RTR on the track or even for that matter on the twisties.
        4. Looks are relative so i wont go into the debate of which bike looks better.
        5. Riding position of the RTR is more on the sportier side than the P220. But its only a matter of getting used to before you feel comfortable.
        6. Mileage is something plus minus 40kmph for the RTR, while the P220 DTSI has been known to give a variable mileage for different riders if you go through the P220 DTSI ownership thread.
        7. Vibrations are there in the RTR from 4k to around 5.5k which is the speed zone of 55 to 68. P220 on the other hand is almost vibe free till you cross the 6.5k rpm. Now since you will be driving in the city, the RTR's vibe zone will have to experienced more than often as thats the speed we generally ride in cities.
        8. Straight line stability of P220 is better compared to RTR.

        Now coming down to the reliability, both the companies are reliable in present times. But face it, whatever bike you buy here, you will be facing some or the other problems, be it minor or major. In my city the Bajaj Probiking is much better than the TVS SVC. I dont know about your city. Ask some owners in your city about the SVC.
        These were all the differences i could note about the two great bikes. See what you can bear with and what you cannot and then make your choice. Also others in this forum might add to the points i have mentioned. Take note of that too.
        Its a descent note buddy... i agree with your above points and very well put for a beginner who is in verge of deciding which one? that's why i always tell to take a TD...
        sigpic...Ride Long...Ride Safe...

        When you dance with the devil, you wait for the song to stop...

        Comment


        • Yesterday, I did a 300kms(to and fro) trip for Chris Pfeiffer's event. The bike was fantastic! Yes, vibrations are very much present between speeds of 55-68km/hr. But once past that, it is a bliss! I managed to touch 114km/hr on the East Coast Road connecting Pondicherry and Chennai! The tacho needle was dancing at 8000rpm. What a bike! I was screaming on top of my voice when I saw those figures on the speedo! The power delivery is super smooth. Every smallest wring on the throttle will bring a change on the speedo and the tacho.
          One hard truth...RTR is not the bike to be used for a pillion ride! You all know it, dont you??
          Last edited by Makky; 05-08-2010, 08:27 AM.

          Comment


          • Originally posted by rags View Post
            As for the rear foot rest I can't comment much on that because I have never been a pillion on the Apache except for this once when I was a pillion for about 500m in busy traffic.
            The rear pegs with their rubber removed, (i've R15's pegs) will make you put your feet off them once the bike will hit 7000RPM...

            Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
            Well i think this question is more apt at the What Bike thread. Anyways, comparing P220 with an RTR180 these are the pros and cons that they have:

            1. RTR180 is a better handler any given day. Period. If you want a more flickable bike which is fun to negotiate the traffic then RTR wont disappoint you. P220 takes a little more effort in this regard.
            2. RTR's initial pickup is equal (or better as some would say although by a very small margin) to that of P220. But i dont think you will be racing with a P220 if you buy an RTR or vice versa that these milliseconds would matter to you. But as the speed builds up, the 40cc extra obviously makes its presence felt and leaves the RTR behind. Having a better top end than RTR, the P220 engine is more relaxed at the same rpm than RTR which is good if you are into touring.
            3. Suspension wise, the RTR's suspension is made for the track and hence feels a little stiff on the bad patches of road. P220 DTSI's suspension has been stiffened after DTSFI but still its better on the bad patches and not as good as RTR on the track or even for that matter on the twisties.
            4. Looks are relative so i wont go into the debate of which bike looks better.
            5. Riding position of the RTR is more on the sportier side than the P220. But its only a matter of getting used to before you feel comfortable.
            6. Mileage is something plus minus 40kmph for the RTR, while the P220 DTSI has been known to give a variable mileage for different riders if you go through the P220 DTSI ownership thread.
            7. Vibrations are there in the RTR from 4k to around 5.5k which is the speed zone of 55 to 68. P220 on the other hand is almost vibe free till you cross the 6.5k rpm. Now since you will be driving in the city, the RTR's vibe zone will have to experienced more than often as thats the speed we generally ride in cities.
            8. Straight line stability of P220 is better compared to RTR.

            Now coming down to the reliability, both the companies are reliable in present times. But face it, whatever bike you buy here, you will be facing some or the other problems, be it minor or major. In my city the Bajaj Probiking is much better than the TVS SVC. I dont know about your city. Ask some owners in your city about the SVC.
            These were all the differences i could note about the two great bikes. See what you can bear with and what you cannot and then make your choice. Also others in this forum might add to the points i have mentioned. Take note of that too.
            Very well put together.

            Originally posted by Makky View Post
            Yesterday, I did a 300kms(to and fro) trip for Chris Pfeiffer's event. The bike was fantastic! Yes, vibrations are very much present between speeds of 55-68km/hr. But once past that, it is a bliss! I managed to touch 114km/hr on the East Coast Road connecting Pondicherry and Chennai! The tacho needle was dancing at 8000rpm. What a bike! I was screaming on top of my voice when I saw those figures on the speedo! The power delivery is super smooth. Every smallest wring on the throttle will bring a change on the speedo and the tacho.
            One hard truth...RTR is not the bike to be used for a pillion ride! You all know it, dont you??
            RTR is best when drriven alone, hell every bike is, the pillion robs the handling.
            The Magician"

            Comment


            • Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post
              RTR is best when driven alone, hell every bike is, the pillion robs the handling.
              Everything in fact! RTR's vibes, seating, suspension etc don't exactly make the pillion comfortable when compared with other top-end Indian bikes. The rider can forget all these since there are much more things he is interested in!!

              @theguitarfreak... Nice comparo! I guess you forgot these bro... its 21bhp v/s 17bhp and the build quality and finish...RTR is way ahead of P220!

              Comment


              • The all metal rear pegs have incresed the "massaging" abilities in my FI....FI was supposed to iron out some of the vibes but once past 6500 my pillion screams for mercy.

                And i've instruction from my better half to ride it below 4000RPM, and she even understood that what is the needle in the round thing is for and it should be below 4000 for her legs to be comfy...
                The Magician"

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Makky View Post
                  @theguitarfreak... Nice comparo! I guess you forgot these bro... its 21bhp v/s 17bhp and the build quality and finish...RTR is way ahead of P220!
                  Yes thats there too but I didnt go into any of the tech specs other than the cc. I guess the guy already knows that.
                  And regarding the build quality, i would have agreed with you if it was 2-3 years ago. But nowadays even Bajaj is looking into their build quality. Im not saying Bajaj has better build quality but the difference isnt by that great a margin now.

                  Oh and another thing, I have put the Zapper S back to my rear wheel. Was missing the grip it offered. Yes maybe the low speed stability has been hampered a little but the amount of grip that it offers when you try to hug the road, makes you forget everything else
                  Last edited by theguitarfreak; 05-08-2010, 11:26 AM.
                  You can only ride better tomorrow if you ride safe today.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
                    I have put the Zapper S back to my rear wheel. Was missing the grip it offered. Yes maybe the low speed stability has been hampered a little but the amount of grip that it offers when you try to hug the road, makes you forget everything else
                    Zapper S is the same one that R15's sports??????
                    The Magician"

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post
                      Zapper S is the same one that R15's sports??????
                      Yes it is the same.
                      You can only ride better tomorrow if you ride safe today.

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
                        Yes it is the same.
                        Cornering god it is.
                        But i really wish it to be available in 18" and 110 and 120 sizes.
                        The Magician"

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post
                          Cornering god it is.
                          But i really wish it to be available in 18" and 110 and 120 sizes.
                          But you have the option of michelin isnt it? Im not sure though.

                          And can someone tell me more about sprocketing? Im really into touring and would like to increase the top end so that at each rpm the bike attains more speed.
                          You can only ride better tomorrow if you ride safe today.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
                            But you have the option of michelin isnt it? Im not sure though.

                            And can someone tell me more about sprocketing? Im really into touring and would like to increase the top end so that at each rpm the bike attains more speed.
                            Shave of two tooths from the rear sproaket, you'll have better top speed at each gear at the cost of the acceleration, the bike will also run at lower RPM at the given speed compared to the previous sproaket.

                            But dont shave off more than two tooths as then it'll put dent on the acceleration.
                            The Magician"

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by rennycornelius View Post

                              But dont shave off more than two tooths as then it'll put dent on the acceleration.
                              Dent on Acceleration alongwith front sprockets will also needs tobe changed for copping up with loss at the rear.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by theguitarfreak View Post
                                Well i think this question is more apt at the What Bike thread. Anyways, comparing P220 with an RTR180 these are the pros and cons that they have:

                                1. RTR180 is a better handler any given day. Period. If you want a more flickable bike which is fun to negotiate the traffic then RTR wont disappoint you. P220 takes a little more effort in this regard.
                                2. RTR's initial pickup is equal (or better as some would say although by a very small margin) to that of P220. But i dont think you will be racing with a P220 if you buy an RTR or vice versa that these milliseconds would matter to you. But as the speed builds up, the 40cc extra obviously makes its presence felt and leaves the RTR behind. Having a better top end than RTR, the P220 engine is more relaxed at the same rpm than RTR which is good if you are into touring.
                                3. Suspension wise, the RTR's suspension is made for the track and hence feels a little stiff on the bad patches of road. P220 DTSI's suspension has been stiffened after DTSFI but still its better on the bad patches and not as good as RTR on the track or even for that matter on the twisties.
                                4. Looks are relative so i wont go into the debate of which bike looks better.
                                5. Riding position of the RTR is more on the sportier side than the P220. But its only a matter of getting used to before you feel comfortable.
                                6. Mileage is something plus minus 40kmph for the RTR, while the P220 DTSI has been known to give a variable mileage for different riders if you go through the P220 DTSI ownership thread.
                                7. Vibrations are there in the RTR from 4k to around 5.5k which is the speed zone of 55 to 68. P220 on the other hand is almost vibe free till you cross the 6.5k rpm. Now since you will be driving in the city, the RTR's vibe zone will have to experienced more than often as thats the speed we generally ride in cities.
                                8. Straight line stability of P220 is better compared to RTR.

                                Now coming down to the reliability, both the companies are reliable in present times. But face it, whatever bike you buy here, you will be facing some or the other problems, be it minor or major. In my city the Bajaj Probiking is much better than the TVS SVC. I dont know about your city. Ask some owners in your city about the SVC.
                                These were all the differences i could note about the two great bikes. See what you can bear with and what you cannot and then make your choice. Also others in this forum might add to the points i have mentioned. Take note of that too.

                                Nice information it will surely help me to take decision, but i did not got one thing how can a 17.3 PS bike with 177.4 CC displacment(Apache) have same pick up as that of 21.04 PS having 220 cc displacment(Pulsar).
                                I have heard that Apache sportier riding position can give you back pain, is it true?
                                And i am thinking of replacing the stock tyres of RTR 180 with P220 front and R15's rear Tyre.
                                Can u suggest me a Tyre with good grip having same size as that of stock one --- 110/80 - 17 other than R15 Zapper S which is 100/80 - 17.
                                When approaching a corner, stay on the gas until you see Jesus. Then brake HARD.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X